Deformation Behavior of a Surfaced Bimetal During Cold Upsetting
Introduction
This paper from 2017 is a more academic study, but its findings have direct implications for the manufacturing of bimetallic components. The authors investigate the deformation behavior of a bimetallic material produced by plasma transferred arc (PTA) surfacing, specifically during cold upsetting. The goal is to determine whether such a material can be forged or formed after surfacing. This is a critical question for industries that want to combine the wear resistance of a hardfacing layer with the toughness of a steel substrate, and then form the composite into a final shape.
Technical Analysis of the Deformation Behavior
The paper's key findings are that the hardness of the surfaced layer is significantly higher than that of the base material, and that the weakest region is at the fusion line. This is a classic result for any surfacing process. The fusion line is where the base material and the weld metal mix, and it often contains a high concentration of carbides or other brittle phases. The paper's use of microhardness testing to identify this region is a good example of how metallographic analysis can be used to understand a material's behavior.
The paper also finds that during cold upsetting, the base material deforms first, while the surfaced layer resists deformation. This is expected, as the harder surfaced layer has a higher yield strength. However, the paper's more interesting finding is that the surfaced layer itself can undergo plastic deformation if the compression is high enough. This is a crucial insight, as it suggests that the bimetallic material has the potential to be formed into complex shapes without cracking the hardfacing layer.
| Region | Microhardness (HV) | Deformation Behavior |
|---|---|---|
| Base material | Lower (e.g., 200–300 HV) | Deforms first |
| Fusion line | Lowest (e.g., 150–250 HV) | Weakest, potential crack site |
| Surfaced layer | Higher (e.g., 400–600 HV) | Resists deformation, but can deform at high strain |
The paper's finding that the fusion line is the weakest region is a critical warning for any manufacturing process that involves forming a bimetallic material. If the fusion line is not strong enough, it will be the first place to crack during forming. The veteran's experience confirms this: in any bimetallic component, the fusion line is the Achilles' heel. The paper's suggestion that the surfaced layer has some plasticity is encouraging, but it must be balanced against the risk of cracking at the fusion line.
Practical Considerations and Implications for Manufacturing
The paper's findings have direct implications for the manufacturing of bimetallic components. If you want to use a surfaced bimetallic material in a forging or forming process, you must pay careful attention to the fusion line. The paper suggests that the surfaced layer can deform, but the fusion line may not be able to accommodate the strain. This means that the forming process must be designed to minimize strain at the fusion line, or the fusion line must be strengthened through a post-weld heat treatment.
In my experience, the most common failure mode for a bimetallic component during forming is a crack that initiates at the fusion line and propagates into the surfaced layer. This is a difficult problem to solve, as the fusion line is inherently a region of metallurgical discontinuity. The paper's approach of using a PTA surfacing process is a good choice, as it produces a relatively thin and uniform surfaced layer with a controlled dilution. However, the fusion line will always be a weak point, and the forming process must be designed accordingly.
Study Insights and Implications
The paper's value lies in its systematic investigation of a complex problem. For the manufacturing engineer, the key takeaway is that bimetallic materials produced by surfacing can be formed, but the forming process must be carefully controlled to avoid cracking at the fusion line. The paper also highlights the importance of microhardness testing as a tool for understanding the properties of a bimetallic material. The veteran's judgment is that the paper's findings are sound, but the practical application is limited by the inherent weakness of the fusion line. For high-volume production, it may be more economical to use a different manufacturing route, such as a solid bimetallic bar or a clad plate, rather than relying on a surfaced layer.
In conclusion, the paper is a valuable contribution to the understanding of bimetallic materials. It provides a clear picture of the deformation behavior and identifies the fusion line as the critical region. The paper's findings are a useful guide for any engineer considering the use of surfaced bimetallic materials in a forming process, and they reinforce the fundamental rule that the interface between two different materials is always the weakest link.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd