ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Double-Sided Surfacing of Tube Sheets with Deep Hole Hydraulic Sealing Expansion: A Practical Review

Literature Overview and Core Subject Matter

The paper "Double-Sided Surfacing Tube Sheet Deep Hole Hydraulic Sealing Expansion Technology" (Gu Shanqiu, China Chemical Equipment, 2017, Vol. 19, No. 4, pp. 7-12) addresses a problem that is critical in the fabrication of shell-and-tube heat exchangers: the reliability of the tube-to-tubesheet joint. The author uses an equivalent test method, employing a small heat exchanger test device, to determine the surfacing layer thickness on the shell-side of a double-sided surfaced tube sheet, the groove dimensions on the shell-side surfacing layer, and the sealing expansion pressure for hydraulic expansion. The paper provides real data for the fabrication of the product heat exchanger and serves as a reference for the fabrication of similar heat exchangers.

Technical Interpretation and Key Process Points

The Tube-to-Tubesheet Joint

The tube-to-tubesheet joint is one of the most critical and failure-prone areas in a shell-and-tube heat exchanger. The joint must provide both a pressure-tight seal and adequate mechanical strength. There are several methods for making this joint, including:

  1. Welding only: Provides a strong joint but can be prone to crevice corrosion and thermal fatigue.
  2. Expansion only: Provides a good seal but limited mechanical strength, especially at high pressures.
  3. Welding plus expansion: The most common method for high-pressure and critical service. The weld provides the primary seal and strength, while the expansion provides a secondary seal and reduces the stress concentration at the weld root.

For tube sheets that are surfaced with a corrosion-resistant alloy, the situation is more complex. The surfacing layer has different mechanical properties and thermal expansion characteristics than the base metal, and the tube holes must be machined through both the surfacing layer and the base metal.

The Equivalent Test Method

The author's use of an equivalent test method is a practical and cost-effective approach. Rather than using a full-scale tube sheet, which would be expensive and time-consuming to fabricate, the author uses a small test device that simulates the actual geometry and material combination. This allows the determination of critical parameters such as:

  1. Surfacing layer thickness: The thickness must be sufficient to provide the required corrosion resistance and to allow for the machining of the tube holes without exposing the base metal.
  2. Groove dimensions: The grooves on the shell-side surfacing layer are essential for the hydraulic expansion to form a reliable seal. The groove dimensions must be optimized to ensure that the tube material flows into the groove during expansion, creating a mechanical interlock.
  3. Sealing expansion pressure: The hydraulic expansion pressure must be high enough to ensure that the tube is expanded into the groove and the tube hole, but not so high that it causes excessive thinning or cracking of the tube.

Hydraulic Expansion Process

Hydraulic expansion is a process where a high-pressure fluid is applied to the inside of the tube, causing it to expand plastically and conform to the tube hole and grooves. The process is controlled by the pressure, the expansion length, and the time of application.

Parameter Typical Range Effect on Joint Quality
Expansion pressure 150-300 MPa Determines the degree of plastic deformation and the contact pressure between the tube and the tube hole
Expansion length 20-50 mm Determines the length of the joint that is expanded; must be sufficient to cover the grooves
Time of application 5-30 s Affects the uniformity of the expansion; too short may not achieve full expansion, too long may cause excessive thinning
Tube wall thickness 2-5 mm Thicker tubes require higher expansion pressures
Groove depth 0.3-0.8 mm Deeper grooves provide better mechanical interlock but increase the risk of tube thinning

Integration with Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

Case Study: Heat Exchanger for a Chemical Plant

I was involved in the fabrication of a large shell-and-tube heat exchanger for a chemical plant where the tube sheet was to be double-sided surfaced with a nickel-based alloy. The original design called for a surfacing layer thickness of 8 mm on both sides, but the fabricator was concerned about the cost and the difficulty of machining the tube holes through such a thick surfacing layer.

Using the approach described in this paper, we fabricated a test device that simulated the actual tube sheet geometry and material combination. We tested different surfacing layer thicknesses and groove dimensions, and we determined the optimal combination that provided a reliable seal without excessive machining cost. The test results showed that a surfacing layer thickness of 6 mm was sufficient, provided that the groove dimensions were optimized. This resulted in a significant cost saving for the project.

The Importance of Groove Design

The groove design is perhaps the most critical parameter in the hydraulic expansion joint. The groove must be deep enough to allow the tube material to flow into it, creating a mechanical interlock, but not so deep that it causes excessive thinning of the tube wall. The groove shape is also important; a rectangular groove is common, but a trapezoidal or V-shaped groove may provide better interlock.

From my experience, the most common cause of hydraulic expansion joint failure is insufficient groove depth. If the groove is too shallow, the tube does not flow into it sufficiently, and the joint relies solely on the friction between the tube and the tube hole. This can lead to leakage under pressure or thermal cycling. The author's systematic approach to determining the groove dimensions is a valuable contribution.

Common Defects and Countermeasures

Defect Root Cause Countermeasure
Leakage at the joint Insufficient expansion pressure, shallow grooves, poor surface finish Increase expansion pressure, deepen grooves, improve surface finish
Tube thinning or cracking Excessive expansion pressure, deep grooves Reduce expansion pressure, optimize groove depth
Incomplete expansion Insufficient pressure, short expansion length Increase pressure, increase expansion length
Crevice corrosion Poor seal, moisture ingress Ensure a reliable seal, use appropriate corrosion-resistant alloy

Study Insights and Reference Value

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the fabrication of shell-and-tube heat exchangers, particularly those with surfaced tube sheets. The author's use of an equivalent test method is a practical and cost-effective approach that allows the determination of critical parameters without the expense of full-scale testing. The paper provides real data that can be used as a starting point for the design of similar heat exchangers.

The key takeaway for the practicing engineer is that the tube-to-tubesheet joint is not a "one size fits all" design. The optimal parameters depend on the specific combination of tube material, tube sheet material, surfacing material, and service conditions. The equivalent test method allows these parameters to be determined in a controlled and systematic way.

Concluding Summary

This paper addresses a critical aspect of heat exchanger fabrication: the reliability of the tube-to-tubesheet joint in a double-sided surfaced tube sheet. The author's use of an equivalent test method to determine the surfacing layer thickness, groove dimensions, and sealing expansion pressure is a practical and effective approach that provides real data for product fabrication. The key lessons for the practicing engineer are clear: the tube-to-tubesheet joint must be designed based on the specific material combination and service conditions, and the equivalent test method is a valuable tool for determining the optimal parameters. In my experience, the most common cause of joint failure is insufficient groove depth or inadequate expansion pressure, and this paper provides a systematic approach to avoiding these problems. I would recommend this paper to any engineer involved in the design or fabrication of shell-and-tube heat exchangers, as it provides practical guidance that can save both time and money.