Microstructure and Properties of H3Cr5WMoV Submerged Arc Surfacing Alloy Layer
Literature Overview and Material Context
The paper by Liu Shuofeng from Nanjing Iron and Steel Company examines the submerged arc surfacing of H3Cr5WMoV alloy onto a Q235 steel substrate. This is a classic hardfacing application, where the goal is to produce a wear-resistant, heat-resistant layer on a low-cost carbon steel base. The paper compares the as-welded condition with the tempered condition, evaluating microstructure, hardness, wear resistance, and thermal fatigue resistance.
H3Cr5WMoV is a hot-work tool steel composition, with approximately 5% chromium, 1% tungsten, 1% molybdenum, and 0.3% vanadium. This composition is designed to provide high hardness at elevated temperatures, which is essential for applications such as hot rolling rolls, forging dies, and extrusion tools. The alloy is typically used in a hardened and tempered condition, where the carbides of tungsten, molybdenum, and vanadium provide the wear resistance, and the chromium provides oxidation resistance.
Microstructural Analysis and Property Comparison
The authors report that the as-welded microstructure consists of lath martensite and retained austenite. This is expected for a low-carbon, high-alloy steel that cools rapidly from the welding temperature. The lath martensite provides high hardness but is brittle, and the retained austenite is unstable and can transform to martensite under stress, leading to cracking.
After tempering, the microstructure changes significantly. The retained austenite transforms to martensite or bainite, and the carbides precipitate from the supersaturated martensite. This results in a tempered martensite structure with a dispersion of fine carbides, which provides a better combination of hardness and toughness.
The authors report that the tempered condition has higher hardness and better wear resistance than the as-welded condition. This is counterintuitive to those who think that welding always produces the hardest, most wear-resistant structure. The explanation lies in the tempering process. As-welded martensite is hard but has low toughness, and the wear mechanism is not purely abrasive. In many wear situations, the material is subjected to impact or thermal cycling, and a brittle material will fail by spalling or cracking, which accelerates wear. The tempered structure, with its improved toughness, resists this type of failure.
The thermal fatigue resistance is also better in the tempered condition. Thermal fatigue occurs when a material is subjected to repeated heating and cooling cycles, which induces cyclic thermal stresses. The as-welded structure, with its retained austenite and brittle martensite, is more susceptible to cracking under these conditions. The tempered structure, with its more stable microstructure, can accommodate the thermal strains without cracking.
Practical Implications for Hardfacing Applications
This paper has direct relevance to the repair and hardfacing of steel mill rolls, which is a topic I know well. In a rolling mill, the rolls are subjected to severe wear, thermal cycling, and impact loading. The common practice is to use a hardfacing alloy that can withstand these conditions, and H3Cr5WMoV is a good candidate.
The key lesson from this paper is that the heat treatment after surfacing is just as important as the surfacing process itself. Many shops will apply a hardfacing layer and then put the roll back into service without any post-weld heat treatment. This is a mistake. The as-welded structure, while hard, is brittle and will fail prematurely by spalling or cracking.
The tempering treatment must be carefully controlled. The temperature and time must be sufficient to transform the retained austenite and precipitate the carbides, but not so high that the hardness drops below the required level. The typical tempering temperature for H3Cr5WMoV is in the range of 550-650°C, and the time is usually 2-4 hours.
Another practical consideration is the dilution of the hardfacing alloy by the base material. In submerged arc surfacing, the depth of penetration is significant, and the dilution rate can be as high as 30-40%. This means that the composition of the first layer of the hardfacing is significantly different from the nominal composition of the electrode. To achieve the desired properties, it is often necessary to apply multiple layers, with the final layer having the correct composition.
Critical Assessment and Reflection
This paper provides valuable data on the properties of H3Cr5WMoV hardfacing, but it has a significant limitation: the tests are conducted on small laboratory specimens, not on actual rolls or components. The performance of a hardfacing layer in service is influenced by many factors that are not present in a laboratory test, such as the thermal gradient through the roll, the presence of a heat-affected zone, and the interaction between the hardfacing and the lubricant or coolant.
The authors also do not address the issue of cracking in the hardfacing layer. H3Cr5WMoV is a high-carbon, high-alloy steel, and it is susceptible to solidification cracking and hydrogen-induced cracking. The welding procedure must include preheating and strict control of the interpass temperature to prevent these defects.
In conclusion, this paper confirms what experienced hardfacing engineers already know: the tempering treatment is essential for achieving the optimal combination of hardness, wear resistance, and thermal fatigue resistance. The paper would be more valuable if it included data on the effect of the number of layers, the dilution rate, and the presence of defects. For now, it serves as a useful reference for the basic properties of this alloy system.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd