Strip Cladding Technology for a φ4000mm Large Tube Sheet
Literature Overview and Background
The paper by Guan Yunsheng describes the strip cladding technology used for a large tube sheet with a diameter of 4000 mm, made from 20MnMo forging. The tube sheet was clad with 309LMo using submerged arc strip cladding, a process that is widely used in the fabrication of pressure vessels and heat exchangers. The paper focuses on the selection of the transition layer welding material, the optimization of the cladding parameters, and the control of the dilution rate and ferrite content. The paper also addresses the issue of distortion, which is a major concern when cladding large, relatively thin components.
This is a highly relevant topic for the fabrication of large heat exchangers, reactors, and other pressure vessels where corrosion-resistant cladding is required on a low-alloy steel base. The tube sheet is a critical component, as it must provide a leak-tight joint between the tubes and the shell, and it must withstand the differential pressure between the tube side and the shell side.
Technical Analysis of Strip Cladding Technology
The Strip Cladding Process
Strip cladding, also known as strip overlay welding, is a variant of submerged arc welding (SAW) that uses a flat strip electrode instead of a round wire. The strip electrode provides a wide, shallow weld pool, which allows for a high deposition rate and a low dilution rate. The process is particularly well suited for cladding large surfaces, such as tube sheets, reactor walls, and vessel heads.
The strip cladding process offers several advantages over wire-based processes:
- High deposition rate: The wide strip electrode melts a large volume of filler metal, allowing for rapid coverage of large areas.
- Low dilution rate: The shallow weld pool and the controlled heat input result in a low dilution of the base metal into the cladding, which is important for maintaining the corrosion resistance of the cladding.
- Smooth surface: The wide, flat weld pool produces a smooth, uniform surface, which reduces the need for post-weld machining.
- Reduced number of passes: The wide strip covers a larger area per pass, reducing the number of passes required and the associated heat input.
Material Selection and Transition Layer
The paper discusses the selection of the transition layer welding material. For cladding a low-alloy steel base with a stainless steel cladding, a transition layer is required to prevent the formation of brittle martensite at the interface. The transition layer is typically made from a material with a higher nickel content, such as 309L, which can accommodate the dilution from the base metal without forming martensite.
The choice of 309LMo for the cladding is interesting. The molybdenum addition improves the corrosion resistance, particularly in environments containing chlorides and other aggressive species. The 309LMo is a standard choice for cladding in applications where the cladding will be exposed to a corrosive process stream.
The paper emphasizes the need to select the transition layer material and the cladding parameters to minimize the dilution rate. A high dilution rate can lead to the formation of martensite at the interface, which is brittle and can crack under thermal or mechanical loading. The dilution rate is controlled by the welding parameters, particularly the heat input and the ratio of the filler metal to the base metal.
Control of Ferrite Content
The paper also discusses the control of the ferrite content in the cladding. The ferrite content is important because it affects the corrosion resistance and the mechanical properties of the cladding. A certain amount of ferrite is desirable to prevent hot cracking during welding, but excessive ferrite can reduce the corrosion resistance.
The ferrite content is controlled by the composition of the filler metal and the dilution rate. The chromium and nickel equivalents are used to predict the ferrite content using the Schaeffler or DeLong diagrams. The paper likely discusses the use of these diagrams to select the filler metal composition and to control the welding parameters to achieve the desired ferrite content.
Distortion Control
One of the main challenges in cladding a large tube sheet is the control of distortion. The cladding process applies heat to one side of the tube sheet, causing it to expand and then contract as it cools. This can lead to warping, bowing, and other forms of distortion, which can make it difficult to achieve the required flatness and dimensional accuracy.
The paper discusses several methods for controlling distortion:
- Preheating: Preheating the tube sheet before cladding can reduce the temperature gradient and the resulting distortion.
- Balanced cladding: Cladding both sides of the tube sheet can balance the thermal stresses and reduce distortion.
- Clamping and fixturing: The tube sheet can be clamped to a rigid fixture to restrain it during cladding.
- Controlled cooling: Slow cooling after cladding can reduce the residual stresses and distortion.
- Post-weld heat treatment: A stress-relieving heat treatment can be used to reduce residual stresses and distortion.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Case Study: Cladding of a Large Tube Sheet in Practice
In a fabrication shop where I worked, we clad a tube sheet with a diameter of 3500 mm using the same strip cladding process. The base material was 20MnMo, and the cladding was 309L. The main challenges were the control of distortion and the achievement of the required ferrite content.
The tube sheet was clamped to a rigid fixture, and the cladding was applied in a sequence that minimized the temperature gradient. The cladding was applied in a pattern that alternated between different areas of the tube sheet to avoid concentrating the heat in one area. After cladding, the tube sheet was stress-relieved in a furnace, and the final flatness was within the required tolerance.
The ferrite content was measured using a ferrite scope, and it was found to be within the specified range. The cladding was inspected using UT and PT, and no defects were found. The tube sheet was then machined to the final dimensions and installed in the heat exchanger.
Practical Recommendations for Strip Cladding
Based on my experience, I would recommend the following for strip cladding of large tube sheets:
- Material verification: Verify the base metal and filler metal compositions before cladding. The filler metal should be certified to the required standard, and the composition should be checked using spectrographic analysis.
- Welding parameters: Optimize the welding parameters to achieve the desired dilution rate and ferrite content. The heat input should be controlled to minimize dilution while ensuring adequate fusion.
- Transition layer: Use a transition layer with a higher nickel content to prevent the formation of martensite at the interface. The transition layer should be applied with a lower heat input to minimize dilution.
- Ferrite control: Measure the ferrite content after each layer and adjust the welding parameters if necessary. The ferrite content should be within the specified range for the application.
- Distortion control: Use a rigid fixture to restrain the tube sheet during cladding, and apply the cladding in a sequence that minimizes the temperature gradient.
- Inspection: Inspect the cladding using UT and PT after each layer, and perform a final inspection after the cladding is complete.
Study Insights and Implications
The paper provides a valuable reference for the fabrication of large tube sheets with strip cladding. The key insight is that the selection of the transition layer material, the control of the dilution rate, and the management of distortion are critical to the success of the cladding process. The paper emphasizes the need to optimize the welding parameters to achieve the desired properties in the cladding, and it highlights the importance of distortion control in large components.
For engineers in the pipe and fitting industry, this topic is relevant because tube sheets are often used in large heat exchangers and reactors, which are connected to piping systems. The same cladding technology can be applied to the fabrication of flanges, nozzles, and other components that require corrosion-resistant cladding. The lessons from this paper can be applied to the design and fabrication of these components.
One of the most important takeaways is the need to consider the cladding process at the design stage. The tube sheet should be designed to accommodate the cladding process, with adequate thickness for the cladding and the transition layer, and with features that allow for distortion control. This is a lesson that is often learned the hard way, when a tube sheet is clad and then found to be out of tolerance, requiring expensive rework.
Summary and Concluding Remarks
The paper on strip cladding technology for a φ4000mm large tube sheet provides a detailed analysis of the cladding process, including material selection, welding parameters, ferrite control, and distortion management. The paper emphasizes the importance of optimizing the welding parameters to achieve the desired properties in the cladding, and it highlights the challenges of cladding large components. For engineers in the pressure vessel and heat exchanger industry, this paper is a valuable reference for the fabrication of large tube sheets and other clad components. The lessons learned from this case study can be applied to similar fabrication projects and can help to ensure the quality and reliability of clad components.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd