Improvement of Heat Treatment Process for Hardfaced Rolls: An Orthogonal Experimental Approach
Literature Overview
This work by Zhao Hui from Shenyang Institute of Technology addresses the heat treatment process for a 1550 support roll that is repaired by submerged arc welding surfacing. The author emphasizes that the heat treatment process is critical to the success of the repair, as an improper heat treatment can lead to spalling of the weld layer and surface delamination, resulting in the scrapping of the repaired roll. The author uses the orthogonal experimental design method to optimize the heat treatment parameters and implements the optimized process in a modified heat treatment furnace. The results show that the optimized process not only produces good surfacing quality but also significantly reduces energy consumption.
Interpretation of Technical Points
The Role of Heat Treatment in Hardfaced Rolls
The heat treatment of a hardfaced roll serves several critical functions. First, it relieves the residual stresses that are generated during the welding process. The welding of a large roll, such as a 1550 support roll, involves a significant amount of deposited metal, and the thermal cycles during welding create a complex pattern of residual stresses. If these stresses are not relieved, they can lead to cracking, spalling, and premature failure of the roll in service. Second, the heat treatment can modify the microstructure of the weld metal and the heat-affected zone, improving the mechanical properties and wear resistance. Third, the heat treatment can temper the hardfacing material to achieve the desired hardness and toughness balance.
The Orthogonal Experimental Design Method
The orthogonal experimental design is a statistical method that allows the engineer to evaluate the effect of multiple factors and their interactions using a relatively small number of experiments. In this study, the author selected three factors that are critical to the heat treatment process: the heating temperature, the holding time, and the cooling rate. Each factor was evaluated at three levels, resulting in a total of 9 experiments using an L9 orthogonal array. The response variable was the quality of the surfacing layer, assessed by visual inspection, hardness testing, and ultrasonic testing for defects such as spalling and delamination.
Optimization of Heat Treatment Parameters
The results of the orthogonal experiments are summarized in the table below:
| Factor | Level 1 | Level 2 | Level 3 | Optimal Level |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Heating Temperature (°C) | 450 | 550 | 650 | 550 |
| Holding Time (h) | 2 | 4 | 6 | 4 |
| Cooling Rate (°C/h) | 50 | 100 | 150 | 50 |
The optimal combination is a heating temperature of 550°C, a holding time of 4 hours, and a cooling rate of 50°C/h. This combination produces a surfacing layer with no spalling or delamination, a uniform hardness of 55 to 58 HRC, and a residual stress level that is within acceptable limits. The slow cooling rate is particularly important, as it allows for the gradual relaxation of residual stresses without creating new thermal stresses.
Integration with Engineering Practice
Application Context in Our Industry
Hardfaced rolls are used extensively in the steel pipe industry, particularly in the straightening machines that are used to correct the curvature of pipe after the forming process. These rolls are subject to severe abrasive wear and impact loading, and they require periodic repair by welding. The repair process involves removing the worn surface layer, building up the roll with a hardfacing alloy, and then heat treating the roll to restore its properties. The heat treatment is a critical step in this process, and the quality of the heat treatment directly determines the service life of the repaired roll.
Practical Considerations for Heat Treatment of Large Rolls
The heat treatment of a large roll, such as a 1550 support roll, presents several practical challenges. First, the roll is heavy, typically weighing several tons, and it must be supported properly in the furnace to prevent distortion. Second, the heating rate must be controlled to prevent thermal shock, which can cause cracking in the weld layer. Third, the temperature uniformity in the furnace must be maintained to ensure consistent heat treatment across the entire roll. Fourth, the cooling rate must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired microstructure and residual stress level.
Furnace Modifications and Energy Savings
The author also describes modifications to the heat treatment furnace that were implemented to support the optimized process. These modifications include the addition of a programmable temperature controller, the installation of a more efficient burner system, and the improvement of the furnace insulation. These modifications allowed for more precise control of the heating and cooling rates, and they resulted in a significant reduction in energy consumption. The author reports that the energy consumption per heat treatment cycle was reduced by approximately 25%, which represents a substantial cost saving for the plant.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
The most common defects in hardfaced rolls after heat treatment are spalling and surface delamination. These defects are typically caused by residual stresses that exceed the bond strength between the weld layer and the substrate. The countermeasures include:
| Defect | Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Spalling | Excessive residual stress | Slow cooling rate, proper preheat |
| Surface Delamination | Poor fusion between weld passes | Increase welding current, reduce welding speed |
| Cracking | Thermal shock during heating | Controlled heating rate, preheating |
| Soft Spots | Inconsistent hardness | Improve furnace temperature uniformity |
Case Study from Our Shop Floor
We encountered a similar problem with a straightening roll that was repaired by submerged arc welding. The roll was 800 mm in diameter and 2000 mm long, and it was surfaced with a Cr-Mo alloy hardfacing material. After the initial repair, the roll was heat treated at 600°C for 2 hours and then air cooled. The roll was put back into service, but after only two weeks, the surfacing layer began to spall, and the roll had to be removed from service and repaired again. We analyzed the failure and found that the residual stress in the weld layer was excessive, and the air cooling had created a steep thermal gradient that contributed to the spalling. We then implemented a modified heat treatment process with a slower cooling rate of 50°C/h, and the roll performed satisfactorily for over six months of service.
Key Questions and Reflections
Is the Orthogonal Experimental Design Method Worth the Effort?
The orthogonal experimental design method is a powerful tool for optimizing process parameters, but it requires careful planning and execution. The engineer must select the right factors and levels, and the response variable must be measurable and meaningful. In our experience, the method is particularly useful when there are multiple interacting factors and when the cost of experiments is high. For heat treatment of large rolls, where each experiment involves a full heat treatment cycle, the orthogonal method can save significant time and resources.
What Is the Optimal Hardness for a Hardfaced Roll?
The optimal hardness for a hardfaced roll depends on the specific application. For a roll that is subject to abrasive wear, a higher hardness is generally preferred. However, if the roll is also subject to impact loading, a lower hardness with higher toughness may be more appropriate. In our experience, a hardness range of 50 to 58 HRC is typically suitable for straightening rolls, with the exact value determined by the material being processed and the severity of the service conditions.
Where Do Standards Leave Room for Judgment?
There is no specific standard that governs the heat treatment of hardfaced rolls. The relevant standards, such as ASME B31.3 and API 5L, address the base material and the weld joint, but not the heat treatment of repaired components. This leaves the engineer with considerable latitude in selecting the heat treatment parameters. In practice, we rely on the results of hardness testing, ultrasonic testing, and metallographic examination to qualify the heat treatment process. We also develop a process qualification record that documents the parameters used and the resulting properties.
Study Insights and Implications
This study demonstrates the value of a systematic approach to process optimization. By using the orthogonal experimental design method, the author was able to identify the optimal heat treatment parameters with a relatively small number of experiments. The implementation of the optimized process resulted in improved surfacing quality and reduced energy consumption, which is a win-win situation for the plant.
For engineers in our industry, this study highlights the importance of heat treatment in the repair of hardfaced components. The heat treatment is not just a final step in the process; it is a critical step that determines the service life and performance of the repaired component. The next time we are faced with a heat treatment problem, we should consider using the orthogonal experimental design method to systematically optimize the parameters.
Reference Value and Outlook
This literature is of direct reference value to our industry, particularly for the repair of hardfaced rolls and other large components. The orthogonal experimental design method can be applied to a wide range of process optimization problems, and it is a valuable tool for any engineer involved in manufacturing or repair.
Looking forward, there is a need for more research on the heat treatment of hardfaced components, particularly on the effect of different cooling rates on the microstructure and residual stress. The development of more advanced heat treatment processes, such as vacuum heat treatment and induction heat treatment, may also provide benefits for certain applications.
In conclusion, this study provides a practical example of how a systematic approach to process optimization can improve quality and reduce costs. The optimized heat treatment process not only produces good surfacing quality but also reduces energy consumption, which is a significant benefit for any manufacturing plant. The lessons learned from this study are directly applicable to our industry, and they should be incorporated into our repair procedures.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd