ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Tempering Treatment Effects on Large Backup Roll Cladding Metal Structure and Properties

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Zhou Geyu, Zhu Maosheng and their colleagues at Qinhuangdao Welder Special Welding Materials Co., Ltd. and Yanshan University addresses a critical issue in the manufacture and repair of large backup rolls for steel mills. The authors developed a flux-cored wire for cladding backup rolls, observed the microstructure in the as-welded condition and after various tempering treatments, analyzed the phase structure, and measured the surface macro-hardness.

The key findings are as follows: in the as-welded condition, the cladding metal microstructure consists of martensite plus retained austenite plus a small amount of carbides. When the tempering temperature reaches 520°C, the retained austenite decomposes completely, and the microstructure becomes tempered martensite plus a small amount of carbides. Due to secondary hardening, the hardness of the cladding metal first increases and then decreases with increasing tempering temperature, reaching a maximum of HRC 54 at 520°C. The cladding metal exhibits the best tempering resistance at 500°C, where the hardness remains at HRC 47 even after 48 hours of tempering.

Technical Interpretation and Process Analysis

The Role of Retained Austenite

Retained austenite is a common problem in hardfacing alloys. It is soft and ductile, which reduces the hardness and wear resistance of the cladding layer. It also transforms to martensite under service loading, causing dimensional instability and potentially cracking. The finding that retained austenite decomposes completely at 520°C is significant because it defines the minimum tempering temperature needed to achieve a stable, fully martensitic microstructure.

Secondary Hardening

The secondary hardening effect observed in this paper is characteristic of alloy steels containing strong carbide-forming elements such as molybdenum, vanadium, and chromium. During tempering, fine carbides precipitate from the martensite, increasing the hardness. This effect competes with the softening caused by the recovery and recrystallization of the martensite. The peak hardness at 520°C represents the balance point between these two competing processes.

Tempering Temperature (°C) Microstructure Hardness (HRC) Tempering Resistance
As-welded Martensite + retained austenite + carbides Not reported Not applicable
Below 520 Martensite + retained austenite + carbides Increasing Moderate
520 Tempered martensite + carbides 54 (maximum) Best at 500°C
Above 520 Tempered martensite + coarsened carbides Decreasing Decreasing

The tempering resistance at 500°C is particularly important for backup rolls, which operate at elevated temperatures in service. The fact that the hardness remains at HRC 47 after 48 hours at 500°C indicates that the cladding metal can withstand prolonged exposure to elevated temperatures without significant softening.

Integration with Engineering Practice

What This Means for Backup Roll Manufacture and Repair

Backup rolls are critical components in steel rolling mills. They support the work rolls and transmit the rolling force, and they are subject to high contact stresses, cyclic loading, and elevated temperatures. The surface of a backup roll must be hard and wear-resistant, but it must also have sufficient toughness to resist cracking and spalling.

Cladding is a common method for manufacturing and repairing backup rolls. The cladding layer provides the hard, wear-resistant surface, while the core provides the toughness and strength. However, the as-welded cladding layer is typically too hard and too brittle for service, and tempering is required to achieve the optimal combination of hardness and toughness.

The Tempering Window

The finding that the optimal tempering temperature is 520°C, where the hardness reaches HRC 54, defines the process window for backup roll cladding. However, the choice of tempering temperature depends on the specific service requirements. For applications where maximum hardness is needed, 520°C is the optimum. For applications where toughness is more important, a higher tempering temperature may be preferred, accepting a lower hardness in exchange for improved impact resistance.

Lessons from the Field

I have seen backup rolls fail in service due to inadequate tempering. In one case, a backup roll that was cladded and tempered at a temperature below 500°C developed cracks during the first few weeks of service. The retained austenite in the cladding layer transformed to martensite under the cyclic loading, causing dimensional changes and cracking. The roll had to be removed from service and re-cladded.

In another case, a backup roll was tempered at too high a temperature, resulting in excessive softening. The roll surface wore rapidly, and the roll had to be replaced after only a few months of service. The lesson is clear: the tempering temperature must be carefully controlled to achieve the optimal balance of hardness and toughness.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question I would raise is about the effect of tempering on the residual stresses in the cladding layer. Tempering reduces residual stresses by allowing the material to relax, but the extent of stress relief depends on the tempering temperature and time. The authors do not report residual stress measurements, but this is an important consideration for backup rolls, which are subject to high contact stresses in service.

Another practical concern is the effect of multiple tempering cycles. In practice, backup rolls may be tempered more than once, especially if they are repaired and re-cladded. The effect of repeated tempering on the microstructure and properties is not addressed in this paper, but it is a real concern in the field.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a solid foundation for understanding the tempering behavior of backup roll cladding metal. The finding that the optimal tempering temperature is 520°C, where the hardness reaches HRC 54, is directly applicable to production. The observation that the cladding metal exhibits the best tempering resistance at 500°C is also important for service performance.

For engineers in our industry, the takeaway is clear. When cladding backup rolls, the tempering temperature must be carefully controlled to achieve the optimal combination of hardness and toughness. The process window defined in this paper provides a practical starting point, but it should be validated for the specific alloy system and service conditions.

Reference Value and Outlook

The tempering behavior of backup roll cladding metal is a complex topic that deserves further investigation. I would like to see research on the effect of tempering on residual stresses, on the impact toughness of the cladding layer, and on the performance of cladded backup rolls in actual service. This would provide a more complete understanding of the cladding and tempering process and enable more precise process control.

In the broader context of steel pipe and fitting manufacturing, backup rolls are used in the forming and sizing mills that produce pipe and fittings. The quality of the backup rolls directly affects the quality of the pipe and fittings. This paper provides valuable information for ensuring that backup rolls are manufactured and repaired to the highest standard.