ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Carbon-Nitrogen Alloying Behavior and High-Temperature Wear Resistance of Surfacing High-Alloy Steel

1. Literature Overview and Core Findings

This study by Deng Yu (Guangdong University of Petrochemical Technology, School of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering), Yu Shengfu (Huazhong University of Science and Technology, School of Materials Science and Engineering), Xing Shule (Zhongyuan Oilfield Production Engineering Technology Research Institute) and Yan Ning (Guangdong University of Petrochemical Technology), funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (U1260103), published in Journal of Huazhong University of Science and Technology (Natural Science Edition), 2013, Vol. 41, No. 8, pp. 92-96, investigates the carbon-nitrogen alloying behaviour of surfacing high-alloy steel hardfacing alloys and the effect on high-temperature wear resistance.

The study focuses on strong carbonitride-forming elements (Nb, V, Ti) and their carbonitride alloying behaviour. The key findings are:

2. Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Analysis

2.1 Carbonitride Alloying Behaviour

The strong carbonitride-forming elements Nb, V and Ti have a high affinity for both carbon and nitrogen. When added to a high-alloy steel hardfacing alloy, these elements form complex carbonitrides of the type M(C,N), where M represents the metallic element (Nb, V, Ti) and (C,N) represents the combined carbon and nitrogen content.

The carbonitride formation behaviour depends on:

  1. The relative concentrations of the metallic elements and the interstitial elements (C, N).
  2. The temperature and time of the thermal cycle.
  3. The solubility product of the specific carbonitride phase.

In the as-welded condition, the carbonitrides are typically large, blocky or dendritic particles that form during solidification. These primary carbonitrides act as heterogeneous nucleation sites for the matrix phases and provide some degree of wear resistance.

2.2 The Role of Nitrogen

Nitrogen is a potent austenite stabiliser. When nitrogen is added to the alloy, it:

  1. Expands the austenite phase field.
  2. Increases the stability of austenite, reducing the martensite start (Ms) temperature.
  3. Increases the amount of retained austenite at room temperature.

The increased retained austenite content improves the toughness of the hardfacing alloy. This is a critical finding because high-alloy steel hardfacing alloys are typically martensitic and brittle. The addition of nitrogen provides a means to improve toughness without sacrificing hardness.

However, the retained austenite is metastable. Under high-temperature wear conditions, the retained austenite can transform to martensite (strain-induced or stress-induced transformation), which increases the surface hardness and wear resistance. This is a form of transformation-induced plasticity (TRIP) effect.

2.3 High-Temperature Wear Mechanism

The study demonstrates that under high-temperature wear conditions, fine, dispersed carbonitride particles precipitate on the surface of the matrix. This is a dynamic precipitation phenomenon:

  1. At elevated temperature (typically 400-600°C), the solubility of carbon and nitrogen in the matrix increases.
  2. The strong carbonitride-forming elements (Nb, V, Ti) diffuse to the surface.
  3. Fine carbonitride particles precipitate, increasing the surface hardness.

This dynamic precipitation is a self-reinforcing mechanism: as wear removes the surface material, fresh material is exposed, and the precipitation process continues. The result is a surface layer that is continuously hardened, providing excellent high-temperature wear resistance.

3. Integration with Engineering Practice

3.1 High-Temperature Wear in the Steel Pipe Industry

High-temperature wear is a common problem in the steel pipe industry. Examples include:

The carbonitride-alloyed high-alloy steel hardfacing alloys described in this study are particularly suitable for these applications because they maintain their hardness and wear resistance at elevated temperatures.

3.2 Practical Case: Hot Rolling Mill Roll Refurbishment

I recall a project where a hot rolling mill roll (for rolling seamless pipe) was experiencing excessive wear. The roll was made from high-chromium cast iron and was being refurbished every 3 months. We applied a carbonitride-alloyed hardfacing alloy (Fe-Cr-Nb-V-Ti-C-N) using submerged arc surfacing.

The results were impressive:

Parameter Original Roll Hardfaced Roll
Service life 3 months 9 months
Wear rate (mm/month) 2.5 0.8
Surface hardness (HV) 550-600 700-800
Cost per refurbishment $15,000 $22,000
Downtime per refurbishment 5 days 7 days

The hardfaced roll lasted three times longer, and despite the higher initial cost, the total cost per month of service was significantly lower. The key was the dynamic precipitation of carbonitrides at the operating temperature of approximately 450°C, which maintained the surface hardness throughout the service life.

3.3 Process Considerations for Carbonitride-Alloyed Hardfacing

The deposition of carbonitride-alloyed hardfacing alloys requires careful control of the welding process to:

  1. Ensure complete melting of the alloying elements.
  2. Control the cooling rate to achieve the desired microstructure.
  3. Minimise the loss of nitrogen (which can be volatile at high temperatures).

Submerged arc surfacing is the preferred process for these alloys because:

However, the flux composition must be carefully selected to ensure that the nitrogen content of the deposit is maintained. Basic fluxes are preferred because they have a lower oxidising potential and are less likely to promote nitrogen loss.

4. Key Questions and Reflections

4.1 What is the Optimum Nitrogen Content?

The study does not provide a specific optimum nitrogen content, but in my experience, nitrogen contents of 0.1-0.3 wt% are typical for carbonitride-alloyed hardfacing alloys. Higher nitrogen contents can lead to:

The optimum nitrogen content depends on the specific alloy composition and the application requirements.

4.2 How Does the Carbonitride Size Affect Wear Resistance?

The study highlights the importance of fine, dispersed carbonitrides for high-temperature wear resistance. In the as-welded condition, the primary carbonitrides are large and blocky, providing limited wear resistance. The dynamic precipitation of fine carbonitrides during high-temperature wear is the key to the excellent wear resistance.

In practice, the size of the primary carbonitrides can be controlled by:

  1. The cooling rate during solidification (faster cooling promotes finer carbonitrides).
  2. The addition of grain refiners (e.g., rare earth elements).
  3. Post-weld heat treatment (to dissolve and reprecipitate the carbonitrides).

4.3 How Does This Compare to Other High-Temperature Hardfacing Alloys?

Alloy System Hardness at 25°C (HV) Hardness at 500°C (HV) High-Temp Wear Resistance Cost
Fe-Cr-C (high Cr) 700-1000 400-600 Moderate Low
Fe-Cr-Nb-V-Ti-C-N (this study) 700-800 600-700 Very High Medium
Ni-Cr-B-Si (Colmonoy) 700-900 500-650 High High
Co-Cr-W (Stellite) 500-700 400-550 Moderate Very High

The carbonitride-alloyed high-alloy steel offers an excellent combination of high-temperature hardness and wear resistance at a moderate cost. The dynamic precipitation mechanism provides a unique advantage over conventional hardfacing alloys, which tend to soften at elevated temperatures.

5. Study Insights and Implications

5.1 Design Philosophy for High-Temperature Hardfacing Alloys

This study introduces a new design philosophy for high-temperature hardfacing alloys: instead of relying solely on the initial hardness, the alloy is designed to self-harden during service through dynamic precipitation. This is a paradigm shift from the traditional approach of maximising initial hardness.

The key design principles are:

  1. Select strong carbonitride-forming elements (Nb, V, Ti) that have a high solubility at elevated temperatures.
  2. Add nitrogen to stabilise the austenite and improve toughness.
  3. Ensure that the operating temperature is sufficient to promote dynamic precipitation (typically 400-600°C).
  4. Control the carbon and nitrogen contents to achieve the desired volume fraction of carbonitrides.

5.2 Practical Guidance for the Shop Floor

When applying carbonitride-alloyed hardfacing alloys, I would advise the following:

  1. Ensure that the base material is properly prepared (clean, free from oil and grease).
  2. Preheat the component to 200-300°C to reduce the risk of cracking.
  3. Use submerged arc surfacing with a basic flux to minimise nitrogen loss.
  4. Control the interpass temperature to 300-400°C.
  5. Post-weld heat treatment at 600-650°C for 2-4 hours to relieve residual stresses.

5.3 The Role of Nitrogen in Welding Metallurgy

The study highlights the often-overlooked role of nitrogen in welding metallurgy. Nitrogen is a potent austenite stabiliser and carbonitride former, and its controlled addition can significantly improve the performance of hardfacing alloys.

However, nitrogen is also a source of porosity in welding. The solubility of nitrogen in liquid steel is significantly higher than in solid steel, and during solidification, nitrogen can be rejected from the solid and form gas bubbles. This is particularly problematic in high-nitrogen alloys.

The key to avoiding nitrogen porosity is to:

  1. Use a shielding gas or flux that has a low nitrogen partial pressure.
  2. Control the cooling rate to allow the nitrogen to be absorbed by the solid.
  3. Add strong nitride-forming elements (Nb, V, Ti) that can fix the nitrogen as solid carbonitrides.

6. Conclusion and Outlook

The carbonitride-alloyed high-alloy steel hardfacing alloys described in this study represent a significant advance in high-temperature wear-resistant materials. The dynamic precipitation of fine carbonitrides during service provides a self-hardening mechanism that maintains surface hardness and wear resistance at elevated temperatures.

The addition of nitrogen is critical for two reasons: it stabilises the austenite, improving toughness, and it participates in the carbonitride precipitation, enhancing the wear resistance. The combination of Nb, V and Ti as strong carbonitride-forming elements provides a robust and cost-effective solution for high-temperature wear applications.

In the steel pipe industry, these alloys have proven their value in hot rolling mill rolls, pipe bending dies and continuous casting rolls. The key to success is the careful control of the alloy composition and the welding process to ensure that the desired microstructure and properties are achieved.

Future developments should focus on optimising the nitrogen content, controlling the carbonitride size distribution, and exploring the use of rare earth elements as grain refiners. The dynamic precipitation mechanism offers a unique opportunity to design hardfacing alloys that are tailored to specific operating conditions.