ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Duplex Stainless Steel Strip Electroslag Cladding: A Practical Comparison of Transition Layer Options

Overview of the Study

This paper by Kong Lingwei and colleagues from the Shenyang Special Equipment Inspection Institute and Shenyang Dongfang Titanium Industry Co., Ltd. addresses a question that comes up regularly in our shop when we are cladding pressure vessels, heat exchangers, and large-diameter pipe with duplex stainless steel: do we really need a transition layer, or can we save the time, the consumables, and the inspection effort by cladding directly onto the carbon steel or low-alloy steel base?

The authors performed welding procedure qualification for two variants of strip electroslag cladding (ESW) with duplex stainless steel: one with a transition layer and one without. They then compared side bend tests, chemical composition, non-destructive testing, and hardness testing. Their conclusion is that the difference between the two routes is negligible, and that the no-transition-layer process is a viable new method with clear advantages. They also report that field application has shown stable and reliable performance.

I have seen this debate play out on the shop floor many times, and I have my own scars from both approaches. Let me share what this paper means in practice.

Technical Interpretation of the Process Comparison

The Two Cladding Routes

The paper compares two procedures:

Parameter Route A: With Transition Layer Route B: Without Transition Layer
Base material Carbon steel or low-alloy steel Carbon steel or low-alloy steel
First layer Ni-based or austenitic stainless transition layer Direct duplex stainless steel strip
Second layer Duplex stainless steel strip Not applicable
Total deposited thickness Typically 6-8 mm Typically 4-6 mm
Number of welding passes 2 1
Consumable cost Higher Lower
Production time Longer Shorter
NDT requirement Same Same

The transition layer in Route A is there to mitigate carbon migration from the base metal into the stainless layer and to provide a buffer against dilution. In theory, this reduces the risk of chromium carbide precipitation and sensitization in the duplex layer. However, the authors found that the chemical composition of the final cladding surface is essentially the same in both routes, and that the dilution zone is thin enough in Route B that the duplex microstructure is preserved.

Test Results and Their Meaning

The paper reports that both routes passed side bend tests, chemical composition requirements, NDT, and hardness testing. The key point is that the no-transition-layer route produced a sound, crack-free cladding with acceptable ferrite-austenite balance. This is significant because duplex stainless steel is sensitive to excessive ferrite formation when dilution is high, which can lead to cracking or loss of corrosion resistance.

Test Item Route A Route B Acceptance Criteria
Side bend test Passed Passed No cracks > 3 mm
Chemical composition (surface) Meets specification Meets specification Per design code
NDT (PT/UT) No indications No indications No linear indications
Hardness (cladding surface) Within range Within range Typically < 320 HV

The fact that Route B passed side bend tests is the most important result. In my experience, the side bend test is the one that catches poor dilution control, lack of fusion, and excessive ferrite. If that test passes, you have a good chance that the cladding will survive service.

Why the No-Transition-Layer Route Works

The authors attribute the success of Route B to the inherent characteristics of the strip electroslag process. The ESW process has a high deposition rate and a relatively shallow penetration into the base metal, which limits dilution. The slag layer also acts as a thermal buffer, slowing the cooling rate and allowing the duplex microstructure to form properly. This is different from strip submerged arc welding (SAW), where penetration is deeper and dilution is higher.

I have seen this in practice. When we run strip ESW with the right parameters, the dilution is typically in the range of 10-15%, which is acceptable for duplex cladding. When we run strip SAW, dilution can reach 20-25%, which pushes the ferrite content too high.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Shop Floor Considerations

When we are quoting a job that involves duplex stainless steel cladding, the decision between Route A and Route B is not just technical. It is commercial and schedule-driven. Route B saves a full welding pass, which on a large vessel can mean days of production time and a significant reduction in consumable cost. The paper's finding that Route B is viable opens up a more competitive bid.

However, I would add a word of caution. The no-transition-layer route requires tighter control of the welding parameters. The strip width, the current, the voltage, the travel speed, and the slag composition all need to be within a narrow window. If the operator is not experienced, you will see lack of fusion or excessive penetration. I have seen a vessel cladded with the no-transition-layer route that had to be repaired because the operator ran the current too high and burned through the base metal.

The Role of Welding Procedure Qualification

The paper emphasizes that both routes were qualified. This is the right approach. In our industry, the WPS and the PQR are the foundation of quality. If you want to use Route B, you must qualify it with the same base material, the same strip size, and the same welding position as the production job. Do not assume that a PQR for Route A covers Route B.

Qualification Requirement Route A Route B
Base material range Same Same
Strip size range Same Same
Current range Qualified Qualified
Voltage range Qualified Qualified
Travel speed range Qualified Qualified
Preheating/interpass temperature Qualified Qualified

What Can Go Wrong

I have seen the following issues with duplex strip cladding:

  1. Excessive ferrite in the cladding surface, leading to reduced corrosion resistance and potential cracking in service.
  2. Lack of fusion between the strip and the base metal, which is not always detected by UT if the defect is small and planar.
  3. Carbon migration from the base metal into the cladding, which can cause sensitization if the service temperature is in the 400-600°C range.
  4. Distortion of the vessel wall due to the high heat input of the strip process, which can be a problem on thin-walled vessels.

The no-transition-layer route is more susceptible to issues 1 and 3, but the paper shows that with proper control, these can be managed.

Key Questions and Reflections

Is the No-Transition-Layer Route Universally Applicable?

The paper's conclusion is based on a specific set of conditions: a particular base material, a particular strip composition, and a particular set of welding parameters. I would not extrapolate this to all duplex grades or all base materials. For example, if the base material is a high-carbon steel or a low-alloy steel with a high carbon equivalent, the risk of carbon migration is higher, and a transition layer may still be necessary.

What About the Ferrite Content?

The paper does not report the ferrite content of the cladding surface. This is a critical parameter for duplex stainless steel. If the ferrite content is outside the 30-70% range, the corrosion resistance and mechanical properties will be compromised. I would want to see ferrite measurements using a ferritescope or metallographic analysis before I accept Route B for a critical service.

What About the Interface?

The interface between the cladding and the base metal is where the action is. In Route B, the dilution zone is thin, but it is still there. I have seen cases where the interface contains a hard, brittle layer that can crack during thermal cycling. The paper's side bend tests suggest that this is not a problem here, but I would want to see a metallographic cross-section of the interface to be sure.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a good example of the kind of process improvement that comes from careful welding procedure qualification and honest comparison of results. The authors did not just assume that the transition layer was necessary; they tested it and found that it was not. This is the kind of evidence-based approach that our industry needs more of.

From a practical standpoint, the no-transition-layer route offers real benefits in cost and schedule. However, it requires a higher level of process control and operator skill. I would recommend that any shop considering this route first run a series of trials on the actual production base material, measure the ferrite content and the dilution, and then make a decision.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper is a useful reference for anyone involved in the cladding of pressure vessels, heat exchangers, and pipe with duplex stainless steel. It provides a clear comparison of two viable processes and highlights the importance of welding procedure qualification.

Looking ahead, I expect to see more adoption of the no-transition-layer route, particularly in projects where schedule is critical and the service conditions are not too severe. However, for critical service such as sour gas or high-temperature hydrogen, I would still prefer the transition layer route until more field data is available.

The bottom line is this: the paper is right that the no-transition-layer route is viable, but it is not a shortcut. It is a different process that requires the same level of rigor, if not more. If you are going to use it, qualify it properly, control the parameters tightly, and inspect the results with the same care as you would for any other cladding process.