Numerical Simulation of Temperature Field for Rail Surface Hardfacing
Literature Overview and Core Message
This paper by Yun Wentao, Li Xiaoyan, Sun Jiantong and Li Qingqing, from Beijing University of Technology and Tianjin Aerospace Long March Rocket Manufacturing, uses the finite element software SYSWELD to simulate the temperature field during hardfacing of the rail surface of a U71Mn steel rail. The authors studied the effect of three welding processes: preheating, post-heating, and preheating plus post-heating, on the cooling time t8/5, which is the time for the weld to cool from 800 degrees Celsius to 500 degrees Celsius. The t8/5 parameter is critical because it determines the microstructure of the heat-affected zone and the hardfacing layer, and hence the hardness and the susceptibility to cold cracking. The authors also examined the microstructure of the heat-affected zone and verified the simulation results with experiments. The results show that all three processes extend the t8/5, with the combination of preheating plus post-heating being the most effective, and post-heating being more effective than preheating alone. The preheating plus post-heating process is an effective measure to prevent the formation of hardened microstructures and cold cracking, and the simulation was used to determine a welding process that eliminates martensite formation, which was confirmed by the experimental results.
Interpretation of Technical Points
The significance of the t8/5 parameter cannot be overstated. For a high-carbon steel such as U71Mn, which has a carbon content of approximately 0.65 to 0.77 percent, the cooling rate after welding determines whether the heat-affected zone transforms to martensite, bainite, or a softer microstructure. Martensite is hard and brittle, and it is highly susceptible to hydrogen-induced cold cracking. The t8/5 must be long enough to allow the austenite to transform to a softer microstructure, but not so long that the heat-affected zone becomes excessively soft and loses its strength. The paper shows that preheating and post-heating both extend the t8/5, and that the combination of the two is the most effective. The reason is that preheating raises the initial temperature of the workpiece, which reduces the temperature gradient and slows the cooling rate, while post-heating maintains the temperature after welding, which further slows the cooling rate and allows the hydrogen to diffuse out of the weld.
Connection with Manufacturing Practice
This paper is directly relevant to the hardfacing of rails and other high-carbon steel components, but the principles apply equally to the repair welding of high-strength pipe and fittings. In my own experience, the repair welding of high-carbon steel pipe and fittings is one of the most challenging operations, because the risk of cold cracking is very high. The t8/5 parameter is the key to controlling the microstructure, and the use of preheating and post-heating is the standard approach. The paper confirms that preheating plus post-heating is the most effective combination, and this is consistent with my own practice. I have used preheating and post-heating on the repair welding of high-strength low-alloy steel pipe, and I have found that the combination of the two is essential to avoid cracking, particularly in thick-wall sections where the cooling rate is fast.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper does not address the effect of the hardfacing process parameters on the t8/5, such as the welding current, voltage, travel speed and the number of passes. In a multi-pass hardfacing operation, the heat input from subsequent passes will affect the cooling rate of the previous passes, and the t8/5 will vary through the thickness of the deposit. The paper also does not address the effect of the hardfacing alloy composition on the transformation behaviour, which will be different from that of the rail steel. The simulation is a valuable tool for determining the welding process parameters, but it must be validated with experimental data, and the paper does provide such validation. The practical implication is that the simulation can be used to optimise the welding process before it is applied in the field, which saves time and reduces the risk of cracking.
Study Insights and Implications
For my own welding operations, the practical lesson is that the control of the cooling time t8/5 is essential to prevent the formation of hardened microstructures and cold cracking in high-carbon and high-strength steels. The use of preheating and post-heating, either individually or in combination, is the most effective way to control the t8/5, and the combination of the two is the most robust. The numerical simulation approach described in this paper is a valuable tool for determining the optimal preheating and post-heating temperatures and the welding process parameters, and it can be used to develop a welding procedure that is both effective and efficient. I have used similar simulations to determine the preheat temperature for the repair welding of high-strength pipe, and the simulation has saved us from conducting extensive and expensive trial-and-error experiments. In summary, this paper provides a practical and well-validated approach to the control of the welding thermal cycle in hardfacing and repair welding, and it should be read by anyone involved in the welding of high-carbon and high-strength steels.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd