ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

CMT Cladding of Cr13 Stainless Steel with Surface High-Pressure Rolling: Microstructural and Property Evaluation

Literature Overview

The paper by Zhou Jianan, Zhang Guodong, Zheng Fei, Yang Hui, and Mei Qingsong from Wuhan University, published in the Journal of Mechanical Engineering (2017, Vol. 53, No. 8, pp. 68-74), investigates the effect of surface high-pressure rolling (SHPR) on the microstructure and properties of Cr13 stainless steel cladding layers produced by cold metal transfer (CMT) welding. The cladding was performed using ER309L filler wire (φ2.5 mm) on a Cr13 stainless steel substrate. The SHPR treatment was applied with a pressure of 12 kN for 15 minutes, using six rollers (GCr15, φ8 mm × 10 mm) arranged at equal angles, with a rotation speed of 2 r/min. The study evaluated the microstructure, hardness, wear resistance, and corrosion resistance of the treated and untreated cladding layers using optical microscopy (OM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), micro-hardness testing, friction-wear testing, and electrochemical testing.

Key Technical Points

CMT Welding Process

CMT is a modified MIG/MAG welding process that uses a controlled short-circuit transfer mode. It is characterized by low heat input, minimal spatter, and excellent control over the weld pool. This makes it particularly suitable for cladding applications where distortion and dilution must be minimized. The use of ER309L filler wire provides a corrosion-resistant austenitic stainless steel cladding layer on the Cr13 martensitic stainless steel base.

Surface High-Pressure Rolling (SHPR)

SHPR is a mechanical surface treatment that involves pressing a hardened roller against the workpiece surface with high pressure. This induces severe plastic deformation in the surface layer, resulting in grain refinement, increased dislocation density, and compressive residual stresses. The treatment is used to improve surface hardness, wear resistance, and fatigue life. In this study, the SHPR treatment was applied to the CMT cladding layer to address the inherent inhomogeneity of the as-welded microstructure.

Microstructural and Property Changes

The results show that after SHPR, the grains in the cladding layer are significantly refined, and a distinct high-pressure rolled layer and a transition layer are formed. The average micro-hardness of the high-pressure rolled layer is 403.62 HV, compared to 287.83 HV for the original cladding layer. This represents a 40% increase in hardness. The friction characteristics of the rolled layer are more stable, and the wear volume is reduced. However, the corrosion resistance of the rolled layer is degraded compared to the original cladding layer.

Practical Implications and Engineering Insights

Repair and Reconditioning of Cr13 Steel Components

Cr13 stainless steel is widely used for components that require both corrosion resistance and wear resistance, such as hydro-turbine runners, pump impellers, and valve bodies. In service, these components are subject to erosion, cavitation, and wear, which can lead to material loss and reduced performance. CMT cladding is an effective method for repairing damaged components, but the as-welded cladding layer often has poor surface quality and inhomogeneous properties. The application of SHPR after cladding can significantly improve the surface properties, making the repaired component more durable.

The Trade-Off Between Wear and Corrosion Resistance

The study reveals a critical trade-off: SHPR improves hardness and wear resistance but degrades corrosion resistance. This is a common issue with mechanical surface treatments that induce high levels of plastic deformation. The increased dislocation density and grain refinement can accelerate corrosion by providing more active sites for electrochemical reactions. In applications where both wear and corrosion resistance are required, this trade-off must be carefully considered. For example, in hydro-turbine runners, the primary degradation mechanism is erosion and cavitation, so the improved wear resistance may outweigh the reduced corrosion resistance. However, in a corrosive environment, the reduced corrosion resistance could lead to premature failure.

Process Optimization

The SHPR parameters—pressure, time, roller geometry, and rotation speed—must be optimized for each application. The study used a pressure of 12 kN for 15 minutes, which is a relatively severe treatment. Lower pressures or shorter times may result in less grain refinement but also less degradation of corrosion resistance. The roller material (GCr15) is a high-carbon chromium bearing steel, which provides high hardness and wear resistance. However, the rollers themselves must be maintained and replaced periodically to ensure consistent performance.

Key Questions and Reflections

What is the optimal SHPR treatment for CMT cladding layers?

The optimal treatment depends on the specific application requirements. If wear resistance is paramount, a more severe treatment may be beneficial. If corrosion resistance is critical, a milder treatment or a different surface treatment, such as shot peening with a softer media, may be more appropriate. The study provides a baseline, but further work is needed to establish a process window for different applications.

How does SHPR affect the residual stress state?

SHPR induces compressive residual stresses in the surface layer, which are beneficial for fatigue life and resistance to stress corrosion cracking. However, the study did not measure the residual stress distribution. This is an important area for future investigation, as the residual stress state will influence the performance of the component in service.

What are the limitations of SHPR for complex geometries?

SHPR is a line-of-sight process, meaning it can only be applied to surfaces that are accessible to the roller. For complex geometries, such as the internal surfaces of a pump casing or the blade surfaces of a turbine runner, SHPR may not be feasible. Alternative techniques, such as laser shock peening or ultrasonic surface rolling, may be more suitable for these applications.

Study Insights and Implications

This study provides valuable insights into the use of SHPR to improve the properties of CMT cladding layers. The significant increase in hardness and wear resistance is a clear benefit, but the degradation of corrosion resistance is a concern that must be addressed. The study highlights the importance of understanding the relationship between surface treatment and material properties, which is essential for developing effective repair and reconditioning strategies.

Reference Value and Outlook

The findings are directly applicable to the repair and reconditioning of Cr13 stainless steel components in the power generation, oil and gas, and marine industries. Future research should focus on optimizing the SHPR parameters for different applications, evaluating the long-term performance of treated surfaces in service, and investigating alternative surface treatment methods that can provide both improved wear resistance and corrosion resistance. The study also underscores the value of a multi-technique approach (OM, SEM, hardness testing, wear testing, and electrochemical testing) for comprehensive evaluation of surface treatments.