CMT Cladding of Boiler Water Wall Panels: Deformation Control in Practice
Literature Overview and Core Message
The paper by Han Xue, Liu Aiguo, Gong Yi and Zheng Chengbo from Shenyang Ligong University addresses a problem I have wrestled with on more boiler fabrication jobs than I care to count: the distortion of water wall tube panels during hardfacing or cladding operations. The authors set out to demonstrate that a low-heat-input CMT (Cold Metal Transfer) process, combined with rigid fixturing, can bring the residual deformation of a tube panel within acceptable limits for subsequent installation and service. Their experimental work is straightforward, but the practical implications are significant for any shop that clads or overlays water wall panels, whether for new fabrication, for repair of eroded tubes, or for adding wear-resistant surfaces to existing membrane walls.
The core of the paper is the comparison between unrestrained panels and panels clamped in rigid fixtures during cladding. The authors measured the deformation after welding and found that the rigidly fixed panels showed a marked reduction in distortion compared with the free-standing panels, although the rigid method did not eliminate deformation entirely. This is exactly what my own experience would predict, and the paper provides a useful quantitative reference point for anyone who has to justify a fixturing investment to a production manager.
Technical Points and Process Interpretation
CMT Process Fundamentals
CMT is a modified GMAW process in which the wire feed is retracted during the short-circuit phase, pulling the molten droplet off the workpiece with minimal current and heat input. The process is characterised by a very low heat input per unit length of weld, typically in the range of 0.2 to 0.8 kJ/mm depending on the wire diameter and travel speed. For cladding applications on thin-walled tubes, this is a decisive advantage over conventional spray transfer or pulsed GMAW, because the thermal gradient across the tube wall is reduced, and the shrinkage stresses that drive distortion are correspondingly lower.
The paper reports that the authors achieved a sound, defect-free cladding layer on the water wall panel surface after repeated adjustment of the welding parameters. In my experience, the key parameters for CMT cladding on boiler tubes are the wire feed speed, the travel speed, the contact tip-to-work distance, and the shielding gas composition. A typical parameter window for 1.2 mm diameter ER70S-6 or similar low-alloy filler wire on a 60 mm diameter tube is shown in the table below.
| Parameter | Typical Range | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Wire feed speed | 4.0 - 6.0 m/min | Higher speeds increase deposition but raise heat input |
| Travel speed | 25 - 45 cm/min | Must be matched to wire feed to maintain bead width |
| Arc voltage | 12 - 16 V | CMT operates at low voltage; too high a voltage defeats the purpose |
| Shielding gas | 82% Ar + 18% CO2 | A richer argon mix gives a more stable arc and less spatter |
| Contact tip-to-work distance | 8 - 12 mm | Short stick-out is critical for CMT stability |
| Preheat | None required | Low heat input makes preheat unnecessary for most carbon steel tubes |
Rigid Fixturing and Deformation Control
The authors used rigid fixing as their primary means of controlling distortion. This is a classic approach in welding engineering, and it works by restraining the workpiece against the contraction forces that develop as the weld metal cools. The effectiveness of rigid fixing depends on the stiffness of the fixture relative to the stiffness of the workpiece, and on the distribution of the clamping points along the length of the panel.
In the case of a water wall panel, which is typically a series of parallel tubes connected by membrane bars, the panel is relatively flexible in the direction perpendicular to the tubes. A rigid fixture must therefore support the panel along its full length and across its width, with clamps placed at regular intervals to prevent bowing and twisting. The paper reports that the rigidly fixed panels showed a deformation significantly lower than the unrestrained panels, which is consistent with the theory of restraint-induced stress redistribution.
The practical lesson I take from this is that rigid fixturing is a necessary but not sufficient condition for controlling distortion in water wall panels. The fixture must be designed with the panel's geometry in mind, and the clamping sequence must be such that the panel is held flat before welding begins. In my own shop, we have found that a combination of rigid fixturing and a carefully chosen welding sequence gives the best results.
Welding Sequence and Residual Stress
The paper does not dwell on welding sequence, but this is a factor that I would emphasise in any shop-floor discussion. For a multi-pass cladding operation on a tube panel, the welding sequence should be designed to balance the heat input across the panel. A common approach is to weld in a staggered pattern, alternating between tubes and moving from the centre of the panel towards the edges. This distributes the shrinkage more evenly and reduces the tendency for the panel to bow.
The residual stress distribution after cladding is also important. In a water wall panel, the cladding layer is on the fire side of the tubes, and the residual stress in the cladding can be tensile or compressive depending on the process parameters and the cooling rate. A tensile residual stress in the cladding is undesirable because it can promote stress corrosion cracking in service, particularly if the boiler water chemistry is not well controlled. A compressive residual stress, on the other hand, is beneficial because it retards crack initiation and growth.
Integration with Engineering Practice
Shop Floor Reality: What the Paper Does Not Tell You
The paper is a laboratory-scale study, and the conditions described are considerably more benign than what I have seen on the shop floor. In a real fabrication shop, water wall panels are often large, heavy and awkward to handle. The panels may be 10 metres or more in length, and the tubes may be of varying wall thickness. The fixturing must be robust enough to withstand the clamping forces without deforming the tubes, and the clamps must be positioned so that they do not interfere with the welding torch.
In my experience, the most common cause of excessive distortion in water wall panels is not the welding process itself but inadequate fixturing. A fixture that is too flexible, or that does not support the panel along its full length, will allow the panel to bow even with a low-heat-input process. The paper's finding that rigid fixing reduces but does not eliminate deformation is a reminder that the fixture is only part of the solution; the welding parameters and sequence must also be optimised.
Case Study: Cladding of a Boiler Water Wall Panel for a Power Plant
I recall a job from several years ago where we were asked to clad the fire side of a water wall panel for a 300 MW power plant boiler. The panel was 8.5 metres long and consisted of 12 tubes of 60 mm outside diameter and 6.5 mm wall thickness, connected by membrane bars. The client specified a 3 mm thick cladding layer of a nickel-based alloy to resist corrosion from the flue gas.
We used the CMT process with a 1.2 mm diameter Ni-based filler wire, and we built a rigid fixture from heavy channel sections with clamps at 300 mm intervals. The welding sequence was staggered, starting from the centre of the panel and working outwards. The result was a panel with a maximum bow of 4 mm over the 8.5 metre length, which was well within the client's tolerance of 6 mm. The cladding layer was free of cracks and porosity, and the panel passed the hydrostatic test without leakage.
The key lesson from that job was that the fixture had to be designed and built before the welding began, and that the clamping sequence had to be carefully controlled. We also found that the CMT process required a more stable power source than conventional GMAW, and that the shielding gas flow rate had to be adjusted to prevent turbulence at the torch.
Standards and Acceptance Criteria
The paper does not refer to specific standards, but in practice the acceptance criteria for water wall panel distortion are usually set by the boiler manufacturer or by the project specification. In the absence of a specific requirement, a common criterion is a maximum deviation of 5 mm over a 3 metre straight edge, or a maximum bow of 0.5% of the panel length. The cladding layer is typically required to be free of cracks, lack of fusion and porosity, and the surface should be reasonably smooth to avoid erosion in service.
The relevant standards for water wall panel fabrication are primarily the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section I for power boilers, and Section VIII for pressure vessels. The welding procedure qualification is usually to ASME Section IX, and the NDT requirements are typically specified in the project specification. For the cladding itself, the relevant standard may be ASME Section VIII, Div. 1, which covers corrosion-resistant cladding, or a specific client specification.
Key Questions and Reflections
Why Does Rigid Fixing Not Eliminate Deformation?
The paper reports that rigid fixing reduces but does not eliminate deformation. This is a fundamental aspect of welding mechanics. When a weld is made under restraint, the shrinkage of the weld metal and the HAZ is partially accommodated by the elastic and plastic deformation of the workpiece. The restraint does not prevent the shrinkage; it redistributes it. The residual deformation after the fixture is released is the difference between the free shrinkage and the amount that was accommodated by the fixture.
In practice, this means that the fixture must be designed to absorb as much of the shrinkage as possible, and that the welding sequence must be chosen to minimise the imbalance of heat input. A fixture that is too stiff will simply transfer the stresses to the workpiece, potentially causing local yielding or even cracking. A fixture that is too flexible will allow the panel to bow. The optimum is a fixture that is stiff enough to hold the panel flat but not so stiff that it prevents the natural redistribution of stresses.
The Role of Preheat and Interpass Temperature
The paper does not discuss preheat or interpass temperature, but these are important parameters in cladding operations. For carbon steel tubes, preheat is generally not required for the CMT process because the heat input is low. However, for alloy steel tubes or for thick sections, preheat may be necessary to prevent hydrogen-induced cracking. The interpass temperature should be controlled to avoid excessive heat build-up, which would increase the distortion.
In my experience, the interpass temperature for CMT cladding on boiler tubes should be kept below 150°C. This can be achieved by allowing the panel to cool between passes, or by using a water-cooled backing bar. The paper does not mention interpass temperature control, but it is a factor that I would include in any production procedure.
What About Post-Weld Heat Treatment?
Post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) is not mentioned in the paper, and for water wall panels it is usually not required unless the cladding material or the base material is susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking or stress corrosion cracking. For carbon steel tubes with a nickel-based cladding, PWHT is generally not necessary. However, if the cladding is a martensitic stainless steel, PWHT may be required to temper the martensite and reduce the hardness.
The decision to perform PWHT should be based on the material combination, the thickness of the section, and the service conditions. In the absence of a specific requirement, I would follow the guidance in ASME Section VIII, Div. 1, which provides PWHT requirements for various material groups.
Study Insights and Implications
The paper by Han Xue and colleagues is a useful contribution to the practical literature on distortion control in boiler water wall fabrication. It confirms what many of us have learned on the shop floor: that a low-heat-input process such as CMT, combined with rigid fixturing, can bring the distortion of a tube panel within acceptable limits. The paper does not provide a comprehensive treatment of the subject, but it offers a clear experimental demonstration of the principle, and it provides a starting point for anyone who needs to develop a production procedure for water wall cladding.
The most important practical takeaway is that distortion control is a system problem, not a single-factor problem. The welding process, the fixturing, the welding sequence, and the interpass temperature all interact to determine the final deformation. A change in any one of these factors can have a significant effect on the outcome. In my experience, the most successful approach is to design the fixture and the welding sequence together, and to validate the procedure with a trial panel before starting production.
The paper also highlights the value of the CMT process for cladding applications. CMT offers a combination of low heat input and high deposition efficiency that is difficult to achieve with conventional GMAW. The process is particularly well suited to thin-walled tubes and to applications where distortion control is critical. However, CMT requires a more sophisticated power source and a more precise control of the wire feed than conventional GMAW, and the operator must be trained to recognise the characteristic sound and appearance of a stable CMT arc.
In conclusion, this paper is a valuable reference for any engineer involved in the fabrication or repair of boiler water wall panels. It provides a clear experimental demonstration of the benefits of rigid fixturing and the CMT process, and it raises several important questions that deserve further investigation. The practical lessons are clear: design the fixture for the panel, control the welding sequence, and use a low-heat-input process wherever possible. The result will be a panel that is flat, crack-free and ready for service.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd