Comparative Study of 304L Stainless Steel Sealing Cladding in Air and Underwater Environments
1. Overview of the Study
This paper by Zhao Youliang, Zhu Jialei, Zhao Xiaoxin, Zhang Renxiang, Zhao Zhibo, Li Guixin, and Zhao Liang, published in China Surface Engineering (2024, Vol. 37, No. 4), investigates the comparative performance of 304L stainless steel sealing cladding prepared in air and underwater environments. The study is motivated by the need for underwater welding repair of nuclear spent fuel pools, where corrosion-induced cracks and holes can develop during long-term service.
The study uses ER-2209 duplex stainless steel solid wire to prepare sealing cladding layers on 304L stainless steel in both air and underwater environments. The research examines the macroscopic morphology, microstructure, phase composition, mechanical properties, microhardness, and corrosion resistance of the cladding layers.
2. Key Technical Parameters and Test Conditions
The following table summarizes the critical parameters and results:
| Parameter | Air Environment | Underwater Environment |
|---|---|---|
| Base material | 304L stainless steel | 304L stainless steel |
| Filler wire | ER-2209 duplex stainless steel | ER-2209 duplex stainless steel |
| Cladding layer morphology | Continuous, uniform, no defects | Continuous, uniform, no defects |
| Microstructure | Duplex stainless steel + austenitic stainless steel | Duplex stainless steel + austenitic stainless steel |
| Tensile strength | Higher than base material | Higher than base material |
| Elongation | Higher than cladding layer | Higher than cladding layer |
| Microhardness | Lower | Higher (due to faster cooling) |
| Corrosion resistance | Good, with passive region | Good, with passive region |
| Texture intensity | Increased at weld junctions | Increased at weld junctions |
3. Microstructural Analysis
The study reveals that the cladding layer microstructure consists of both duplex stainless steel and austenitic stainless steel regions, with regional distribution. The duplex stainless steel structure contains δ-ferrite and γ-austenite phases, while the austenitic stainless steel structure contains γ-austenite and possibly some δ-ferrite.
In the underwater environment, the faster cooling rate promotes the following microstructural changes:
- Suppression of δ → γ transformation. The fast cooling inhibits the transformation of δ-ferrite to γ-austenite, resulting in larger δ-ferrite grains.
- Formation of lath-like ferrite. The fast cooling promotes the formation of lath-like ferrite along austenite grain boundaries in the austenitic stainless steel regions.
- Increased hardness. The presence of larger δ-ferrite grains with higher stacking fault energy increases the hardness of the duplex stainless steel regions. The lath-like ferrite in the austenitic regions also increases hardness.
4. Mechanical Properties and Corrosion Resistance
The mechanical properties and corrosion resistance of the cladding layers are summarized below:
| Property | Air Environment | Underwater Environment |
|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength | Higher than base material | Higher than base material |
| Elongation | Lower than base material | Lower than base material |
| Microhardness | Baseline | Higher |
| Polarization curve | Clear passive region | Clear passive region |
| Corrosion resistance | Good | Good |
The tensile strength of the cladding layers is higher than that of the base material, which is attributed to the presence of duplex stainless steel with its higher strength. However, the elongation is lower than that of the base material, indicating reduced ductility.
The polarization curves show clear passive regions, indicating good corrosion resistance in both environments. The passive region is attributed to the formation of a protective chromium oxide film on the surface.
5. Engineering Practice Considerations
From my experience with underwater welding and repair operations, the following practical points are critical:
- Underwater welding is fundamentally different from air welding. The water environment affects the cooling rate, arc stability, and weld pool behavior. These differences must be accounted for in the welding procedure.
- Cooling rate is the dominant factor. The faster cooling rate in underwater welding significantly affects the microstructure and properties of the cladding layer. This must be considered in the design of the welding procedure.
- The choice of filler wire is critical. ER-2209 duplex stainless steel wire provides good corrosion resistance and mechanical properties, but the welding parameters must be optimized for the specific environment.
- Defect formation is a major concern. Underwater welding is more prone to porosity, lack of fusion, and other defects due to the water environment. Rigorous inspection is essential.
- Qualification testing is essential. Before underwater welding repair, the welding procedure must be qualified in the actual environment to ensure that the required quality can be achieved.
6. Comparison of Air and Underwater Welding
The following table compares the key characteristics of air and underwater welding:
| Parameter | Air Welding | Underwater Welding |
|---|---|---|
| Cooling rate | Moderate | Fast |
| Arc stability | Good | Reduced |
| Weld pool behavior | Stable | Unstable |
| Defect susceptibility | Lower | Higher |
| Microstructure | Balanced | Coarser δ-ferrite, lath-like ferrite |
| Hardness | Baseline | Higher |
| Corrosion resistance | Good | Good |
7. Study Insights and Practical Implications
This study provides several important lessons for engineers involved in underwater welding and repair:
- The cooling rate is the dominant factor in determining the microstructure and properties of the cladding layer. The faster cooling in underwater welding promotes the formation of larger δ-ferrite grains and lath-like ferrite, which increase hardness but may reduce ductility.
- The choice of filler wire is critical for achieving the desired properties. ER-2209 duplex stainless steel wire provides good corrosion resistance and mechanical properties, but the welding parameters must be optimized for the specific environment.
- The corrosion resistance of the cladding layer is good in both environments. The passive region observed in the polarization curves indicates that the cladding layer can provide adequate corrosion protection.
- The mechanical properties of the cladding layer are acceptable. The tensile strength is higher than that of the base material, although the elongation is lower. This is consistent with the presence of duplex stainless steel.
8. Conclusion
The study by Zhao Youliang et al. provides valuable insights into the comparative performance of 304L stainless steel sealing cladding prepared in air and underwater environments. The key finding is that the faster cooling rate in underwater welding promotes the formation of larger δ-ferrite grains and lath-like ferrite, which increase hardness but may reduce ductility. The cladding layers exhibit good corrosion resistance in both environments, with clear passive regions in the polarization curves. For engineers involved in underwater welding repair of nuclear spent fuel pools and other critical applications, this work serves as a valuable reference for developing effective welding procedures and understanding the effects of the environment on cladding quality.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd