Temperature Field and Hardness Evolution in Bimetallic Surfaced Hot Forging Dies
Background and the Service Environment
Hot forging dies operate in one of the most demanding environments in metal forming. They are subjected to repeated thermal cycling, high mechanical loads, and abrasive wear at elevated temperatures. The die surface can reach temperatures well above 500°C during the forging cycle, and this thermal load is a primary driver of die failure.
This paper by Li Mengyao and colleagues from Chongqing University investigates the temperature field in a cast steel substrate with bimetallic surfacing, using Deform-3D simulation and hardness measurements before and after service. The work addresses a fundamental question: what is the actual temperature distribution in the die during continuous operation, and how does it affect the hardness of each layer?
Simulation Results - Temperature Distribution
The Deform-3D simulation modeled the die in continuous service, with repeated forging cycles. The results show a clear temperature gradient from the surface to the substrate:
| Zone | Temperature Range | Hardness Change After Service |
|---|---|---|
| Surface layer | 550-650°C | Max drop ~250 HV0.5 |
| Near-surface layer | 470-550°C | Drop ~40 HV0.5 |
| Substrate (base) | ~315°C constant | Negligible change |
The surface layer experiences the most severe thermal load, reaching 550-650°C during continuous operation. This is well above the tempering temperature of many tool steels and hardfacing alloys, which explains the significant hardness drop. The near-surface layer is somewhat cooler at 470-550°C, and the hardness drop is correspondingly smaller. The substrate remains at a relatively constant 315°C, which is below the temperature where significant softening occurs.
Hardness Evolution and Its Implications
The hardness measurements before and after service reveal a critical insight: the surface layer softens dramatically during service. A maximum drop of approximately 250 HV0.5 represents a substantial loss of hardness, which directly translates to reduced wear resistance and shorter die life.
The mechanism is over-tempering. The surface layer, initially hardened to a high hardness level, is subjected to temperatures above its tempering threshold for extended periods. This causes the martensitic or bainitic microstructure to over-temper, reducing hardness and increasing ductility. The result is a softer, less wear-resistant surface that is more susceptible to plastic deformation and abrasive wear.
The near-surface layer, at 470-550°C, undergoes a smaller hardness drop of about 40 HV0.5. This is still significant but less severe than the surface layer. The substrate, at a constant 315°C, shows negligible hardness change - this temperature is below the threshold for significant softening in most steels.
Practical Implications for Die Design and Surfacing
- The surface layer must be designed to withstand 550-650°C without excessive softening. This means selecting a hardfacing alloy with adequate hot hardness and tempering resistance. Alloys containing strong carbide formers such as vanadium, niobium, or tungsten are preferred, as they maintain hardness at elevated temperatures.
- The initial hardness of the surface layer should be higher than the final required hardness. If the die surface will soften by 250 HV0.5 during service, the initial hardness must be correspondingly higher to maintain adequate wear resistance at end of life.
- The transition layer must be designed to maintain its properties at 470-550°C. This layer provides the bond between the surface hardfacing and the substrate, and its properties must remain stable at the operating temperatures.
- The substrate temperature of 315°C is manageable but not negligible. While the substrate does not soften significantly, the thermal stress from the temperature gradient between surface and substrate can contribute to cracking or delamination.
- Die life is thermally limited. The primary failure mode is likely thermal fatigue or over-tempering, not mechanical overload. Die design should focus on reducing surface temperature through cooling channels, proper die geometry, and selection of materials with high thermal conductivity.
Lessons for Hot Work Tooling and Forming Applications
This work has direct relevance beyond forging dies. The same principles apply to hot forming rolls, mandrels, extrusion dies, and other hot work tooling used in pipe and tube manufacturing. When I specify hardfacing for hot work tools, I always ask: what is the operating temperature, and how will the hardness change over time?
The answer determines the alloy selection. If the surface temperature will exceed 550°C, I need an alloy with good hot hardness - typically one containing vanadium, tungsten, or niobium carbides. If the temperature is lower, a simpler alloy may suffice. The key is to match the alloy to the actual service temperature, not just the initial hardness.
Summary
This paper provides valuable data on the temperature distribution and hardness evolution in bimetallic surfaced hot forging dies. The simulation results show a steep thermal gradient from the surface (550-650°C) to the substrate (315°C), with corresponding hardness drops of up to 250 HV0.5 in the surface layer. The practical implication is clear: die and tooling design must account for the thermal environment, and hardfacing alloys must be selected based on their hot hardness and tempering resistance. For anyone involved in hot work tooling, this is a useful reference that connects thermal analysis to material selection and service life prediction.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd