ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Sintered Flux Submerged Arc Surfacing Repair of φ650 Mill Rolls

Literature Overview and Industrial Context

The paper by Zhu Yan from Dalian Second Steel Plant describes the repair of φ650 rolling mill rolls using submerged arc surfacing with a sintered flux. This is a classic example of the economic value of hardfacing repair. A rolling mill roll is an expensive component, and when the roll groove is worn, the roll is typically scrapped. The author presents a repair method that extends the life of the roll, providing significant cost savings.

The φ650 mill is a medium-sized section mill, used for rolling billets into bars or sections. The rolls are subjected to severe wear, particularly in the roll groove, where the metal is deformed at high temperature and pressure. The roll material is typically a cast iron or cast steel, with a hardness that is carefully selected to balance wear resistance and toughness.

Technical Analysis of the Repair Process

The author uses submerged arc surfacing with a sintered flux. Sintered flux is a modern alternative to the traditional fused flux. It is produced by mixing the flux components, forming them into granules, and then sintering them at a high temperature. The sintered flux has several advantages over fused flux: it has a higher basicity, which provides better deoxidation and alloying; it has a lower density, which allows for a higher deposition rate; and it can be formulated with specific alloying elements to control the composition of the weld metal.

The choice of a sintered flux is critical for this application. The roll material is a high-carbon, high-alloy steel, and the surfacing alloy must be compatible with the base material. The sintered flux can be formulated to provide the necessary alloying elements, such as chromium, molybdenum, and vanadium, to achieve the desired hardness and wear resistance.

The author mentions that after welding, the roll is subjected to an annealing treatment and then remachined. This is a standard practice for roll repair. The annealing treatment relieves the residual stresses that are induced by the welding process, and it also softens the hardfacing layer, making it easier to machine. After machining, the roll is typically heat-treated again to restore the hardness.

Practical Considerations for Roll Repair

In my experience, roll repair is a specialized operation that requires careful attention to several factors. The first is the preparation of the roll surface. The worn groove must be machined to remove all cracks and defects. If the groove is not completely machined, the cracks will propagate into the new hardfacing layer, leading to premature failure.

The second factor is the preheating of the roll. A large roll, such as a φ650 roll, has a significant thermal mass, and if it is not preheated, the welding will induce severe thermal stresses, leading to cracking. The preheat temperature is typically in the range of 200-400°C, depending on the roll material and the hardfacing alloy.

The third factor is the welding procedure. The submerged arc process is well-suited for this application because it provides a high deposition rate and a smooth, uniform surface. However, the process parameters must be carefully controlled to ensure that the hardfacing layer is free from defects such as porosity, slag inclusions, and lack of fusion.

Critical Assessment and Reflection

This paper is a practical case study, and it provides valuable insights into the roll repair process. However, it is limited in its technical detail. The author does not provide the specific welding parameters, the composition of the hardfacing alloy, or the mechanical properties of the repaired roll. This makes it difficult to replicate the process in another shop.

The paper also does not address the economic aspects of the repair. While it is clear that repair is cheaper than replacement, the actual cost savings depend on the cost of the repair, the number of times the roll can be repaired, and the performance of the repaired roll compared to a new roll. A thorough economic analysis would be valuable.

In conclusion, this paper is a useful reminder that roll repair is a viable and economically attractive option for steel mills. The use of a sintered flux is a good choice for this application, as it provides the necessary alloying and a high deposition rate. However, the success of the repair depends on the discipline of the welders and the quality of the welding procedure. I would recommend that any shop undertaking roll repair develop a detailed procedure that covers all aspects of the process, from surface preparation to final inspection.