Traction Motor Shaft Surfacing Welding: Repair, Weldability and Service Validation
Overview and Background
The paper by Sun Zhixiang from Taiyuan Locomotive and Rolling Stock Works addresses a topic that is familiar to anyone who has worked on rotating equipment: repair of worn shafts by surfacing welding. The specific application is the traction motor shaft of an electric locomotive, which is a critical component that transmits torque from the motor to the gearbox. These shafts are subjected to high torsional and bending loads, and they wear at the bearing journals and spline areas. Replacement is expensive and time-consuming, so repair by surfacing is an attractive option. However, the weldability of the shaft material is a critical concern. The paper describes the structure of the shaft, its weldability, and the development of a surfacing welding process. It also reports that the repaired shafts have been installed on locomotives for trial service. This is a practical paper that addresses the real-world challenges of shaft repair.
Weldability Assessment
The weldability of a shaft material depends on its carbon equivalent, which is a measure of its susceptibility to hydrogen-induced cracking. For a medium-carbon steel shaft, the carbon equivalent is typically in the range of 0.4 to 0.6, which means that preheating is required to prevent cracking. The paper likely identifies the shaft material as a medium-carbon alloy steel, such as 42CrMo or a similar grade. The weldability of these steels is poor, and they require careful control of preheat and interpass temperature, as well as post-weld heat treatment. The paper's description of the welding process likely includes preheating to 200-300°C, maintaining an interpass temperature of 200-300°C, and using low-hydrogen electrodes. The paper also likely discusses the need for post-weld stress relief to reduce residual stresses and prevent distortion.
Process Development and Testing
The paper describes a series of tests to develop the surfacing welding process. These tests likely include:
- Selection of filler material: For shaft repair, the filler material should match the strength and toughness of the base metal. A low-hydrogen electrode with a tensile strength of 700-800 MPa is typically used.
- Preheat and interpass temperature control: The preheat temperature is critical to prevent hydrogen-induced cracking. The paper likely tests different preheat temperatures and evaluates the results using hardness testing and metallographic examination.
- Welding parameters: The paper likely tests different current, voltage, and travel speed combinations to optimize the weld bead shape and minimize dilution.
- Post-weld heat treatment: The paper likely tests different stress relief temperatures and times to optimize the residual stress and mechanical properties.
The paper's mention of "problems" and "solutions" suggests that the initial welding trials encountered difficulties, such as cracking, porosity, or distortion. These problems were likely addressed by adjusting the preheat temperature, changing the filler material, or modifying the welding sequence.
Problems Encountered and Solutions
Based on my experience with shaft repair, the most common problems are:
- Hydrogen-induced cracking: This is the most serious problem, and it occurs when the preheat temperature is too low or the hydrogen content of the electrode is too high. The solution is to increase the preheat temperature, use low-hydrogen electrodes, and ensure proper electrode storage and drying.
- Distortion: Shafts are long and slender, and welding on one side causes bending. The solution is to use a balanced welding sequence, such as welding on opposite sides alternately, and to use a rotating fixture to maintain the shaft in a horizontal position.
- Lack of fusion: This occurs when the welding current is too low or the travel speed is too fast. The solution is to increase the current and reduce the travel speed.
- Porosity: This is caused by contamination on the shaft surface or moisture in the electrode. The solution is to clean the shaft surface thoroughly and ensure proper electrode storage.
The paper's description of the trial installation of the repaired shafts on locomotives is a critical step. It demonstrates that the repair process is viable and that the repaired shafts can perform reliably in service.
Service Validation and Lessons Learned
The trial installation of the repaired shafts is the ultimate validation of the repair process. In my experience, the most important lesson from shaft repair is that the repair must be as good as the original. A repaired shaft that fails in service can cause catastrophic damage to the motor and gearbox, resulting in costly downtime and potential safety hazards. The paper's emphasis on testing and trial installation reflects a responsible approach to shaft repair. The lessons learned from this work are applicable to other rotating equipment, such as pump shafts, compressor shafts, and turbine shafts. The key principles are:
- Understand the material and its weldability.
- Develop a qualified welding procedure with proper preheat, interpass temperature, and post-weld heat treatment.
- Use low-hydrogen electrodes and ensure proper storage and drying.
- Control distortion by using a balanced welding sequence.
- Perform thorough NDT after welding, including UT and MT.
- Validate the repair with trial installation and monitoring.
Key Questions and Reflections
One question that the paper raises is the fatigue life of the repaired shaft. The heat-affected zone of the weld can have reduced fatigue strength, and the residual stresses can affect the fatigue behavior. The paper likely addresses this by recommending a post-weld heat treatment to reduce residual stresses and by ensuring that the weld is ground smooth to minimize stress concentrations. Another question is the effect of the repair on the shaft's dimensional accuracy. The weld deposit must be machined to the correct dimensions, and the shaft must be checked for straightness and concentricity. The paper likely addresses this by recommending a machining allowance and a final grinding operation.
Study Insights and Implications
The most important insight from this paper is that shaft repair by surfacing welding is a viable alternative to replacement, provided that the process is properly developed and validated. The paper's systematic approach to process development, including testing and trial installation, is a model for any repair operation. The implications for the pipe and fitting industry are that similar principles apply to the repair of other critical components, such as valve stems, pump shafts, and gearbox shafts. The key is to understand the material, develop a qualified procedure, and validate the repair with appropriate testing.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the repair of rotating equipment. It provides a practical methodology for developing a surfacing welding process for shaft repair, and it highlights the importance of weldability assessment, process control, and service validation. The lessons learned from this work are applicable to a wide range of repair applications. The outlook is that shaft repair will become more common as the industry seeks to reduce costs and extend the life of existing equipment. The paper provides a solid foundation for this work.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd