Development of Surfacing Materials for Power Station Valve Sealing Surfaces
1. Literature Overview and Core Content
The paper by Gao Qingbao, Su Zhidong and Huang Jiansheng from Shenyang Valve Research Institute, published in 1995, describes the development of a new surfacing electrode for high temperature, high pressure power station valve sealing surfaces. The electrode uses an H08A mild steel core wire with alloying elements transferred through the flux coating. The deposit achieves a hardness of HRC ≥ 38, and the authors report that four key performance indicators — high temperature scratch resistance, hardness, microstructure stability and thermal fatigue resistance — meet or exceed those of HS111 cobalt-based alloy (Stellite No. 6). The surfacing processability and crack resistance are reported to be superior to HS111, and the material cost is significantly lower.
This paper is particularly interesting because it addresses a critical issue in power plant valves: the sealing surfaces must maintain their integrity at high temperature and high pressure, where the combination of thermal cycling, mechanical stress and aggressive media (steam, water, impurities) causes rapid degradation. The traditional solution has been cobalt-based alloys, but these are expensive and, in some applications, subject to supply constraints. The development of a cost-effective iron-based alternative with comparable performance is a significant achievement.
2. Technical Points and Alloy Design
2.1 Alloy Transfer Mechanism
The electrode design uses an H08A mild steel core wire with alloying elements added through the flux coating. This is a common approach for surfacing electrodes, as it allows the alloy composition to be adjusted without the need for expensive alloy core wires.
| Alloying Element | Typical Content in Deposit (%) | Function |
|---|---|---|
| C | 0.5–1.0 | Hardness, carbide formation |
| Cr | 12–18 | Hardness, corrosion resistance, carbide formation |
| Mo | 1–3 | Hardness, high temperature strength |
| W | 1–3 | Hardness, high temperature stability |
| V | 0.5–1.5 | Grain refinement, hardness |
| B | 0.1–0.5 | Hardness, boride formation |
| Ni | 1–3 | Toughness, austenite stabilisation |
| Fe | Balance | Matrix |
The alloy transfer through the flux coating has advantages and disadvantages:
| Aspect | Advantage | Disadvantage |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Uses cheap H08A core wire | Alloy recovery is less predictable |
| Flexibility | Easy to adjust composition | Alloying elements may be lost during arc transfer |
| Consistency | Uniform deposit composition | Requires careful control of flux composition |
| Processability | Good arc stability, smooth deposit | May produce more slag, requiring interpass cleaning |
2.2 Performance Comparison with Cobalt-Based Alloys
The paper reports that the new iron-based electrode meets or exceeds the performance of HS111 cobalt-based alloy in four key areas. This is a significant claim, and it is important to understand the basis for comparison.
| Performance Indicator | New Fe-Based Electrode | HS111 (Stellite No. 6) | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hardness (HRC) | ≥ 38 | 38–42 | Comparable |
| High temperature scratch resistance | Meets or exceeds HS111 | Reference | The Fe-based alloy forms hard carbides that resist scratching |
| Microstructure stability | Meets or exceeds HS111 | Reference | The Fe-based alloy maintains its microstructure at high temperature |
| Thermal fatigue resistance | Meets or exceeds HS111 | Reference | The Fe-based alloy has good thermal fatigue resistance |
| Processability | Superior | Reference | Better arc stability, less spatter, easier slag removal |
| Crack resistance | Superior | Reference | The Fe-based alloy is less prone to cracking |
| Cost | Significantly lower | Reference | The Fe-based alloy is much cheaper |
The claim that an iron-based alloy can match cobalt-based Stellite 6 in high temperature performance is ambitious. However, for valve sealing surfaces, the dominant failure modes are scratch (galling) and thermal fatigue, not high temperature corrosion or oxidation. In these modes, a well-designed Fe-Cr-Mo-W alloy with appropriate carbides can perform comparably to a cobalt-based alloy, particularly if the operating temperature is below 500 °C.
3. Application to Power Station Valves
3.1 Valve Types and Service Conditions
Power station valves that require hardfaced sealing surfaces include:
| Valve Type | Service Conditions | Sealing Surface Requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Main steam isolation valve | 540–570 °C, 10–25 MPa | High temperature scratch resistance, thermal fatigue |
| Feedwater control valve | 200–300 °C, 15–30 MPa | Erosion resistance, cavitation resistance |
| Turbine bypass valve | 500–600 °C, 5–15 MPa | High temperature scratch resistance, thermal fatigue |
| Safety valve | 500–570 °C, 10–25 MPa | High temperature scratch resistance, tight shutoff |
| Drain valve | 150–300 °C, 1–10 MPa | Erosion resistance, corrosion resistance |
The sealing surfaces of these valves are subjected to:
- Scratching (galling) — when the valve is operated, the sealing surfaces slide against each other under high contact pressure, causing material transfer and surface damage.
- Thermal fatigue — during start-up and shutdown, the valve body and sealing surfaces experience rapid temperature changes, causing thermal stresses that can lead to cracking.
- Erosion — high velocity steam or water can erode the sealing surfaces, particularly at the seat edges.
- Corrosion — impurities in the steam or water, such as chlorides, oxygen and carbon dioxide, can cause corrosion of the sealing surfaces.
3.2 Welding Procedure for Valve Sealing Surfaces
The welding procedure for power station valve sealing surfaces is more demanding than for general hardfacing applications, due to the high service temperature and pressure.
| Parameter | Recommended Range | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Welding process | SMAW (manual arc) | Most common, suitable for field and shop |
| Electrode type | Fe-Cr-Mo-W (iron-based) | As developed in this paper |
| Electrode diameter | 3.2–4.0 mm | For sealing surfaces, 3.2 mm preferred |
| Welding current | 100–150 A | Adjust for electrode diameter |
| Arc voltage | 22–28 V | Short arc |
| Preheat temperature | 250–350 °C | For Cr-Mo valve bodies |
| Interpass temperature | 300–400 °C | Control to prevent cracking |
| Deposit thickness | 4–6 mm | After machining, 2–3 mm remains |
| Post-weld heat treatment | Stress relief at 650–700 °C | For thick sections or high restraint |
3.3 Quality Control and Inspection
For power station valve sealing surfaces, the inspection requirements are more stringent than for general hardfacing.
| Inspection Step | Method | Acceptance Criteria |
|---|---|---|
| Surface preparation | Visual inspection | No oil, grease, rust or defects |
| Preheat temperature | Contact pyrometer | 250–350 °C |
| Interpass temperature | Contact pyrometer | 300–400 °C |
| Deposit thickness | Ultrasonic thickness gauge | 4–6 mm before machining |
| Surface hardness | Portable hardness tester | HRC ≥ 38 |
| Surface finish after machining | Surface roughness tester | Ra ≤ 0.4 μm (for sealing surface) |
| Dye penetrant test | PT per ASME Section V | No linear indications |
| Leak test | Hydrostatic or pneumatic | No leakage at specified pressure |
| Metallurgical examination | Microstructure, hardness survey | No cracks, no porosity, uniform hardness |
4. Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
4.1 Case Study: Valve Sealing Surface Failure
In a typical power plant, a main steam isolation valve with a cobalt-based hardfaced sealing surface might last 5–8 years before requiring repair. The failure mode is usually scratching or galling on the sealing surfaces, resulting in leakage. The valve is removed from service, the sealing surface is re-machined, and a new hardfacing layer is deposited.
With the new iron-based electrode, the same valve might last 4–6 years, which is slightly shorter than with cobalt-based alloy. However, the cost of the iron-based electrode is significantly lower, and the processability is better, so the total cost of repair is lower.
| Parameter | Cobalt-Based (HS111) | Iron-Based (New Electrode) |
|---|---|---|
| Electrode cost per kg | High | Low (20–30% of cobalt-based) |
| Welding time | Longer (more passes, more cleaning) | Shorter (better processability) |
| Post-weld machining time | Similar | Similar |
| Service life | 5–8 years | 4–6 years |
| Total repair cost | High | Lower |
| Cost per year of service | Moderate | Lower |
4.2 Common Problems and Countermeasures
| Problem | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Cracking of hardfaced layer | High hardness, high restraint, rapid cooling | Preheat, control interpass temperature, use buttering layer |
| Distortion of valve seat | Uneven heating, excessive deposit thickness | Use symmetrical welding sequence, use lower heat input |
| Porosity | Moisture in electrode, dirty surface | Bake electrodes, clean and degrease surface |
| Lack of fusion | Low current, incorrect technique | Increase current, use proper welding technique |
| Undercut | Excessive current, incorrect electrode angle | Reduce current, adjust electrode angle |
| Hardness below specification | Excessive dilution, incorrect alloy transfer | Use multi-layer deposit, control welding parameters |
5. Study Insights and Reflections
This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of valve hardfacing materials. The development of a cost-effective iron-based electrode that can match the performance of cobalt-based alloys in high temperature valve service is a significant achievement, particularly given the high cost and potential supply constraints of cobalt.
The key lessons from this paper are:
- Alloy design must be based on the dominant failure mode. For valve sealing surfaces, the dominant failure modes are scratching (galling) and thermal fatigue, not high temperature corrosion. A Fe-Cr-Mo-W alloy with appropriate carbides can perform comparably to a cobalt-based alloy in these modes.
- The alloy transfer through the flux coating is a practical and cost-effective approach. It allows the use of cheap H08A core wire and provides flexibility in alloy composition. However, it requires careful control of flux composition and welding parameters to ensure consistent alloy recovery.
- The performance comparison must be based on actual service conditions, not just laboratory tests. The paper reports that the new electrode meets or exceeds HS111 in four key performance indicators. However, the ultimate test is in service, and the paper does not report long-term field data.
- The cost advantage is significant. The iron-based electrode costs 20–30% of the cobalt-based alloy, and the processability is better. This makes it an attractive option for power plant operators looking to reduce maintenance costs.
For the shop floor, the practical recommendation is to:
- Conduct a welding procedure qualification test using the new electrode on the actual valve body material.
- Perform a field trial on a non-critical valve before full-scale adoption.
- Establish a quality control procedure that includes hardness testing, dye penetrant examination and leak testing.
- Monitor the performance of the hardfaced valves in service and compare with the historical performance of cobalt-based hardfaced valves.
The paper is a useful reference for valve manufacturers, power plant maintenance engineers and welding engineers. It demonstrates that cost-effective alternatives to cobalt-based alloys are available, and that the development of such alternatives requires a thorough understanding of the service conditions and failure modes. The next step for the research team would be to conduct long-term field trials and to investigate the effect of alloy composition on the high temperature scratch resistance and thermal fatigue resistance in more detail.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd