ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Tube Sheet Cladding: Welding Operation and Deformation Control

1. Overview of the Study

This paper by Kong Bianli and Zhou Lixin, published in Welding (2010, No. 10), addresses the practical challenges of cladding austenitic stainless steel corrosion-resistant layers on 16MnR tube sheets for heat exchangers in a coal chemical project. The study focuses on welding operation techniques and deformation control, which are critical for achieving the required quality and dimensional accuracy.

The project involved 12 tube sheets with a design requirement for cladding the 16MnR base material with an austenitic stainless steel corrosion-resistant layer. The design required 100% penetrant testing (PT) of the cladding layer to meet Level I requirements of JB/T 4730.5-2005, and the cladding layer chemical composition had to comply with austenitic stainless steel standards.

2. Key Technical Requirements

The following table summarizes the critical technical requirements for the tube sheet cladding:

Parameter Requirement
Base material 16MnR (low-alloy steel, equivalent to P355GH)
Cladding material Austenitic stainless steel (e.g., 309L, 316L)
Cladding method Surface cladding (likely strip cladding or wire cladding)
Inspection 100% penetrant testing (PT) to Level I per JB/T 4730.5-2005
Chemical composition Must comply with austenitic stainless steel standards
Deformation control Critical for tube sheet flatness and dimensional accuracy
Number of tube sheets 12

3. Welding Operation Techniques

The paper emphasizes several key welding operation techniques for successful tube sheet cladding:

  1. Preheating. Preheating of the 16MnR base material is necessary to prevent hydrogen-induced cracking, particularly for thick sections. The preheat temperature should be determined based on the carbon equivalent and section thickness, typically in the range of 100-150°C.
  2. Welding sequence. The cladding should be performed in a controlled sequence to minimize distortion. This typically involves alternating weld passes on opposite sides of the tube sheet, or using a back-step technique.
  3. Interpass temperature control. Maintaining the interpass temperature below a specified maximum (typically 150-200°C for austenitic stainless steel) is essential to prevent excessive grain growth and distortion.
  4. Welding parameters. The welding current, voltage, and travel speed must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired deposit thickness and dilution. For strip cladding, the strip width and thickness are also critical parameters.
  5. Dilution control. The dilution of the cladding layer by the base material must be minimized to ensure the corrosion resistance of the deposit. This is typically achieved by using a low heat input and a high deposition rate.

4. Deformation Control Strategies

Deformation control is one of the most challenging aspects of tube sheet cladding. The following strategies are commonly employed:

Strategy Description
Symmetrical welding sequence Alternating weld passes on opposite sides of the tube sheet
Back-step technique Welding in segments, with each segment starting from the center and progressing outward
Clamping and fixturing Rigid clamping of the tube sheet to a fixture to resist distortion
Controlled interpass temperature Limiting the maximum interpass temperature to reduce thermal gradients
Post-weld stress relief Heat treatment to relieve residual stresses and reduce distortion
Mechanical straightening Cold or hot straightening after welding, if necessary

The paper emphasizes that the welding operation and deformation control are interrelated. A well-planned welding sequence can minimize distortion, while poor welding practice can lead to significant deformation that is difficult to correct.

5. Quality Control and Inspection

The following quality control measures are critical for tube sheet cladding:

Inspection Method Acceptance Criteria
Visual inspection No cracks, porosity, slag inclusions, or lack of fusion
Penetrant testing (PT) 100% of cladding surface, Level I per JB/T 4730.5-2005
Ultrasonic testing (UT) No lack of fusion or delamination at the cladding/base interface
Chemical analysis Cladding composition within specified limits
Hardness testing Consistent hardness across the cladding layer
Dimensional inspection Flatness and thickness within specified tolerances

6. Engineering Practice Considerations

From my experience with heat exchanger fabrication, the following practical lessons are worth highlighting:

  1. Planning is the foundation of quality. A detailed welding procedure specification (WPS) and welding procedure qualification record (WPQR) are essential. The welding sequence, parameters, and inspection requirements must be clearly defined before work begins.
  2. Deformation control starts with the welding sequence. The most effective way to control distortion is to plan the welding sequence carefully. Symmetrical welding and back-step techniques are proven methods for minimizing distortion in large, flat components.
  3. Interpass temperature is often underestimated. Many shops focus on preheat but neglect interpass temperature control. Excessive interpass temperature can lead to grain growth, reduced corrosion resistance, and increased distortion.
  4. Fixturing is critical but not sufficient. Clamping can help resist distortion, but it cannot overcome the effects of poor welding sequence or excessive heat input. The welding operation must be optimized in conjunction with fixturing.
  5. Penetrant testing is a necessary but not sufficient inspection. While PT can detect surface defects, it cannot detect lack of fusion or delamination at the cladding/base interface. UT should be performed in addition to PT for critical applications.

7. Study Insights and Practical Implications

This study highlights several important lessons for engineers involved in tube sheet cladding:

8. Conclusion

The study by Kong Bianli and Zhou Lixin provides practical guidance on tube sheet cladding, emphasizing the importance of welding operation techniques and deformation control. The successful cladding of 12 tube sheets for a coal chemical project demonstrates that with careful planning, proper welding sequence, and rigorous quality control, high-quality cladding can be achieved. For engineers in the heat exchanger and pressure vessel industry, this work serves as a valuable reference for developing effective cladding procedures and controlling distortion in large, flat components.