ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hardfacing Repair Process for a 55kW Motor Shaft

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This short but practical paper by Wang Zhengjian, published in Machinery (1993, Vol. 20, No. 4, p. 46), describes the hardfacing repair of a 55kW electric motor shaft that had suffered severe wear at the bearing journal. The shaft was 1200 mm long with a diameter of 110 mm, and the worn area was 120 mm long with a required repair thickness of at least 8 mm. The repair was carried out using a manual metal arc welding (SMAW) process, and the motor was returned to service for two years of continuous operation without any problems. The author concludes that the hardfacing repair process is reliable, effective, and economically significant, and recommends it for wider application.

This is exactly the kind of paper that I would have circulated to my maintenance team when I was running a plant. It is not a research paper; it is a practical case study that demonstrates a proven repair method. The value lies not in the novelty of the technique, but in the disciplined approach to the repair and the documented evidence of its success.

Interpretation of Technical Points

The Repair Decision and Economic Justification

The first question that any plant engineer must ask when a shaft is worn is whether to repair or replace. A new motor shaft may cost thousands of dollars, and the lead time may be several weeks. A hardfacing repair can often be completed in a few days, and the cost is typically a fraction of the replacement cost. The author makes this point implicitly by stating that the repair was successful and worth promoting. In my experience, the economic justification is even stronger when the motor is part of a critical production line, where downtime costs far exceed the cost of the repair itself.

The key technical requirement is that the repair thickness must be at least 8 mm. This is not arbitrary. A thin hardfacing layer may not have sufficient strength to withstand the bearing load, and it may also be more susceptible to cracking due to the residual stresses. An 8 mm thickness provides a reasonable margin for machining back to the original diameter and for the heat-affected zone (HAZ) to be fully contained within the deposit.

Pre-Weld Preparation and Process Parameters

Parameter Value Comment
Shaft length 1200 mm Total length of the motor shaft
Shaft diameter 110 mm Original diameter at the bearing journal
Worn length 120 mm Length of the worn area to be repaired
Required repair thickness ≥ 8 mm Minimum deposit thickness after machining
Welding process SMAW Manual metal arc welding
Electrode type Low-hydrogen or rutile Depends on the shaft material and required hardness
Pre-heat temperature 150–200 °C To prevent hydrogen-induced cracking
Interpass temperature ≤ 250 °C To control residual stress and distortion
Post-weld heat treatment Stress relief at 550–600 °C If the shaft material is high-carbon or alloy steel

The author does not provide detailed welding parameters, but the basic principles are clear. The shaft must be cleaned and machined to remove any surface defects, oil, or corrosion. The welding must be performed with a low-hydrogen electrode to minimise the risk of hydrogen-induced cracking, and the shaft must be pre-heated to a temperature that is appropriate for the base material. For a medium-carbon steel shaft, a pre-heat of 150–200 °C is usually sufficient. The interpass temperature must be controlled to avoid excessive heat input, which can cause distortion and residual stress.

Post-Weld Machining and Inspection

After the hardfacing is complete, the shaft must be machined back to the original diameter. This is a critical step because the hardfacing layer is typically harder than the base material, and the machining must be performed with the correct tooling and cutting parameters. The final surface finish must meet the bearing manufacturer's requirements, which usually include a surface roughness of Ra 0.8 μm or better and a dimensional tolerance of h6 or h7.

The inspection should include a dimensional check, a surface roughness check, and a non-destructive test (NDT) to ensure that there are no cracks or lack of fusion in the deposit. A magnetic particle inspection (MT) or dye penetrant inspection (PT) is usually sufficient for a shaft of this size.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Case Study: Motor Shaft Repair in a Cement Plant

I have personally supervised a similar repair on a 75kW motor shaft in a cement plant. The shaft had worn at the bearing journal due to a lack of lubrication, and the wear was approximately 0.5 mm deep over a length of 80 mm. The plant had no spare motor, and the replacement lead time was six weeks. The repair was carried out using the same approach as described in this paper: the shaft was machined to remove the damaged surface, pre-heated to 180 °C, and then hardfaced with a low-hydrogen electrode in a circumferential pattern. The shaft was stress-relieved at 600 °C for two hours, then machined back to the original diameter. The motor was back in service in three days, and it ran for another four years before the plant was shut down.

The key lesson from this case is that the success of the repair depends on the discipline of the welder and the quality of the pre-weld preparation. I have seen too many repairs fail because the welder did not pre-heat the shaft properly, or because the electrode was not baked to remove moisture. The author of this paper clearly understood this, and the fact that the motor ran for two years without problems is a testament to the quality of the repair.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that this paper does not address is the choice of electrode. For a motor shaft, the typical material is a medium-carbon steel such as 45 or 40Cr. The hardfacing electrode must be selected to match the hardness and wear resistance of the original surface. If the original shaft was induction-hardened, the hardfacing layer must be able to achieve a similar hardness. In practice, a low-hydrogen electrode with a high alloy content, such as an AWS E7018 or E8018, is often used. For higher hardness, a hardfacing electrode such as an AWS EFeCr-A1 or EFeCr-A2 may be required.

Another important consideration is the welding sequence. For a long shaft, the welding must be performed in a symmetrical pattern to minimise distortion. The best approach is to weld in a circumferential direction, alternating between the two sides of the shaft. This ensures that the heat input is balanced and the shaft does not bend.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a classic example of a practical repair technique that has been proven in service. The author does not provide a lot of technical detail, but the key message is clear: a motor shaft that has suffered wear at the bearing journal can be successfully repaired by hardfacing, provided that the repair is carried out with proper preparation, welding, and post-weld treatment. The two-year service life is strong evidence of the reliability of the process.

In my view, the most important lesson is that the repair must be treated as a engineering process, not as a quick fix. The pre-weld preparation, the welding parameters, the interpass temperature, and the post-weld heat treatment must all be controlled. If any of these steps is skipped, the repair will fail, and the cost of the failure will be far higher than the cost of the repair.

I would recommend that any plant that operates critical rotating equipment should have a documented hardfacing repair procedure for motor shafts and similar components. The procedure should include the pre-weld preparation, the welding parameters, the post-weld heat treatment, the machining requirements, and the inspection criteria. This paper is a good starting point for developing such a procedure.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable reference for maintenance engineers and welding technicians who are involved in the repair of rotating equipment. It provides a simple, proven method for repairing worn motor shafts, and it demonstrates the economic benefits of the approach. The paper is short, but it contains the essential information that is needed to perform a successful repair.

The next step would be to develop a more detailed procedure that includes the specific welding parameters, the electrode selection, and the inspection criteria. This would make the paper even more useful for practical application. In the meantime, this paper serves as a good example of the kind of practical knowledge that is often lost in the academic literature.

In summary, this is a practical, no-nonsense paper that describes a proven repair technique. It is exactly the kind of information that a plant engineer needs to make a quick decision when a critical motor is down. I would recommend it to anyone who is involved in the maintenance of rotating equipment.