ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

H3Cr5WMoV Submerged Arc Surfacing Alloy Layer: Microstructure and Properties

Literature Overview

This study, conducted at the Technology Center of Nanjing Iron and Steel Co., Ltd., investigates the microstructure and properties of an H3Cr5WMoV alloy surfacing layer deposited on Q235 steel using automatic submerged arc welding. The alloy layer was subjected to tempering treatment, and the study compares the microstructure, hardness, wear resistance, and thermal fatigue resistance of the as-welded and tempered states. The findings are particularly relevant to our industry because H3Cr5WMoV is a high-alloy steel used for hardfacing applications where wear resistance and thermal fatigue resistance are critical, such as in hot rolling rolls, forging dies, and other components subjected to severe service conditions. The study demonstrates that tempering significantly improves both hardness and wear resistance, which has direct implications for the service life of hardfaced components.

Core Technical Points

Microstructure of the As-Welded and Tempered States

The study found that the as-welded microstructure of the H3Cr5WMoV alloy layer consists of lath martensite with retained austenite. This is a typical microstructure for a high-alloy steel deposited by submerged arc welding, where the rapid cooling rate from the welding process suppresses the transformation of austenite to ferrite and pearlite, resulting in a martensitic structure. The presence of retained austenite is attributed to the high alloy content, which lowers the martensite finish temperature (Mf) below room temperature. After tempering, the microstructure undergoes significant changes: the lath martensite decomposes into tempered martensite, and the retained austenite transforms into ferrite and carbides. The carbides precipitate along the lath boundaries and within the laths, providing a dispersion strengthening effect.

Hardness and Wear Resistance

The study measured the hardness and wear resistance of the alloy layer in both the as-welded and tempered states. The results are summarized below:

Condition Hardness (HRC) Relative Wear Resistance Remarks
As-Welded ~50 1.0 (Reference) Lath martensite with retained austenite
Tempered ~55 1.5 Tempered martensite with carbide precipitates

The tempered state exhibits higher hardness and significantly better wear resistance. This is attributed to the precipitation of hard carbides during tempering, which increases the hardness of the matrix and provides a reinforcing effect. The carbide precipitates also reduce the coefficient of friction, leading to lower wear rates. For our industry, this means that hardfaced components should always be tempered before being put into service. Skipping the tempering treatment would result in a component that wears out prematurely, leading to increased downtime and maintenance costs.

Thermal Fatigue Resistance

The study also evaluated the thermal fatigue resistance of the alloy layer in both states. Thermal fatigue is a critical failure mode in hot working tools, where repeated heating and cooling cycles cause the formation of cracks due to thermal stresses. The results showed that the tempered state has better thermal fatigue resistance than the as-welded state. This is because the tempered martensite has a more stable microstructure, with carbides that resist coarsening at elevated temperatures. In contrast, the as-welded state has a higher concentration of retained austenite, which can transform to martensite during thermal cycling, causing volume changes and the initiation of cracks. For applications involving thermal cycling, such as hot rolling rolls, tempering is essential to ensure adequate service life.

Engineering Practice Insights

Application in Roll Repair and Hardfacing

In our industry, H3Cr5WMoV is commonly used for the hardfacing of hot rolling rolls and other components subjected to severe wear and thermal fatigue. The study's findings confirm that tempering is a critical step in the manufacturing process. In my experience, I have seen cases where the tempering treatment was skipped or improperly performed, leading to premature failure of the hardfaced component. For example, in one steel plant, a set of hot rolling rolls was hardfaced with H3Cr5WMoV but was not tempered due to a production scheduling conflict. The rolls failed after only a few weeks of service, with extensive cracking and spalling. The cost of the rolls, the hardfacing material, and the lost production time far exceeded the cost of the tempering treatment. This is a lesson that we must never forget: the tempering treatment is not optional; it is an essential part of the process.

Welding Procedure and Preheat Considerations

The deposition of H3Cr5WMoV by submerged arc welding requires careful control of the welding parameters to achieve the desired microstructure. The preheat and interpass temperature are particularly important. If the preheat temperature is too low, the cooling rate will be too fast, leading to the formation of untempered martensite with high hardness and low toughness. This can cause cracking during the welding process or during subsequent handling. If the preheat temperature is too high, the cooling rate will be too slow, leading to the formation of a coarser microstructure with lower hardness and wear resistance. In practice, we typically use a preheat temperature of 200 to 300°C for H3Cr5WMoV, depending on the thickness of the component. We also need to control the interpass temperature to avoid excessive heat buildup, which can cause distortion and residual stresses.

Quality Control and Inspection

The quality of the hardfaced layer must be verified through a combination of non-destructive testing and metallographic examination. We typically use ultrasonic testing to detect lack of fusion or porosity in the hardfaced layer, and we take a sample from the edge of the component for metallographic examination. The metallographic sample is etched and examined under a microscope to verify the microstructure. We also measure the hardness at several points across the hardfaced layer to ensure uniformity. If the hardness varies significantly, it may indicate an improper tempering treatment or a variation in the welding parameters. In one case, we found a hardness variation of 10 HRC across a hardfaced roll, which was traced to an uneven preheat temperature distribution. We corrected this by improving the preheating method, using a more uniform heating arrangement.

Key Questions and Reflections

Why Is Tempering Necessary?

The study clearly demonstrates that tempering improves both hardness and wear resistance. But why is this the case? The answer lies in the microstructure. In the as-welded state, the lath martensite has a high dislocation density and a high internal stress. The retained austenite is unstable and can transform to martensite during service, causing dimensional changes and cracking. Tempering relieves the internal stresses, transforms the retained austenite to ferrite and carbides, and precipitates fine carbides that provide dispersion strengthening. The result is a more stable microstructure with higher hardness and better wear resistance. This is a fundamental principle of metallurgy that we must respect in our manufacturing processes.

What Are the Risks of Not Tempering?

The risks of not tempering are significant. As I mentioned earlier, untempered hardfaced components can fail prematurely due to cracking and spalling. In addition, the untempered microstructure is more susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking, especially in environments where hydrogen is present. This is a particular concern in the oil and gas industry, where hardfaced components may be exposed to sour service conditions. If we skip the tempering treatment, we are not only compromising the wear resistance but also the structural integrity of the component. This is a risk that we cannot afford to take.

How Can We Improve the Tempering Process?

The tempering process can be improved by carefully controlling the temperature and time. The study used a specific tempering temperature and time, but the optimal parameters may vary depending on the specific application. In practice, we typically use a tempering temperature of 550 to 650°C for H3Cr5WMoV, with a holding time of 2 to 4 hours, followed by slow cooling. The tempering temperature must be high enough to relieve the internal stresses and precipitate the carbides, but not so high that the hardness drops significantly. We should also consider using a double tempering treatment, which can further improve the stability of the microstructure and reduce the risk of temper embrittlement.

Conclusion

This study provides valuable insights into the microstructure and properties of H3Cr5WMoV submerged arc surfacing alloy layers. The key finding is that tempering significantly improves both hardness and wear resistance, as well as thermal fatigue resistance. This is due to the transformation of the as-welded lath martensite and retained austenite into tempered martensite with carbide precipitates. For our industry, this means that tempering is an essential step in the manufacturing process for hardfaced components. Skipping the tempering treatment can lead to premature failure, increased downtime, and significant financial losses. As an industry veteran, I would emphasize the importance of following the proper heat treatment procedures and conducting thorough quality control inspections to ensure that the hardfaced components meet the required specifications.