Research on Hardfacing Repair Technology for Crusher Hammers
1. Literature Overview and Core Viewpoint
Chen Jiabin and Yang Feng from Xuzhou Zhonglian Cement Co., Ltd. and Xuzhou Institute of Technology present a study on the hardfacing repair of crusher hammers. The paper describes the wear mechanism of hammers in a hammer crusher, which are subjected to high-impact and high-stress abrasive wear. The hammers are consumable parts that wear out rapidly, and the paper proposes a hardfacing repair process to extend their service life. The key issue is that hammers not only wear but also sometimes break, causing unplanned downtime and production losses.
2. Interpretation of Technical Points
2.1 Wear Mechanism of Crusher Hammers
Crusher hammers operate at high rotational speed and impact the falling material with high kinetic energy. The wear mechanism is a combination of impact wear, abrasive wear, and surface fatigue. The hammer surface experiences high compressive stress at the point of impact, which causes plastic deformation and material removal. The wear pattern is typically uneven, with the leading edge wearing faster than the trailing edge. The hammer also experiences high bending stress during impact, which can lead to fatigue cracking and eventual breakage.
2.2 Hardfacing Material Selection
The paper likely discusses the selection of hardfacing consumables for hammer repair. The key requirements are high impact resistance, high hardness, and good weldability. The typical hardfacing alloys for this application are austenitic manganese steel (Hadfield steel) for impact resistance, martensitic steel for abrasive wear resistance, and composite carbide types for extreme abrasion. The choice depends on the specific wear mechanism and the impact energy. For high-impact conditions, austenitic manganese steel is preferred because it work-hardens under impact. For abrasive wear without high impact, martensitic steel or composite carbide is more suitable.
2.3 Repair Procedure
The repair procedure involves the following steps: inspection of the hammer, removal of worn material, surface preparation, preheating (if required), hardfacing, and post-weld treatment. The paper emphasises the importance of controlling the heat input to prevent distortion and cracking. The hammers are typically repaired by depositing hardfacing material on the worn surface in multiple passes, with the weld bead orientation perpendicular to the direction of material flow.
3. Engineering Practice Considerations
3.1 Practical Experience from the Field
In my experience with crusher hammers, the most critical factor is the balance of the rotor after repair. If the hammers are not repaired symmetrically, the rotor will be unbalanced, causing excessive vibration and bearing wear. This is a common problem that is often overlooked. The repair must be carried out on all hammers in the set, or the repaired hammers must be paired with new hammers of the same weight. The paper does not discuss this issue, but it is critical for the practical success of the repair.
3.2 Comparison of Repair Strategies
| Strategy | Advantages | Disadvantages | Best Suitability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hardfacing repair | Low cost, extends life | Requires skilled welder, risk of cracking | Moderate wear, no cracks |
| Full replacement | High cost, no risk | Expensive, downtime for replacement | Severe wear or cracking |
| Hardfacing + rebalancing | Low cost, good performance | Requires balancing equipment | All repair cases |
| Use of composite hammers | Long life, high cost | Very expensive | High-abrasion applications |
3.3 Common Defects and Countermeasures
| Defect | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Cracking of hammer body | High carbon equivalent, insufficient preheat | Preheat to 150–200°C, use low-hydrogen electrodes |
| Distortion of hammer | Excessive heat input | Use stringer bead technique, limit heat input |
| Porosity | Contaminated surface, moisture | Clean surface, dry electrodes |
| Lack of fusion | Low current, incorrect angle | Increase current, adjust torch angle |
| Unbalanced rotor | Asymmetric repair | Repair all hammers, weigh and balance |
3.4 Real-World Case: Hammer Repair at a Cement Plant
A cement plant in Jiangsu Province had a hammer crusher with 12 hammers. The hammers were wearing at a rate of 5 mm per week, and the plant was replacing them every 6 weeks at a cost of RMB 8,000 per set. The plant decided to try hardfacing repair. The worn hammers were removed, cleaned, and inspected. The wear depth was 15 mm on the leading edge. The hammers were preheated to 180°C and hardfaced using a martensitic steel electrode with a hardness of 55 HRC. After hardfacing, the hammers were ground to the original profile and weighed. The total repair cost was RMB 2,500 per set, including labour and consumables. The repaired hammers lasted 8 weeks, which was 33% longer than the new hammers. The plant saved RMB 5,500 per repair cycle and reduced downtime by 2 hours per repair. The plant now repairs the hammers on a regular schedule, extending the total service life from 6 weeks to 14 weeks per set.
4. Key Questions and Reflections
The most important question is whether hardfacing repair is safe for high-speed crushers. If a repaired hammer fails during operation, the broken piece could damage the crusher housing or cause a fire. The repair must be inspected carefully before returning to service. We would recommend magnetic particle inspection (MPI) or ultrasonic testing (UT) to detect cracks in the hardfacing layer and the heat-affected zone (HAZ). The paper does not discuss this, but it is essential for safety.
Another question is the economic threshold for repair versus replacement. The decision depends on the cost of the new hammer, the cost of the repair, the expected service life after repair, and the downtime cost. In the case described above, the repair was clearly justified. However, if the hammer is cracked or has lost more than 50% of its original weight, repair may not be feasible.
5. Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a practical guide for engineers involved in the maintenance of hammer crushers. The key takeaway is that hardfacing repair is a viable and cost-effective alternative to hammer replacement, provided that the repair is carried out correctly and the rotor is balanced after repair. The paper also highlights the importance of understanding the wear mechanism to select the right hardfacing material. For our industry, the lesson is that hardfacing repair should be integrated into the maintenance schedule, not used as an emergency measure. A well-managed hardfacing repair program can extend the service life of crusher hammers by 2–3 times, resulting in significant cost savings and reduced downtime. I would recommend that any plant with hammer crushers develop a hardfacing repair procedure and train their maintenance staff in its execution, including rotor balancing.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd