ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Influence of Process Parameters on Strip Electroslag Cladding

Evolution and Comparison of Strip Cladding Processes

Strip cladding is a high-deposition welding process used to apply a corrosion-resistant or wear-resistant layer onto a base metal. The process uses a flat strip electrode instead of a round wire, which allows for a wider coverage per pass and a higher deposition rate. The two main variants are strip submerged arc welding (SAW) and strip electroslag welding (ESW). The paper by Zhang Liangcheng and Yin Heping from Shanghai Boiler Works provides a detailed comparison of these two processes and discusses the influence of process parameters on the quality of the ESW cladding.

In my experience, strip cladding is a critical process for the manufacture of pressure vessels and heat exchangers, particularly for the cladding of tube sheets and channel heads. The choice between SAW and ESW depends on the required quality and the thickness of the cladding. SAW is a more established process that offers good control over the weld bead shape and a low dilution rate. ESW, on the other hand, is a newer process that offers an even lower dilution rate and a higher deposition rate, but it requires more careful control of the process parameters. The paper correctly identifies that the fundamental difference between the two processes is the mechanism of heat transfer. In SAW, the arc is the primary heat source, and the weld pool is relatively shallow. In ESW, the heat is generated by the resistance of the molten slag, and the weld pool is deeper and wider, which results in a lower dilution rate.

Detailed Analysis of Process Parameters

The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the key process parameters for ESW, including welding voltage, welding current, welding speed, strip width, and flux composition. The authors point out that the welding voltage is the most critical parameter for controlling the width of the weld bead. A higher voltage leads to a wider bead, but it also increases the heat input and the dilution rate. The welding current determines the deposition rate and the penetration. A higher current increases the deposition rate but also increases the penetration, which can lead to a higher dilution rate. The welding speed affects the shape of the weld bead and the cooling rate. A higher speed reduces the heat input per unit length, which can lead to a narrower bead and a higher cooling rate.

The authors also discuss the importance of the flux composition. In ESW, the flux must have a high electrical conductivity to maintain the slag pool. The flux also determines the chemical composition of the weld metal, as it can react with the base metal and the strip electrode. The authors recommend a flux that is specifically designed for ESW, with a high basicity and a low viscosity. The paper also highlights the importance of the strip width and the gap between the strip and the base metal. A wider strip allows for a higher deposition rate, but it also increases the heat input. The gap between the strip and the base metal must be carefully controlled to ensure a stable slag pool and a uniform weld bead.

Practical Considerations and Defect Prevention

From a practical standpoint, the paper provides valuable guidance for the development of ESW cladding procedures. The key challenge is to achieve a low dilution rate while maintaining a good weld bead shape and a defect-free deposit. The authors recommend a welding voltage of 25 to 30 V, a welding current of 800 to 1200 A, and a welding speed of 10 to 20 cm/min. These parameters are typical for a 60 mm wide strip electrode. The paper also emphasizes the importance of preheating and interpass temperature control. A high preheat temperature can reduce the risk of cracking, but it also increases the heat input and the dilution rate. The authors recommend a preheat temperature of 100 to 150 °C for carbon steel and 150 to 200 °C for low-alloy steel.

The paper also discusses common defects in ESW cladding, including lack of fusion, slag inclusions, and porosity. Lack of fusion is often caused by an insufficient welding current or an incorrect gap between the strip and the base metal. Slag inclusions are typically caused by an unstable slag pool or a high welding speed. Porosity can be caused by moisture in the flux or by a high welding current that leads to a turbulent slag pool. The authors recommend a thorough inspection of the cladding using ultrasonic testing and dye penetrant testing to detect these defects.

In summary, this paper is a valuable reference for engineers who are involved in the development and qualification of strip cladding procedures. The comparison between SAW and ESW is particularly useful, as it helps to clarify the advantages and limitations of each process. The detailed analysis of the process parameters provides a solid foundation for the development of a robust ESW cladding procedure. In my experience, the key to a successful ESW cladding is to maintain a stable slag pool and to control the dilution rate. The paper provides the necessary guidance to achieve this. However, it is important to note that the optimal parameters may vary depending on the specific application and the equipment used. Therefore, a thorough procedure qualification is essential before the process is used in production.