Hardfacing Applications in Underground Scraper Conveyor Maintenance
The Wear Problem in Underground Conveyors
In an underground coal mine, the scraper conveyor is the workhorse that moves the coal from the face to the main haulage system. The components that wear the fastest are the machine head frame, the filter trough, the scraper chain, and the flight bars. These components are subjected to a combination of abrasive wear from the coal and rock, impact from the falling material, and corrosion from the mine water, which is typically acidic and laden with dissolved salts. The paper reports that in a particular coal mine, the wear of the scraper conveyor components was severe enough to cause frequent breakdowns and significant production losses.
The conventional approach to managing this wear is to replace the worn components with new ones. This is expensive, both in terms of the cost of the new components and the cost of the downtime required to install them. In an underground mine, the downtime is particularly costly because the entire production chain is affected; if the scraper conveyor stops, the shearer stops, and the whole face stops producing. The paper proposes the use of hardfacing technology to repair the worn components in place, rather than replacing them, and reports that this approach can reduce maintenance time and cost while improving the efficiency of the operation.
Hardfacing Process Selection for Underground Repair
The hardfacing of scraper conveyor components is not a straightforward application. The components are typically made of cast steel or low-alloy steel, and they are worn in a complex pattern that is not uniform across the surface. The hardfacing must be applied in the worn areas, and the deposit must be thick enough to restore the original dimensions but not so thick that it causes distortion or cracking. The most common hardfacing processes for this application are shielded metal arc welding (SMAW) with a hardfacing electrode, flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) with a hardfacing wire, and oxy-acetylene welding with a hardfacing rod.
| Process | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|
| SMAW | Simple equipment, works in confined spaces | Lower deposition rate, more operator skill required |
| FCAW | Higher deposition rate, better for large areas | Requires shielding gas, more complex equipment |
| Oxy-acetylene | Low dilution, good for thin deposits | Slow, limited to small areas |
In an underground mine, the choice of process is often dictated by the available equipment and the accessibility of the component. SMAW is the most common choice because the welding machine can be located at the face, and the electrode can be used in the confined space of the conveyor pan. FCAW is used where a higher deposition rate is needed, but the shielding gas cylinder adds to the logistics of the repair. Oxy-acetylene is used for small, precise repairs where dilution must be minimized.
Application to Specific Components
The machine head frame is the most critical component because it houses the drive sprocket and the chain tensioning mechanism. The wear is typically on the contact surfaces where the chain runs, and the hardfacing must be applied in a pattern that restores the original geometry. The filter trough is a large component that collects the fines and the water, and the wear is typically on the bottom and the sides where the coal slurry flows. The hardfacing here is more of a general surface build-up, and the deposit can be applied in a grid pattern to minimize distortion.
The scraper chain and the flight bars are the most challenging components because they are in constant motion and they are subjected to impact as well as abrasion. The hardfacing on these components must be tough enough to withstand the impact without spalling, and hard enough to resist the abrasion. A typical hardfacing alloy for this application is a martensitic steel with a hardness of 45 to 55 HRC, which provides a good balance of toughness and wear resistance. For the most severe applications, a chromium carbide overlay with a hardness of 55 to 60 HRC can be used, but the overlay is more susceptible to spalling under impact.
Economic and Operational Benefits
The paper reports that the use of hardfacing technology in the underground repair of scraper conveyors can significantly reduce maintenance time and cost. From my experience, the key economic benefit is not the cost of the hardfacing materials, which are relatively inexpensive, but the reduction in downtime. A scraper conveyor that is repaired with hardfacing can be back in service in a fraction of the time required for a component replacement, because the hardfacing can be applied in place without the need to remove and reinstall the component. In a coal mine, where the production rate is measured in tonnes per hour, the value of the coal that is lost during downtime can easily exceed the cost of the repair.
There is also a benefit in terms of the inventory of spare parts. If the worn components can be repaired with hardfacing, the mine does not need to carry a large inventory of spare components, which reduces the working capital tied up in the warehouse. The paper's finding that the hardfacing approach can improve the efficiency of the operation is consistent with my experience; a component that is repaired with hardfacing and then wears at a slower rate than the original component will extend the maintenance interval, which is always a win in the mining industry.
Lessons from the Field
I would add a few practical lessons from my own experience with hardfacing in underground applications. First, the surface preparation is critical. The worn component must be cleaned of all coal dust, rust, and grease before hardfacing, otherwise the deposit will have porosity and lack of fusion. In an underground mine, this is difficult because the environment is dirty and wet, but it is essential. Second, the hardfacing must be applied in a pattern that minimizes distortion. A continuous weld on a large component will cause it to bow, and the component will no longer fit in the conveyor pan. The hardfacing should be applied in short, staggered passes with a skip sequence, and the component should be allowed to cool between passes. Third, the hardness of the hardfacing should be checked with a portable hardness tester after the repair, and the deposit should be inspected for cracks. A crack in the hardfacing will propagate into the base metal and cause a catastrophic failure.
The paper is a practical example of how a relatively simple technology can solve a significant operational problem. It is not a groundbreaking scientific contribution, but it is exactly the kind of applied engineering that keeps a coal mine running.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd