ATOX50 Mill Grinding Disc Hardfacing Repair and Its Application Effect
Literature Overview and Core Message
This paper by Li Chun and Wang Cun, from Guangdong Tapai Group and Beijing Sunwell Welding Technology, describes the hardfacing repair of an ATOX50 vertical mill grinding disc in a large cement plant in northern China. The ATOX50 is a large vertical roller mill used for grinding raw materials in cement production, and the grinding disc and grinding rollers are subjected to severe wear and impact from the working medium, which includes steel slag, sandstone, limestone and shale. The authors make a very important point at the outset: the original components were produced by melting and casting, and the casting process, limited by the state of the technology and by casting quality, cannot reliably produce the ideal chemical composition that the metallurgist designed. As a result, the wear resistance of the cast components is not as high as intended, and the service life is short, which seriously disrupts normal production.
Interpretation of Technical Points
The core technical argument is that hardfacing repair offers a way to apply a designed alloy composition to the wear surface, which is not possible with a conventional casting. The grinding disc, once it has worn, can be built up with a hardfacing alloy that is specifically formulated for the abrasive and impact conditions in the mill. The paper describes the repair procedure and the application effect, and the key point is that the hardfacing layer can be tailored to the actual wear mechanism, whether it is abrasive wear, impact wear, or a combination of the two. The authors also note that the hardfacing repair can be carried out in situ, which avoids the need to remove the grinding disc from the mill and transport it to a workshop, and this is a significant advantage in terms of downtime and cost.
Connection with Manufacturing Practice
This paper is directly relevant to my own experience with hardfacing repair of large components in the pipe and fitting industry. We use the same approach when we repair worn mill rolls, mandrels, and forming dies. The principle is identical: the component is too large or too expensive to replace, and the wear surface can be rebuilt with a hardfacing alloy that is better than the original casting. The practical challenge is always the same: how to prepare the worn surface, how to select the hardfacing alloy, and how to control the distortion and residual stress that arise from the repair welding. In the case of the ATOX50 grinding disc, the component is large and heavy, and the repair welding must be carefully sequenced to avoid cracking and distortion. I have seen large rolls crack during hardfacing repair because the preheat was inadequate or the interpass temperature was not controlled, and the same risk applies to a grinding disc.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper does not provide detailed mechanical test data for the repaired disc, and it would be useful to know the hardness and the impact toughness of the hardfacing layer, and how these properties compare with the original casting. In my experience, the hardfacing alloy must have not only high hardness but also sufficient toughness to withstand the impact loads in a grinding mill. A hardfacing layer that is too hard and too brittle will spall and crack, and the repair will fail prematurely. The paper also does not discuss the inspection methods used to verify the quality of the repair, such as ultrasonic testing or magnetic particle inspection, which are essential to detect lack of fusion and cracking in the hardfacing layer. I have always insisted on a full NDT examination of hardfaced components before they are returned to service, and I would expect the same for a grinding disc.
Study Insights and Implications
The practical lesson for my own plant is that hardfacing repair is a viable and often superior alternative to replacement, provided that the repair is properly engineered. The key factors are the selection of the hardfacing alloy, the preheat and interpass temperature control, the welding procedure, and the post-repair inspection. I have used hardfacing repair to extend the life of mill rolls and mandrels by a factor of two or three, and the cost saving is substantial. The paper also reinforces the importance of understanding the wear mechanism before selecting the hardfacing alloy. In a grinding mill, the wear is a combination of abrasive wear and impact wear, and the hardfacing alloy must be designed for both. In summary, this paper is a good practical example of hardfacing repair applied to a large industrial component, and it provides a useful reference for anyone considering a similar repair in their own plant.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd