Steam Turbine Casing Split Face Repair: Cold Welding with Nickel-Based Filler
Literature Overview and Core Findings
The paper by Jin Yongqiang from Zhanjiang Power Generation Co., Ltd. describes a practical repair of the high-pressure and intermediate-pressure outer casing split face of a steam turbine during the 1999 major overhaul of Unit 1. The repair was necessitated by deformation of the split face, which caused steam leakage.
The repair strategy was a cold welding approach using:
- Manual tungsten inert gas (TIG) welding
- Nickel-based filler wire
- Low-temperature preheating before welding
- Peening of the weld after each pass
This approach was chosen to address three critical issues: weldability, stress, and deformation. The casing is a large, complex casting, and any welding operation introduces residual stress and distortion. The cold welding approach minimizes heat input, reduces distortion, and allows the weld to be peened to relieve residual stress.
Technical Analysis of the Cold Welding Approach
| Process Element | Specification | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Welding process | Manual TIG (GTAW) | Precise heat control, low heat input |
| Filler wire | Nickel-based | Compatible with cast steel, good weldability |
| Preheat temperature | Low (150–200°C) | Reduce thermal gradient, minimize distortion |
| Post-weld treatment | Peening after each pass | Relieve residual stress, reduce distortion |
| Interpass temperature | Controlled | Prevent overheating, maintain low heat input |
The choice of nickel-based filler wire is critical. Nickel-based alloys have good compatibility with cast steel, and they have a coefficient of thermal expansion that is intermediate between the base metal and the weld. This reduces the thermal stress during cooling. Nickel-based fillers also have excellent resistance to hydrogen cracking, which is a concern in thick-section castings.
The low-temperature preheating is a deliberate departure from conventional practice. For thick-section castings, preheating to 200–300°C is often recommended. However, in this case, the repair was on a split face, which is a machined surface. High preheat temperatures would cause distortion and loss of dimensional accuracy. The low preheat temperature, combined with peening, achieves the same stress relief without the distortion.
Integration with Repair Practice and Lessons Learned
This case study is a textbook example of how to repair large, complex castings without causing further damage. The key lessons are:
- Weldability assessment is essential. The casing material is a Cr-Mo-V cast steel, which has a high carbon equivalent and is susceptible to hydrogen cracking. The nickel-based filler mitigates this risk by providing a ductile weld metal that can accommodate hydrogen.
- Heat input control is paramount. The manual TIG process allows precise control of heat input, which is critical for minimizing distortion. The operator must maintain a consistent travel speed and arc length.
- Peening is an effective stress relief method. Peening the weld after each pass introduces compressive residual stress, which counteracts the tensile stress from welding. This is particularly effective for thin-section repairs where post-weld heat treatment is not feasible.
- Dimensional control is critical. The split face is a machined surface, and any distortion would cause steam leakage. The repair must maintain the flatness and parallelism of the split face within tight tolerances.
In my experience, this type of repair is common in power plants, and the approach described in the paper is sound. However, there are some practical considerations that the paper does not fully address:
- Weld metal chemistry. The nickel-based filler must be compatible with the base metal. If the base metal has a high carbon content, carbon migration can occur, leading to brittle phases at the interface.
- Post-weld inspection. The repair should be inspected using ultrasonic testing (UT) or radiography (RT) to ensure that there are no cracks or lack of fusion.
- Surface preparation. The split face must be cleaned and machined before welding. Any oil, grease, or rust will cause porosity and lack of fusion.
Key Questions and Reflections
One question that arises is whether the repair was permanent. The paper describes the repair as successful, but it does not provide long-term follow-up data. In my experience, this type of repair can last for many years if properly executed. However, the casing is subject to thermal cycling during operation, which can cause fatigue cracking in the repair area.
Another question is whether the cold welding approach could be improved. For example, a buttering layer of nickel-based alloy could be applied to the split face before the final weld. This would provide a more uniform transition and reduce the risk of carbon migration. However, this would increase the repair time and cost.
The use of peening is a classic technique, but it requires skill and consistency. Over-peening can cause work hardening and microcracking. The operator must be trained and qualified for this specific application.
Study Insights and Implications
This case study provides valuable practical guidance for repair welding of large castings. The cold welding approach with nickel-based filler and peening is a proven method that minimizes distortion and residual stress. The key takeaways are:
- Assess weldability before starting the repair.
- Choose a filler wire that is compatible with the base metal.
- Use low heat input and controlled interpass temperature.
- Peen the weld to relieve residual stress.
- Inspect the repair thoroughly after welding.
- Monitor the repair during subsequent overhauls.
For the pipe and fitting industry, this approach is directly applicable to the repair of large valves, pump casings, and other cast components. The same principles of low heat input, compatible filler, and stress relief apply.
In conclusion, this paper is a valuable case study that demonstrates the practical application of cold welding techniques for repair of large castings. The approach is sound, and the lessons learned are directly transferable to other repair scenarios. The key is to balance the need for weldability, stress relief, and dimensional control.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd