Transition Layer Hardfacing for 14Cr1MoR Welded Joints: Eliminating Post-Weld Heat Treatment
The Metallurgical Problem
14Cr1MoR is a chromium-molybdenum low alloy steel used extensively in pressure vessels and heat exchangers for elevated temperature service, particularly in the petrochemical and power generation industries. The "R" designation indicates that the steel is intended for pressure vessel applications, and it is typically supplied in the normalized and tempered condition. The weldability of 14Cr1MoR is governed by its carbon equivalent and its susceptibility to hydrogen-induced cracking in the heat-affected zone (HAZ). The standard practice for welding this steel is to use a matching low-alloy filler metal, preheat to 150 to 200 °C, maintain an interpass temperature of no more than 250 °C, and then perform a post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) at 620 to 700 °C to relieve residual stresses and to temper the HAZ.
The problem that this paper addresses is what happens when the welded joint needs to be repaired or re-welded after it has already been in service. If a weld is made on a 14Cr1MoR component that has already been PWHT, the new weld introduces fresh residual stresses and a new HAZ that is hard and susceptible to cracking. The standard solution is to perform another PWHT after the repair, but this is often impractical or impossible because the component may be installed in a location where PWHT cannot be performed, or the PWHT may cause distortion or damage to other parts of the assembly. The paper proposes a solution: use a nickel-based filler metal for the transition layer, so that the weld deposit is austenitic and does not require PWHT for stress relief.
The Nickel-Based Transition Layer Approach
The concept is to deposit a nickel-based alloy on the 14Cr1MoR base material in the groove, using a nickel-based filler metal that is compatible with both the base metal and the subsequent fill welds. The nickel-based deposit has a coefficient of thermal expansion that is intermediate between the low-alloy steel and the austenitic stainless steel that might be used for the final fill, and it has excellent toughness and resistance to hydrogen-induced cracking. The key metallurgical advantage is that the nickel-based deposit is austenitic, so it does not undergo the martensitic transformation that causes the HAZ hardening in low-alloy steels. The residual stresses in the nickel-based deposit are lower than in a matching low-alloy deposit, and the deposit can tolerate a certain amount of hydrogen without cracking.
The paper states that by using the nickel-based transition layer, the weld can be repaired in the future without the need for PWHT. This is a significant operational advantage. In a refinery or a petrochemical plant, a pressure vessel may be in service for 20 to 30 years, and during that time, it may need to be modified or repaired several times. Each repair that requires PWHT means that the vessel must be taken out of service, the insulation removed, the PWHT performed, and the insulation reinstalled. This can take weeks and cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. If the original weld was made with a nickel-based transition layer, the repair can be performed without PWHT, saving time and money.
Welding Process Parameters and Qualification
| Parameter | Value / Range | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Base material | 14Cr1MoR | Normalized and tempered |
| Transition layer filler | Nickel-based (e.g., ERNiCr-3 or ERNiCrMo-3) | Austenitic deposit |
| Fill weld filler | Matching or nickel-based | Depends on service conditions |
| Preheat temperature | 100 - 150 °C | Lower than for low-alloy filler |
| Interpass temperature | Max 250 °C | Control to prevent over-heating |
| Heat input | 15 - 25 kJ/cm | Optimize for dilution control |
| Post-weld heat treatment | Not required for the nickel-based deposit | Key advantage |
The critical process parameter is dilution. When the nickel-based filler is deposited on the 14Cr1MoR base, the base metal melts and mixes with the filler, creating a diluted zone that has a composition intermediate between the two. If the dilution is too high, the nickel-based deposit will pick up enough carbon and chromium from the base metal to become susceptible to martensitic transformation, and the whole point of the nickel-based transition layer is lost. The welding procedure must be qualified with a dilution test, typically by depositing a bead on the base metal and then measuring the composition of the deposit at various depths. The dilution should be kept below 30 percent, and the heat input should be kept low enough to minimize the depth of the base metal melting.
Inspection and Qualification
The weld must be inspected with the same rigor as any pressure vessel weld. Radiographic testing (RT) or ultrasonic testing (UT) is required to detect any lack of fusion, porosity, or cracking in the transition layer. The nickel-based deposit is more difficult to inspect with UT than a low-alloy steel deposit because the nickel-based alloy has a coarser grain structure and a different acoustic impedance, so the UT operator must be qualified for this specific application. The hardness of the transition layer should be checked to ensure that it does not exceed the specified maximum, typically 220 HV for the nickel-based deposit, and that the HAZ of the base metal is not excessively hardened.
Practical Implications for the Shop Floor
From a practical standpoint, the nickel-based transition layer approach is a sound solution, but it requires a level of process control that is not always present in a typical fabrication shop. The welding operator must be trained to control the heat input and the dilution, and the welding procedure must be qualified with the specific combination of base metal, filler metal, and welding process that will be used in production. The cost of the nickel-based filler metal is significantly higher than that of a low-alloy filler, so the economic benefit only materializes if the component is likely to be repaired in the future. For a one-off weld that will never be touched again, the cost of the nickel-based filler may not be justified.
I would also caution that the nickel-based transition layer does not eliminate the need for preheat. The 14Cr1MoR base metal still has a HAZ that is susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking, and the preheat is required to prevent this. The preheat temperature can be lower than for a matching low-alloy weld because the nickel-based deposit is more tolerant of hydrogen, but it cannot be eliminated entirely. The paper's claim that the weld can be repaired without PWHT is valid, but the repair still requires preheat and controlled heat input.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd