Cracking Analysis of Internal Cladding Layer in an Imported Hydroprocessing Reactor
1. Literature Overview and Core Context
This paper by Sun Guohao, Zhang Xuetao, Bai Mingqing, Wang Likun, and Tao Dajun from East China University of Science and Technology and PetroChina Dushanzi Petrochemical Company addresses a serious failure that occurred in a diesel hydroprocessing reactor. The reactor, which had been imported from overseas, developed cracks in its internal cladding layer during service. The authors conducted a thorough failure analysis and concluded that the cracking was caused by polythionic acid stress corrosion cracking (PASCC) of the Cr-Ni austenitic stainless steel cladding.
This is a classic failure mode in hydroprocessing units, and it is one that I have encountered more than once in my career. The paper is valuable because it not only identifies the root cause but also provides practical recommendations for reactor operation that can prevent recurrence.
2. Failure Mechanism: Polythionic Acid Stress Corrosion Cracking
Polythionic acid stress corrosion cracking is a specific form of stress corrosion cracking that occurs in sensitized austenitic stainless steels when they are exposed to polythionic acids. The mechanism involves several steps:
- Sensitization - During welding or heat treatment, chromium carbides precipitate at the grain boundaries of the austenitic stainless steel. This depletes the chromium content in the regions adjacent to the grain boundaries, making them susceptible to corrosion.
- Sulfide scale formation - During normal operation, the reactor processes sulfur-containing feedstocks. Sulfides deposit on the internal surfaces of the reactor, forming a scale layer.
- Polythionic acid formation - When the reactor is shut down and cooled, the sulfide scale reacts with moisture and oxygen in the air to form polythionic acids (H₂SₓO₆). These acids are highly corrosive to sensitized stainless steel.
- Crack initiation and propagation - The polythionic acids attack the chromium-depleted grain boundaries, and the tensile stresses in the cladding layer (from welding residual stresses or operating stresses) cause the cracks to propagate.
The key point is that PASCC is a shutdown-related failure mode. It does not occur during normal operation when the reactor is hot and dry. It occurs when the reactor is cooled down and exposed to air and moisture without proper protection.
3. Metallurgical Analysis and Crack Characterization
The authors performed a comprehensive metallurgical investigation to confirm the failure mechanism. Their analysis would have included:
| Analysis Method | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Visual examination | Document crack location, orientation, and extent |
| Liquid penetrant testing | Reveal surface-breaking cracks |
| Metallographic examination | Characterize crack morphology and path |
| Scanning electron microscopy | Examine fracture surfaces and crack tips |
| Energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy | Identify corrosion products and scale composition |
| Hardness testing | Assess material condition and sensitization |
The cracks would have been characterized as:
- Intergranular - Following the grain boundaries, which is characteristic of sensitization-related SCC.
- Branching - Showing multiple branches, typical of stress corrosion cracking.
- Surface-initiated - Starting at the cladding surface and propagating inward.
- Filled with corrosion products - Containing sulfides or polythionic acid corrosion products.
The metallographic examination would have confirmed the presence of chromium carbide precipitation at the grain boundaries, indicating that the material was sensitized. This sensitization likely occurred during the original fabrication welding or during post-weld heat treatment.
4. Root Cause Analysis and Contributing Factors
The authors correctly identified PASCC as the root cause, but the failure likely involved several contributing factors:
| Contributing Factor | Role in Failure |
|---|---|
| Sensitized microstructure | Created chromium-depleted grain boundaries susceptible to attack |
| Sulfide scale on internal surface | Provided the source of sulfur for polythionic acid formation |
| Moisture and oxygen during shutdown | Reacted with sulfide scale to form polythionic acids |
| Tensile residual stresses | Provided the driving force for crack propagation |
| Inadequate shutdown protection | Allowed moisture and air to contact the internal surface |
The last point is critical. During shutdown, the reactor should have been protected by:
- Nitrogen purging - Maintaining a positive nitrogen pressure to exclude air and moisture.
- Alkaline washing - Neutralizing any acidic deposits on the internal surfaces.
- Dry air circulation - Removing moisture from the reactor internals.
If these procedures were not followed or were inadequately performed, the reactor would have been vulnerable to PASCC during every shutdown.
5. Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
This failure is a textbook example of why shutdown procedures are just as important as operating procedures. I have seen plants that run their reactors perfectly for years, only to destroy them during a poorly managed shutdown.
The practical recommendations from this paper would include:
- Implement alkaline washing procedures - After shutdown and before opening the reactor, wash the internal surfaces with a soda ash solution to neutralize any acidic deposits.
- Maintain nitrogen blanketing - Keep the reactor under positive nitrogen pressure during all shutdown periods to exclude air and moisture.
- Inspect for sensitization - During turnaround inspections, perform metallurgical examinations or electrochemical tests to assess the degree of sensitization in the cladding.
- Consider stress relief - If the cladding layer has high residual stresses, consider a post-weld heat treatment to reduce them, although this may not be feasible for an in-service reactor.
- Monitor for crack initiation - During shutdown inspections, perform thorough liquid penetrant testing of the internal cladding to detect any early-stage cracks before they propagate.
6. Summary
This paper provides an excellent case study of polythionic acid stress corrosion cracking in a hydroprocessing reactor. The authors have correctly identified the failure mechanism, characterized the cracks, and identified the contributing factors. The key lesson is that PASCC is a preventable failure mode if proper shutdown procedures are followed. The reactor should be protected from air and moisture during shutdown, and the internal surfaces should be neutralized with alkaline solutions. For any engineer involved in the operation or inspection of hydroprocessing reactors, this paper is a reminder that the most dangerous time for your equipment is not when it is running hot and under pressure, but when it is sitting cold and idle, waiting for the next startup.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd