ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

High-Temperature Wear Behaviour of Hardfacing on Continuous Casting Rolls - A Practical Review

Literature Overview and Core Message

This study by Cheng Jianguo and colleagues at Baowu Heavy Industry addresses a question I have wrestled with many times on the shop floor: what actually happens to a hardfaced roll surface when it is running hot, and why does the wear rate suddenly climb at a certain temperature? The authors tested a 414N hardfacing layer deposited on 42CrMo continuous casting roll steel at 400, 500 and 600 degrees Celsius, using a high-temperature wear tester, and then characterised the worn surfaces with SEM, EDX and XRD. The headline result is stark: average wear depth at 500 degrees Celsius is about 2.1 times that at 400 degrees Celsius, and at 600 degrees Celsius it reaches 2.5 times. For anyone who has ever watched a roll wear out prematurely in a hot mill, that is not a surprise, but the mechanism they identify is the real value of the paper.

Interpretation of Technical Points

The wear mechanism transition is the key insight. At 400 degrees Celsius, the 414N hardfacing layer wears by a combination of oxidative wear, abrasive wear from wear debris, and a small amount of oxide scale spalling. At 500 and 600 degrees Celsius, the abrasive component disappears and the mechanism shifts entirely to oxidative wear plus oxide scale spalling. The oxide scale itself is composed of three phases: alpha-prime Fe, cubic (Fe,Cr)2O3, and hexagonal (Fe,Cr)2O3. The critical change is that at temperatures of 500 degrees Celsius and above, the bright white oxides in the wear track are greatly reduced, and the chromium content in the dark oxides drops markedly. In plain language, the protective chromium-rich oxide layer that forms at lower temperatures breaks down, and the scale becomes less adherent and less protective. The authors conclude that the phase composition of the oxide scale and its chromium content are the decisive factors controlling the high-temperature wear mode and performance.

Connection with Manufacturing Practice

In my own experience with continuous casting rolls, and indeed with any hot-work roll in a pipe mill or a rolling stand, this chromium depletion mechanism explains a very common field failure mode. I have seen rolls that were hardfaced with a nominally high-chromium alloy perform beautifully for a campaign, then suddenly lose metal at an alarming rate when the roll surface temperature crept above a certain threshold due to a cooling water problem or an overload condition. The lesson is that the hardfacing alloy chemistry must be selected not just for room-temperature hardness, but for the ability to form and retain a stable, chromium-rich oxide scale at the actual operating temperature. A 414N type deposit is a reasonable choice for moderate temperatures, but if the roll is going to run at 500 degrees Celsius or above, the alloy needs more chromium, or a different alloy system altogether, such as a martensitic stainless type or a carbide-forming alloy with niobium or vanadium.

Key Questions and Reflections

A question that this paper raises but does not fully answer is how the hardfacing process itself influences the oxide scale behaviour. The dilution from the 42CrMo substrate will change the local chemistry of the first few millimetres of the deposit, and that dilution zone may behave differently from the bulk hardfacing. In practice, I always insist on a buttering layer before the final hardfacing pass, precisely to control dilution and to ensure that the wear-resistant surface has the intended chemistry. The paper also does not address the effect of thermal cycling, which in a real continuous casting roll is continuous and severe. A roll does not sit at a constant 500 degrees Celsius; it cycles between the hot strand and the cooling spray, and that thermal fatigue can accelerate oxide spalling in a way that a constant-temperature laboratory test cannot capture. I would therefore treat the reported wear ratios as a lower bound for what happens in service.

Study Insights and Implications

The practical takeaway for my own plant is straightforward: when we specify hardfacing for hot-work rolls, we must define the maximum expected surface temperature, and then require the hardfacing supplier to demonstrate, with test data, that the oxide scale remains chromium-rich and adherent at that temperature. I have had to reject hardfacing proposals that looked excellent on hardness alone but had no high-temperature wear data, and this paper gives me the technical justification for that position. It also reinforces the importance of controlling the roll surface temperature in operation, because once the scale breaks down, the wear rate accelerates so rapidly that the roll may be lost in a single shift. In summary, the paper is a valuable contribution to the practical understanding of hardfacing wear at elevated temperature, and it should be read alongside the actual operating conditions of the roll, not in isolation.