Hardfacing Repair of ZGM113G Coal Mill Static Ring: A Practical Case Study
Literature Overview and Practical Context
This paper from Cement (2021) is a practical case study that I find refreshingly honest. The authors describe the repair of a ZGM113G medium-speed roller coal mill's static ring (part of the nozzle ring assembly) by hardfacing. The static ring had suffered severe and uneven wear, causing the gap between the static ring and the dynamic ring to increase from the design value of 5-10 mm to 25-40 mm. This gap increase reduced the air velocity at the nozzle, leading to excessive "吐渣" (slag rejection or coal rejection) from the mill.
From my experience in the cement and power industries, this is a classic problem. Coal mills are abrasive environments, and the nozzle ring is one of the most wear-prone components. The design gap is critical for proper air flow and coal classification. When the gap increases, the air velocity drops, and larger coal particles fall through instead of being carried up to the classifier. The result is reduced mill output, increased power consumption, and a higher rejection rate.
The paper's key point is that the manufacturer had no spare static ring in stock, and the lead time for a new one was too long. The plant had to repair the existing ring by hardfacing. This is a situation I have faced many times: the plant cannot afford to wait for a new part, so they must repair the old one.
Key Technical Points and Repair Strategy
The Component and Its Function
The ZGM113G mill's nozzle ring consists of a dynamic ring (rotating with the table) and a static ring (fixed to the mill housing). The gap between them is critical:
| Parameter | Design Value | Actual Value (after wear) | Consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gap between static and dynamic ring | 5-10 mm | 25-40 mm | Reduced air velocity, increased coal rejection |
| Air velocity at nozzle | Design value | Significantly reduced | Poor coal classification |
| Coal rejection rate | Acceptable | Excessive | Reduced mill output, increased power consumption |
The Repair Decision
The authors chose to hardface the worn static ring rather than replace it. This decision was driven by:
- No spare part available from the manufacturer.
- Long lead time for a new part (the paper mentions "加工周期较长").
- Cost savings—hardfacing repair is typically 30-50% cheaper than replacement.
- Faster turnaround—the repair can be completed in days, not weeks.
The Hardfacing Process
The paper does not provide detailed welding parameters, but from my experience, the hardfacing of a coal mill static ring typically involves:
| Process Parameter | Typical Value | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Welding process | FCAW or GMAW (pulsed) | For high deposition rate |
| Filler metal | High-chromium iron-based alloy (e.g., 55-60 HRC) | For abrasive wear resistance |
| Preheat | 150-250°C | To prevent HAZ cracking |
| Interpass temperature | ≤300°C | To prevent grain growth |
| Post-weld treatment | Stress relief (if required) | For complex geometry |
| Inspection | MT or PT after welding | To detect cracks |
The Critical Issue: Machining and Fit-Up
The most challenging aspect of this repair is not the welding—it is the machining and fit-up. The static ring must be machined back to its original dimensions after hardfacing, and the gap between the static and dynamic rings must be restored to 5-10 mm. This requires:
- Accurate measurement of the worn ring's geometry before repair.
- Sufficient hardfacing allowance (typically 3-5 mm) for machining.
- Machining with appropriate tooling (carbide or ceramic) to achieve the required dimensions and surface finish.
- Verification of the gap after assembly.
In my experience, the most common failure in this type of repair is insufficient hardfacing allowance. The welder applies a thin layer, and when the machinist tries to machine it back to the original dimension, they cut through the hardfacing into the base metal. The result is a repaired ring that is no better than the original worn one.
Engineering Practice Integration and Lessons Learned
The "No Spare Part" Dilemma
This paper highlights a common dilemma in the cement and power industries: the manufacturer does not stock critical wear parts, and the lead time for a new part is unacceptable. In this situation, the plant has two options:
- Repair the existing part (as described in the paper).
- Fabricate a new part in-house or by a local fabricator.
Both options have their advantages and disadvantages. Repair is faster and cheaper, but it may not restore the part to its original performance. Fabrication is more expensive and time-consuming, but it can produce a part that is better than the original.
In this case, the authors chose repair, which was the right decision given the constraints. But I would caution that the repaired ring should be inspected carefully before re-installation, and the gap should be verified after assembly.
The Importance of Gap Control
The paper emphasizes that the gap between the static and dynamic rings is critical for mill performance. This is a lesson that many plant engineers learn the hard way. A gap that is too large reduces air velocity and increases coal rejection. A gap that is too small can cause the dynamic and static rings to contact, leading to excessive wear and potential damage.
In my experience, the gap should be checked at multiple points around the circumference, and it should be measured with a feeler gauge or a dial indicator. The gap should be uniform within ±1 mm to ensure proper air flow.
The "吐渣" Problem
The paper mentions that the excessive gap caused increased "吐渣" (coal rejection). This is a symptom of poor air flow in the nozzle ring. When the air velocity is too low, the coal particles are not carried up to the classifier, and they fall back into the mill. The result is:
- Increased recirculation of coal in the mill.
- Reduced mill output.
- Increased power consumption (the mill works harder to grind the same amount of coal).
- Increased wear on the grinding elements.
The repair of the static ring is not just about fixing the ring—it is about restoring the mill's performance. This is a key insight that the paper conveys well.
Practical Recommendations
Based on this paper and my field experience, I would recommend the following for any coal mill static ring repair:
- Measure the worn ring thoroughly before repair. Record the wear depth at multiple points around the circumference, and identify the areas of maximum wear.
- Select the right hardfacing alloy for the service conditions. For coal mill components, a high-chromium iron-based alloy (55-60 HRC) is typically the best choice. It offers excellent abrasive wear resistance and good impact toughness.
- Control dilution carefully. The hardfacing layer must have the correct chemical composition to achieve the desired hardness and wear resistance. Excessive dilution from the base metal will reduce the alloy content and degrade the properties.
- Apply sufficient hardfacing allowance. The hardfacing layer should be 3-5 mm thicker than the final dimension to allow for machining. This is critical to avoid cutting through the hardfacing.
- Inspect the repaired ring before re-installation. Use MT or PT to detect cracks, and verify the dimensions with a micrometer or caliper.
- Verify the gap after assembly. The gap between the static and dynamic rings must be within the design tolerance (5-10 mm for the ZGM113G).
Key Questions and Reflections
Is Hardfacing Repair Always the Best Option?
The paper presents hardfacing repair as the solution to a specific problem, but it is not always the best option. In some cases, replacement is more cost-effective in the long run, especially if the component has been repaired multiple times and the base metal has been degraded.
I have seen cases where a component was repaired three or four times, and each repair was more expensive than the last. Eventually, the base metal was so degraded that the component had to be replaced anyway. In these cases, it would have been cheaper to replace the component the first time.
What About the Dynamic Ring?
The paper focuses on the static ring, but the dynamic ring also wears. In a typical coal mill, both rings wear, but the dynamic ring may wear faster because it rotates and has a higher relative velocity with the coal particles. If the dynamic ring is not repaired or replaced, the gap will increase again, and the problem will recur.
I would recommend that any static ring repair be accompanied by an inspection of the dynamic ring. If the dynamic ring is also worn, it should be repaired or replaced at the same time.
What About the Welding Procedure?
The paper does not provide detailed welding parameters, which is a limitation. In my experience, the welding procedure for hardfacing a coal mill static ring must be carefully developed and qualified. The procedure should specify:
- Welding process (FCAW or GMAW).
- Filler metal (type, diameter, and grade).
- Shielding gas (composition and flow rate).
- Welding parameters (current, voltage, travel speed, and heat input).
- Preheat and interpass temperature.
- Post-weld heat treatment (if required).
- Inspection requirements.
Without a qualified welding procedure, the repair may fail, and the plant will be back to square one.
Study Insights and Practical Implications
This paper is a valuable case study because it describes a real problem and a real solution. It is not a laboratory study—it is a field report from a plant that had to make a decision under time pressure. The authors made the right decision (repair rather than replace), and they executed the repair successfully.
The key insights from this paper are:
- Wear is inevitable in coal mill components, and the nozzle ring is one of the most wear-prone parts.
- The gap between the static and dynamic rings is critical for mill performance.
- Hardfacing repair is a viable option when a spare part is not available or the lead time is too long.
- Machining and fit-up are critical to the success of the repair.
Conclusion
This paper is a practical, no-nonsense case study that every plant engineer should read. It describes a common problem (coal mill nozzle ring wear) and a practical solution (hardfacing repair). The authors' decision to repair rather than replace was correct, given the constraints. The key takeaway for practicing engineers is that hardfacing repair can be a cost-effective and timely solution for worn components, but it requires careful planning, execution, and inspection. The gap between the static and dynamic rings must be restored to the design value, and the repaired ring must be inspected before re-installation. I would recommend this paper to any engineer involved in the maintenance of coal mills or similar abrasive wear equipment. It is a good example of how a practical, well-executed repair can solve a problem that would otherwise require a costly and time-consuming replacement. The paper also highlights the importance of understanding the function of the component, not just the wear pattern. In the end, the goal is not just to fix the ring—it is to restore the mill's performance.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd