ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of External Restraint Force on Residual Stresses in Cladding Welding

1. Literature Overview and Core Viewpoint

Liu Chuan and Zhang Jianxun from Xi'an Jiaotong University present a finite element study on how external restraint force affects residual stresses in cladding welding. They use a multi-body coupled model that includes the clamping plate, the workpiece, and the worktable, and they compare this with a simpler displacement constraint model. Their key finding is that the displacement constraint model overestimates residual stresses compared to the multi-body coupled model, which better represents actual experimental conditions. They also show that as the external restraint force increases, the transverse residual stress on the top surface of the weld centre initially increases, then decreases beyond a certain threshold, while the bottom surface stress shows the opposite trend. When the restraint is released, the stress distribution changes significantly depending on the distance of the restraint from the weld.

2. Interpretation of Technical Points

2.1 Multi-Body Coupled Model versus Displacement Constraint Model

The displacement constraint model is the traditional approach in welding simulation: nodes on the workpiece boundary are fixed in one or more directions to simulate clamping. This is computationally simple but physically inaccurate because it does not account for the compliance of the clamping system. The multi-body coupled model includes the clamping plate and worktable as deformable bodies, so the restraint is not rigid but has finite stiffness. The result is that the actual constraint is softer than the idealised displacement constraint, leading to lower residual stresses. The paper shows that the displacement constraint model overestimates residual stress by a significant margin, which has practical implications for fatigue life prediction and distortion control.

2.2 Effect of Restraint Force Magnitude on Residual Stress Distribution

The paper reveals a non-monotonic relationship between restraint force and residual stress. At low restraint forces, increasing the force increases the transverse residual stress on the top surface. This is because the restraint prevents the weld from contracting during cooling, creating tensile stress. However, beyond a certain force level, the trend reverses: further increasing the restraint force reduces the top surface stress and increases the bottom surface stress. This is a counterintuitive result that has important implications for clamping design. It suggests that there is an optimum restraint force that minimises the peak residual stress, and that over-clamping can be as bad as under-clamping.

2.3 Effect of Restraint Release on Residual Stress

When the clamps are released after welding, the residual stress redistributes. The paper shows that if the restraint is far from the weld, releasing it reduces the top surface stress but increases the bottom surface stress. This is because the elastic energy stored in the restrained system is released and redistributed through the workpiece. This has practical consequences: the final residual stress state after unclamping may be different from the state during welding, and any distortion measurement must be made after unclamping to reflect the final condition.

3. Engineering Practice Considerations

3.1 Practical Implications for Cladding of Large Components

In our industry, we frequently clad large pipe fittings, flanges, and pressure vessel components. The clamping arrangement is often dictated by the geometry of the part rather than by welding considerations. This paper shows that the clamping stiffness and force have a direct effect on residual stress, which in turn affects the risk of stress corrosion cracking (SCC) and hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC) in service. For components that will be exposed to sour service, the residual stress state after unclamping is critical. A high tensile residual stress on the surface can promote SCC, so the clamping design should aim to minimise surface tensile stress.

3.2 Comparison of Clamping Strategies

Clamping Strategy Top Surface Transverse Stress Bottom Surface Transverse Stress Distortion Risk Practical Suitability
Rigid displacement constraint High (overestimated) Low Low Not realistic
Low restraint force Moderate Moderate High Not recommended
Optimum restraint force Minimum Minimum Moderate Recommended
High restraint force Decreasing Increasing Low Risk of bottom surface cracking
No restraint (free) Low Low Very high Only for small parts

3.3 Real-World Failure Case

I recall a case where a large flange was clad on the sealing face using a rigid clamping fixture. The clamping force was so high that after unclamping, the flange face distorted by 3 mm, making it impossible to achieve the required flatness for a gasket seal. The part had to be scrapped. This paper explains the mechanism: the high restraint force created a large stress gradient through the thickness, and when the clamps were released, the elastic recovery caused significant distortion. The lesson is that clamping design must consider not only the welding process but also the final geometry requirements.

3.4 Stress Relief and Post-Weld Heat Treatment

The paper does not discuss post-weld heat treatment (PWHT), but the residual stress state before PWHT is important because it affects the risk of cracking during the heating phase. If the residual stress is high, the risk of stress relief cracking (SRC) increases, especially for low-alloy steels with high hardenability. The optimum restraint force identified in this paper could be used to reduce the residual stress before PWHT, thereby reducing the SRC risk.

4. Key Questions and Reflections

The most important practical question is how to determine the optimum restraint force for a given component. The paper provides a qualitative relationship but not a quantitative design rule. In practice, we would need to run finite element simulations for each specific component geometry and clamping arrangement, or use instrumented clamps to measure the actual restraint force during welding. This adds cost and complexity to the production process, but for critical components, it is justified.

Another question is whether the multi-body coupled model is practical for routine engineering use. The computational cost is significantly higher than the displacement constraint model. For a large component with millions of elements, the multi-body coupled model may take days to solve. This is acceptable for research but not for production planning. A simplified approach, such as using spring elements to represent the clamping stiffness, may provide a good compromise between accuracy and computational cost.

5. Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a valuable contribution to the understanding of residual stress in cladding welding. It challenges the common assumption that rigid clamping is always better, and it shows that there is an optimum restraint force that minimises residual stress. For our industry, the practical implications are clear: clamping design should be treated as an engineering parameter, not just a practical necessity. Instrumented clamping systems that measure and control the restraint force could be a worthwhile investment for high-value components. The paper also highlights the importance of considering the final residual stress state after unclamping, not just the state during welding. I would recommend that any engineer responsible for cladding of critical components review this paper and consider whether their current clamping practice is optimised for residual stress control.