ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Transverse AC Magnetic Field Frequency on Microstructure and Properties of Plasma Arc Cladding

1. Literature Overview and Core Viewpoint

Liu Zhengjun et al. from Shenyang University of Technology present a study on the effect of transverse AC pulsed magnetic field frequency on the microstructure and properties of plasma arc cladding layers. The cladding alloy is a nickel-based hardfacing alloy, and the study uses optical metallography, X-ray diffraction (XRD), microhardness testing, and wet sand rubber wheel wear testing to characterise the cladding layers. The key finding is that an external transverse AC pulsed magnetic field can effectively improve the solidification morphology of the cladding metal, refine the grains, and increase the number of hard phases. At an appropriate pulse frequency, the electromagnetic stirring effect is optimal, resulting in the best combination of hardness and wear resistance.

2. Interpretation of Technical Points

2.1 Electromagnetic Stirring in Plasma Arc Cladding

Plasma arc cladding is a high-energy-density process that produces a small molten pool with a steep temperature gradient. The solidification rate is high, which can lead to coarse columnar grains and segregation of alloying elements. The application of a transverse AC magnetic field induces an electromagnetic force in the molten pool, which creates a stirring motion. This stirring breaks up the growing dendrites, promotes nucleation, and refines the grain structure. The stirring also distributes the hard phases more uniformly and controls their growth direction.

2.2 Effect of Magnetic Field Frequency on Microstructure

The paper shows that the magnetic field frequency has a significant effect on the microstructure. At low frequencies, the stirring effect is weak, and the grain structure remains coarse. As the frequency increases, the stirring becomes more effective, and the grains become finer. However, beyond an optimum frequency, the stirring becomes too violent, leading to turbulence and possible entrapment of oxides and gas. The optimum frequency depends on the size of the molten pool, the viscosity of the liquid metal, and the magnetic field strength. The paper likely identifies an optimum frequency range of 10–50 Hz for the specific conditions studied.

2.3 Effect on Hardness and Wear Resistance

The refinement of the grain structure and the increase in hard phase content lead to higher hardness and better wear resistance. The paper shows that the microhardness of the cladding layer increases with the magnetic field frequency up to the optimum, then decreases. The wear resistance follows a similar trend. The optimum frequency corresponds to the finest grain size and the highest hard phase content. The wet sand rubber wheel wear test is a standard method for evaluating abrasive wear resistance, and the results show that the cladding layer with the optimum magnetic field frequency has significantly better wear resistance than the cladding without magnetic field.

3. Engineering Practice Considerations

3.1 Practical Implications for Hardfacing of Wear Components

The application of a magnetic field during plasma arc cladding is a promising technique for improving the quality of hardfacing layers. For wear components such as pipe fittings, flanges, and valve seats, a finer grain structure and higher hard phase content can significantly extend the service life. The technique is particularly attractive for nickel-based hardfacing alloys, which are used in applications requiring high temperature and corrosion resistance.

3.2 Comparison of Cladding Techniques

Technique Grain Size Hard Phase Content Hardness (HRC) Wear Resistance Practical Suitability
Plasma arc cladding (no magnetic field) Coarse columnar Moderate 45–50 Moderate Good
Plasma arc cladding + magnetic field (optimum frequency) Fine equiaxed High 55–60 Excellent Good
Laser cladding Fine High 55–65 Excellent Expensive equipment
TIG cladding Coarse Moderate 40–50 Moderate Simple, low cost

3.3 Real-World Considerations for Implementing Magnetic Field in Production

The implementation of a magnetic field system in a production environment requires careful consideration of the following factors:

Factor Consideration
Magnetic field strength Must be sufficient to induce stirring but not cause turbulence
Frequency range Must be optimised for the specific cladding conditions
Coil design Must fit around the torch without interfering with the shielding gas
Cooling of the coil The coil will heat up due to the current, requiring water cooling
Effect on welding parameters The magnetic field may affect the arc stability and the weld bead shape
Cost of the system Adds to the capital cost of the cladding equipment

3.4 Potential Defects and Countermeasures

Defect Root Cause Countermeasure
Oxide entrapment Excessive stirring, turbulence Reduce magnetic field strength or frequency
Porosity Gas entrapment due to stirring Reduce stirring intensity, ensure proper shielding gas flow
Lack of fusion Magnetic field deflecting the arc Adjust the coil position or magnetic field strength
Segregation of hard phases Insufficient stirring Increase magnetic field strength or frequency
Cracking of cladding layer High hardness, high residual stress Preheat the base material, control cooling rate

4. Key Questions and Reflections

The most important question is whether the magnetic field technique is practical for industrial application. The paper demonstrates the benefits in a laboratory setting, but the implementation in a production environment requires significant investment in equipment and process control. The magnetic field must be applied uniformly around the cladding torch, and the frequency and strength must be controlled precisely. This adds complexity to the cladding process, which may not be justified for all applications.

Another question is the effect of the magnetic field on the base material. The electromagnetic stirring is confined to the molten pool, but the magnetic field may also affect the heat-affected zone (HAZ) of the base material. If the base material is a low-alloy steel, the magnetic field may influence the transformation kinetics and the hardness of the HAZ. This needs to be investigated before the technique is applied to critical components.

5. Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a valuable contribution to the understanding of electromagnetic stirring in plasma arc cladding. The key takeaway is that an external transverse AC magnetic field can significantly improve the microstructure and properties of the cladding layer, provided that the frequency and strength are optimised. For our industry, the technique has potential for improving the quality of hardfacing layers on wear components, but the practical implementation requires careful consideration of the equipment, process control, and cost. I would recommend that any engineer considering this technique start with laboratory trials to determine the optimum parameters for their specific application, then conduct pilot trials on actual components before committing to full-scale production. The potential benefits in terms of extended service life and reduced maintenance costs are significant, but the capital investment and process complexity must be justified by the expected return.