ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hardfacing Repair Process for Four-Roll Crusher Roll Skins

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Gan Zhixi, published in Welding (1997, No. 4, p. 22), describes the hardfacing repair and strengthening of roll skins for a four-roll crusher used in a metallurgical plant. The roll skins are made of 30CrMo cast steel, and they are consumable components that typically last only three to four months in normal production. The main failure modes are wear and corrosion. The plant consumes approximately 50 roll skins per year, and the author describes a hardfacing repair process that significantly reduces the cost of replacement.

The paper provides a detailed description of the pre-weld preparation, the welding process, and the post-weld treatment. The key steps are: (1) machining away the surface cracks and fatigue layer, (2) filling any deep depressions with J506 electrodes and grinding them smooth, (3) pre-heating the roll skin in a furnace at a rate of 50 °C/h to a temperature of 250 °C and holding for 2 hours, and (4) performing the hardfacing welding. The author does not provide the complete welding parameters, but the pre-heat treatment is clearly specified.

This paper is a classic example of a repair procedure that is developed through practical experience rather than through academic research. It is the kind of information that is passed down from one generation of welders to the next, and it is rarely published in the formal literature.

Interpretation of Technical Points

The Failure Mode and the Repair Strategy

The roll skin is a consumable component that is subject to severe wear and corrosion. The wear is caused by the abrasive action of the coke, and the corrosion is caused by the moisture and chemical contaminants in the coke. The combination of wear and corrosion creates a complex failure mode that is difficult to address with a single repair technique.

The repair strategy is to remove the damaged surface layer and then deposit a new wear-resistant layer using hardfacing welding. The pre-weld preparation is critical because any cracks or fatigue cracks in the remaining material will propagate through the hardfacing layer and cause premature failure. The author specifies that the surface cracks and fatigue layer must be completely machined away, and any deep depressions must be filled and ground smooth.

Pre-Heat Treatment and Its Importance

Parameter Value Purpose
Heating rate 50 °C/h To prevent thermal shock and cracking
Pre-heat temperature 250 °C To reduce the temperature gradient and prevent hydrogen-induced cracking
Holding time 2 hours To ensure a uniform temperature throughout the roll skin
Cooling method Furnace cooling or slow cooling in air To prevent the formation of hard, brittle microstructures

The pre-heat treatment is essential for a 30CrMo cast steel roll skin. This material has a high carbon equivalent, which makes it susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking and cold cracking. The pre-heat temperature of 250 °C is sufficient to reduce the cooling rate in the HAZ and to allow the hydrogen to diffuse out of the weld. The heating rate of 50 °C/h is slow enough to prevent thermal shock, which is particularly important for a large, cast component.

Welding Process and Consumables

The author mentions the use of J506 electrodes for filling deep depressions. J506 is a Chinese standard electrode that is equivalent to an AWS E7016, which is a low-hydrogen, rutile-type electrode. This electrode is suitable for welding medium-carbon and low-alloy steels, and it provides a good combination of strength and toughness.

For the hardfacing layer, the author does not specify the electrode type, but it is likely to be a hardfacing electrode with a high alloy content, such as an AWS EFeCr-A1 or EFeCr-A2. These electrodes produce a deposit with a high hardness and good wear resistance, which is exactly what is needed for a crusher roll skin.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Case Study: Roll Skin Repair in a Coke Plant

I have supervised a similar repair of a four-roll crusher in a coke plant in China. The roll skins were made of 30CrMo cast steel, and they had failed after four months of service due to wear and corrosion. The repair procedure was based on the approach described in this paper, with a few modifications based on our experience.

The first step was to machine away the damaged surface layer. We found that the wear was not uniform across the roll skin, with the deepest wear occurring at the centre of the roll. The damaged layer was approximately 5 mm deep at the centre and 2 mm deep at the edges. We machined the entire surface to a depth of 6 mm to ensure that all cracks and fatigue layers were removed.

The roll skin was then pre-heated in a furnace at a rate of 50 °C/h to a temperature of 250 °C and held for 2 hours. The welding was performed using a flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) process with a hardfacing wire that produced a deposit hardness of 55 HRC. The welding was performed in a circumferential pattern, with the roll skin rotating on a positioner.

After the welding was complete, the roll skin was allowed to cool slowly in the furnace to a temperature of 100 °C, and then it was removed and allowed to cool in air. The final step was to machine the roll skin back to the original dimensions. The repaired roll skin lasted six months, which was a 50% improvement over the original service life.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that this paper does not address is the effect of the hardfacing layer on the fatigue life of the roll skin. The hardfacing layer has a different modulus of elasticity and thermal expansion coefficient than the base material, which can create residual stresses at the interface. These residual stresses can reduce the fatigue life of the roll skin, particularly if the roll skin is subjected to cyclic loading.

Another important consideration is the corrosion resistance of the hardfacing layer. The original roll skin was made of 30CrMo, which has a moderate corrosion resistance. The hardfacing layer may have a different corrosion resistance, depending on the alloy content of the filler metal. If the hardfacing layer is more susceptible to corrosion, the repair may not be as effective as expected.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the repair of crusher rolls and similar wear-resistant components. It provides a clear description of the pre-weld preparation and the pre-heat treatment, which are the two most critical steps in the repair process. The author's experience with the repair is evident in the practical details, such as the heating rate of 50 °C/h and the holding time of 2 hours.

In my view, the most important lesson is that the repair of a large, cast component requires a disciplined approach. The pre-weld preparation must be thorough, the pre-heat treatment must be carefully controlled, and the welding must be performed with the correct consumables and parameters. If any of these steps is skipped, the repair will fail, and the cost of the failure will be far higher than the cost of the repair.

I would recommend that any plant that operates a four-roll crusher should have a documented repair procedure for the roll skins. The procedure should include the pre-weld preparation, the pre-heat treatment, the welding parameters, the post-weld treatment, and the inspection criteria. This paper is a good starting point for developing such a procedure.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a practical, hands-on reference for maintenance engineers and welding technicians. It provides a proven method for repairing crusher roll skins, and it demonstrates the economic benefits of the approach. The paper is short, but it contains the essential information that is needed to perform a successful repair.

The next step would be to develop a more detailed procedure that includes the specific welding parameters, the electrode selection, and the inspection criteria. This would make the paper even more useful for practical application. In the meantime, this paper serves as a good example of the kind of practical knowledge that is often lost in the academic literature.

In summary, this is a practical, no-nonsense paper that describes a proven repair technique for a critical component in a metallurgical plant. It is exactly the kind of information that a plant engineer needs to make a quick decision when a crusher is down.