Hardfacing of High Temperature Blowdown Valve Sealing Surfaces in Blast Furnace Service
1. Literature Overview and Core Content
The paper by Yang Lingchuan and colleagues, published in Welding Technology in 1999, addresses a practical problem: premature failure of high temperature blowdown valve sealing surfaces in blast furnace service. The authors describe a welding procedure for depositing a high hardness wear-resistant alloy on the sealing surfaces, and report that the approach significantly extended valve service life and generated substantial economic benefits.
This is a short, practice-oriented paper that does not delve deeply into metallurgical theory. However, for an engineer who has spent time in steel plants, the problem it addresses is very familiar. Blast furnace blowdown valves operate in an extremely hostile environment: high temperature, abrasive dust-laden gas, frequent pressure cycles and occasional thermal shock. The sealing surfaces must maintain a tight shutoff to prevent gas leakage, which is both a safety and an efficiency issue.
2. Technical Points and Service Conditions
2.1 Blowdown Valve Service Environment
A blast furnace blowdown valve is typically located on the gas cleaning system, downstream of the dust catcher and scrubber. Its function is to periodically release pressure or to isolate sections of the gas cleaning plant. The service conditions are:
| Parameter | Typical Range | Impact on Sealing Surface |
|---|---|---|
| Operating temperature | 150–350 °C | Thermal fatigue, oxidation |
| Gas composition | CO, CO2, N2, dust particles | Abrasive wear, erosion |
| Dust loading | 5–50 g/Nm³ | Severe erosion on sealing edges |
| Pressure cycles | Frequent, 0–0.3 MPa | Mechanical fatigue, fretting |
| Shutoff differential pressure | 0.1–0.3 MPa | Sealing surface stress |
The sealing surfaces are subjected to a combination of abrasive wear from dust particles carried by the gas stream, erosion at the sealing edges due to high velocity gas flow during blowdown, and thermal fatigue from repeated heating and cooling cycles. The result is premature leakage, which forces valve replacement or re-machining.
2.2 Why Hardfacing is the Preferred Solution
There are several approaches to extending sealing surface life:
| Approach | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|
| Hardfacing with wear-resistant alloy | High hardness, good wear resistance, repairable | Requires skilled welder, distortion control needed |
| Nitriding or carburising | Good surface hardness, no distortion | Thin case, limited wear allowance |
| Ceramic coating (plasma spray) | Very high hardness, good erosion resistance | Brittle, poor thermal shock resistance, coating spalling |
| Replaceable seat inserts | Easy maintenance | Higher cost, sealing performance depends on insert quality |
| Surface hardening (laser or induction) | Localised hardening, minimal distortion | Limited depth, complex geometry difficult |
Hardfacing is the most practical and cost-effective approach for blast furnace blowdown valves. It allows the use of a relatively cheap base material for the valve body and applies a wear-resistant alloy only where it is needed. The hardfaced deposit can be re-machined and repaired, which is a significant advantage for valves that are already installed.
3. Welding Procedure and Process Control
3.1 Recommended Welding Parameters
Based on the paper and my experience with similar applications, the following welding parameters are typical for hardfacing valve sealing surfaces:
| Parameter | Recommended Range | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Welding process | SMAW (manual arc) | Most flexible, suitable for field repair |
| Electrode type | High hardness Fe-Cr-C or Ni-Cr-B-Si | Depending on service temperature |
| Electrode diameter | 3.2–4.0 mm | For sealing surfaces, 3.2 mm preferred |
| Welding current | 90–140 A | Adjust for electrode diameter |
| Arc voltage | 20–26 V | Short arc |
| Preheat temperature | 200–300 °C | For Cr-Mo valve bodies |
| Interpass temperature | 250–350 °C | Control to prevent cracking |
| Deposit thickness | 3–5 mm | After machining, 2–3 mm remains |
| Post-weld heat treatment | Stress relief at 600–650 °C | For thick sections or high restraint |
3.2 Common Problems and Countermeasures
From my experience with valve hardfacing, the most common problems are:
| Problem | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Cracking of hardfaced layer | High hardness, high restraint, rapid cooling | Preheat, control interpass temperature, use buttering layer |
| Distortion of valve seat | Uneven heating, excessive deposit thickness | Use symmetrical welding sequence, use lower heat input, clamp the valve |
| Porosity | Moisture in electrode, dirty surface | Bake electrodes, clean and degrease surface |
| Lack of fusion | Low current, incorrect technique | Increase current, use proper welding technique |
| Undercut | Excessive current, incorrect electrode angle | Reduce current, adjust electrode angle |
| Spalling of deposit | Excessive hardness, impact loading | Use buffer layer, reduce hardness if impact is severe |
3.3 The Importance of the Buttering Layer
One technique that is often overlooked but is critical in valve hardfacing is the use of a buttering layer. When hardfacing a Cr-Mo or carbon steel valve body with a high hardness alloy, the first layer should be deposited using a more ductile electrode, such as a Ni-based or austenitic stainless steel electrode. This buttering layer:
- Provides a transition in hardness and thermal expansion coefficient between the base metal and the hardfacing alloy.
- Reduces the risk of cracking in the hardfaced layer due to the difference in thermal expansion.
- Prevents carbon migration from the base metal into the hardfacing alloy, which can cause brittle phases at the interface.
The buttering layer should be at least 2 mm thick and should be deposited using a low heat input technique to minimise dilution.
4. Engineering Practice and Economic Benefits
4.1 Real-World Case Study
In a typical blast furnace application, a blowdown valve sealing surface without hardfacing might last 6–12 months before requiring replacement. After hardfacing with a high hardness alloy, the service life can be extended to 24–36 months, depending on the severity of the service conditions.
| Parameter | Without Hardfacing | With Hardfacing |
|---|---|---|
| Valve service life | 6–12 months | 24–36 months |
| Valve replacement cost | High (complete valve replacement) | Moderate (re-machining and re-hardfacing) |
| Downtime | 8–16 hours per replacement | 4–8 hours per repair |
| Labour cost | High (skilled fitters, crane, rigging) | Moderate (welder and machinist) |
| Total annual cost | 2–4 valve replacements per year | 1 valve repair per year |
The economic benefit is substantial. In a plant with multiple blast furnaces, the savings from reduced valve replacement, reduced downtime and reduced maintenance labour can easily reach hundreds of thousands of dollars per year.
4.2 Quality Control and Inspection
For valve sealing surface hardfacing, the following inspection steps are essential:
| Inspection Step | Method | Acceptance Criteria |
|---|---|---|
| Surface preparation | Visual inspection | No oil, grease, rust or defects |
| Preheat temperature | Contact pyrometer or temperature indicating crayon | 200–300 °C |
| Interpass temperature | Contact pyrometer | 250–350 °C |
| Deposit thickness | Ultrasonic thickness gauge or dial gauge | 3–5 mm before machining |
| Surface hardness | Portable hardness tester (Leeb) | HRC ≥ 45 (or as specified) |
| Surface finish after machining | Surface roughness tester | Ra ≤ 0.8 μm (for sealing surface) |
| Leak test | Hydrostatic or pneumatic | No leakage at specified pressure |
| Dye penetrant test | PT per ASME Section V | No linear indications |
5. Study Insights and Reflections
This paper is a concise, practical contribution that addresses a real industrial problem. The authors have not attempted to develop a new alloy or to explore complex metallurgical phenomena; they have taken a known hardfacing approach and applied it to a specific valve application, with documented results.
The key lessons from this paper are:
- Understand the service environment before selecting the hardfacing alloy. A blowdown valve sealing surface experiences a combination of abrasive wear, erosion and thermal fatigue. The alloy must be selected based on the dominant wear mechanism, not just on hardness.
- The buttering layer is essential for high hardness deposits on Cr-Mo valve bodies. Many failures I have seen in valve hardfacing can be traced to the absence of a buttering layer, resulting in cracking at the interface.
- Process control is more important than alloy selection. A high quality alloy will fail if the welding procedure is not followed. Preheat, interpass temperature and post-weld cooling must be strictly controlled.
- The economic benefits of hardfacing are significant but are often underestimated. The cost of a hardfacing operation is typically 10–20% of the cost of a new valve, and the service life extension is often 2–4 times. This is a very favourable return on investment.
For the shop floor, the practical recommendation is to establish a hardfacing procedure for blowdown valve sealing surfaces that includes:
- A buttering layer of Ni-based or austenitic stainless steel electrode
- A hardfacing layer of Fe-Cr-C or Ni-Cr-B-Si alloy with hardness HRC 45–55
- Strict control of preheat and interpass temperature
- Post-weld stress relief where required
- Full inspection including hardness testing and dye penetrant examination
This approach has been proven in numerous applications and provides a reliable, cost-effective solution to a persistent maintenance problem. The paper is a valuable reference for plant engineers and maintenance personnel who deal with valve wear in blast furnace service.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd