ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Double-Consumable Electrode TiC-VC Reinforced Wear-Resistant Surfacing

Introduction to the Novel Process

This paper introduces a new approach to synthesizing hard carbide particles in a surfacing layer. The authors use a double-consumable electrode welding rod, which is an interesting concept because it changes the arc characteristics and the metallurgical reactions compared to a conventional single-electrode process. The goal is to produce a Fe-based surfacing layer reinforced with TiC and VC ultra-hard particles.

The raw materials are ferro-titanium, ferro-vanadium and graphite, which are added to the coating of the electrode. During welding, these react in the arc to form carbides. The novelty is the double-consumable electrode configuration, where two consumable electrodes are used in a single arc, creating a unique thermal and chemical environment.

Metallurgical Analysis of the Surfacing Layer

The authors used X-ray diffraction, scanning electron microscopy and wear testing to characterize the layer. Their findings are quite revealing.

Phase Observation Interpretation
TiC Only small amounts detected Ti mainly acts as a deoxidizer, not as a carbide former
VC Main carbide reinforcement phase V has a stronger carbide-forming tendency under these conditions
(Ti,V)C Coexisting crystals on the matrix Solid solution carbides form in the remaining Ti-V system
Matrix Fe-based with dispersed carbides Hardness above 55 HRC

The most interesting result is that Ti, which is normally a strong carbide former, is consumed primarily as a deoxidizer in this process. This is a consequence of the special arc structure of the double-consumable electrode, which creates a highly oxidizing environment that favors Ti oxidation over TiC formation. The result is that the reinforcement is predominantly VC, with only minor TiC and some (Ti,V)C solid solution carbides.

Wear Resistance and Practical Implications

The wear test results are dramatic. The surfacing layer has a hardness above 55 HRC, and its weight loss in the wear test is only 1/16 of the Q235 base metal. This is a very high level of wear resistance, which makes the process attractive for applications such as mining equipment, crushing rolls, and other high-abrasion components.

From a practical standpoint, the key question is whether this process is reproducible and economical. The double-consumable electrode concept is interesting, but it requires a special electrode design and a welding machine that can feed two consumable electrodes simultaneously. This adds complexity to the welding operation.

Engineering Practice Considerations

In my experience, hardfacing with carbide-reinforced layers is a well-established technique, but the choice of carbide type and the process route depend heavily on the service conditions. VC is a very hard carbide, but it is also more brittle than some alternatives. For impact loading, a more ductile matrix with dispersed carbides is often better than a very hard but brittle layer.

The double-consumable electrode process appears to produce a layer with good hardness and wear resistance, but the practical challenge is the control of the arc and the consistency of the carbide distribution. In a production setting, you need to ensure that the carbide particles are uniformly distributed and that the layer is free from cracks and porosity.

Summary and Practical Takeaways

This paper demonstrates a novel approach to producing TiC-VC reinforced wear-resistant surfacing layers. The double-consumable electrode process creates a unique metallurgical environment that favors VC formation over TiC, and the resulting layer has excellent hardness and wear resistance. The practical value of this work lies in the potential for producing high-performance hardfacing layers with a relatively simple process. However, the transition from laboratory to production will require careful control of the welding parameters and the electrode composition, and the economics of the double-consumable electrode system must be compared with conventional hardfacing methods. I would recommend this process for applications where extreme wear resistance is required and where the brittleness of the layer can be tolerated.