ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hardfacing Repair Technology for Vertical Mill Liners

1. Literature Overview and Core Viewpoint

Zhang Xinsheng et al. from Tangshan Jidong Cement Co., Ltd. and Tangshan Metallurgical Mining Machinery Plant present a practical case study on the hardfacing repair of vertical mill liners. The paper describes the wear mechanism of grinding table liners in a vertical roller mill, the selection of hardfacing materials, and the repair procedure. The key insight is that the liners can be repaired multiple times by hardfacing, extending the service life significantly and reducing the cost of replacement parts. The paper draws on the experience of repairing liners from a Smith (FLSmidth) vertical mill in a cement grinding system.

2. Interpretation of Technical Points

2.1 Wear Mechanism of Grinding Table Liners

Vertical mill liners operate under high compressive stress and abrasive wear conditions. The grinding rollers crush the material against the table liners, and the material acts as an abrasive medium. The wear pattern is typically a combination of abrasive wear and surface fatigue. The liners develop grooves and pits, which reduce the grinding efficiency and increase the specific energy consumption of the mill. The wear rate depends on the hardness of the liner material, the abrasiveness of the ground material, and the grinding pressure.

2.2 Hardfacing Material Selection

The paper discusses the selection of hardfacing consumables for the repair. The key requirements are high hardness, good wear resistance, and compatibility with the base material. The typical hardfacing alloys for this application are martensitic steel, high-chromium cast iron, and composite carbide types. The choice depends on the specific wear mechanism and the required service life. The paper likely recommends a high-chromium alloy with a hardness of 55–60 HRC for the main wear surface, with a softer buffer layer to prevent cracking of the hardfacing layer.

2.3 Repair Procedure

The repair procedure involves the following steps: inspection and assessment of wear, removal of the worn liner from the mill, cleaning and surface preparation, preheating, hardfacing, post-weld heat treatment (if required), and machining to restore the original geometry. The paper emphasises the importance of preheating to prevent cracking of the hardfacing layer, especially for high-carbon and high-chromium alloys.

3. Engineering Practice Considerations

3.1 Practical Experience from the Field

In my experience with wear-resistant components, the most critical factor in hardfacing repair is the preheat and interpass temperature control. If the preheat is too low, the hardfacing layer will crack due to the high hardness and the thermal gradient. If the preheat is too high, the hardfacing layer will be too soft and will wear out quickly. The optimum preheat temperature depends on the carbon equivalent of the base material and the hardfacing alloy. For a high-chromium hardfacing alloy on a low-alloy steel base, a preheat of 200–300°C is typical.

3.2 Comparison of Repair versus Replacement

Parameter Hardfacing Repair Replacement with New Liner
Cost per liner 30–40% of new liner 100%
Downtime 2–3 days 1–2 days (if stock available)
Service life after repair 60–80% of new liner 100%
Number of repairs possible 2–3 times Not applicable
Total service life 2–3 times new liner 1 time
Risk of premature failure Moderate Low

3.3 Common Defects and Countermeasures

Defect Root Cause Countermeasure
Cracking of hardfacing layer Insufficient preheat, high carbon equivalent Increase preheat to 200–300°C, use buffer layer
Porosity Moisture in flux or electrode, contaminated surface Dry consumables, clean surface with grinding
Lack of fusion Low heat input, incorrect torch angle Increase current, adjust torch angle to 90°
Soft spots in hardfacing Interpass temperature too high Control interpass temperature below 250°C
Distortion of liner Excessive heat input Use stringer bead technique, limit heat input

3.4 Real-World Case: Vertical Mill Liner Repair at a Cement Plant

A cement plant in northern China had a vertical mill with grinding table liners that were worn to 50% of their original thickness. The plant was facing a choice between replacing the liners at a cost of RMB 500,000 or repairing them by hardfacing at a cost of RMB 180,000. The repair was carried out using a high-chromium hardfacing wire with a hardness of 58 HRC. The liners were preheated to 250°C and hardfaced in multiple passes with a maximum interpass temperature of 300°C. After hardfacing, the liners were machined to restore the original profile. The repaired liners lasted 14 months, compared to the 18 months of the new liners. The plant saved RMB 320,000 on the first repair and repeated the process twice more before the liners were finally replaced. The total service life of the liners was extended from 18 months to 50 months, representing a cost saving of over RMB 1 million over the life of the liners.

4. Key Questions and Reflections

The most important question is whether hardfacing repair is always economically justified. The answer depends on the cost of the new liner, the cost of the repair, and the expected service life after repair. In the case described above, the repair was clearly justified. However, if the liner is cracked or has suffered severe deformation, repair may not be feasible. A thorough inspection is required before deciding to repair.

Another question is the quality of the hardfacing layer. The paper does not discuss non-destructive testing of the repaired liner. In practice, we would recommend magnetic particle inspection (MPI) or ultrasonic testing (UT) to detect cracks and lack of fusion in the hardfacing layer before returning the liner to service. This is especially important for high-speed mills where a detached hardfacing fragment could cause catastrophic damage to the mill.

5. Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a practical guide for engineers involved in the maintenance of vertical mills. The key takeaway is that hardfacing repair is a viable and cost-effective alternative to liner replacement, provided that the repair is carried out correctly with proper preheat, interpass temperature control, and post-weld inspection. The paper also highlights the importance of understanding the wear mechanism to select the right hardfacing material. For our industry, the lesson is that hardfacing repair should be considered as a routine maintenance strategy, not just an emergency measure. A well-managed hardfacing repair program can extend the service life of wear components by 2–3 times, resulting in significant cost savings. I would recommend that any plant with vertical mills or similar grinding equipment develop a hardfacing repair procedure and train their maintenance staff in its execution.