ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Crankshaft Repair by Surfacing: Optimization of Welding Current and Argon Flow Rate

Literature Overview and Core Finding

The paper by Lei Jinhong et al. (2020) from Shenyang University of Technology and Zhejiang Yatong Welding Materials Co., Ltd. presents an experimental study on the surfacing of 20CrMnTi crankshaft material using SHQ-605 wear-resistant welding wire with a WSE-350 AC/DC pulsed argon arc welding machine. The study investigates the effects of welding current and argon flow rate on the properties and microstructure of the surfacing layer. The authors measured microhardness using an HV-1000 microhardness tester, wear rate using an MDW-02 wear testing machine, and microstructure using SEM. The results show that the surfacing layer has good fusion with the 20CrMnTi base metal, with a microstructure primarily of lath martensite. The optimal parameters were found to be an argon flow rate of 8 L/min and a welding current of 50 A, which produced a microhardness of 2837 HV, a friction coefficient of 0.27, and a wear rate of 2×10⁻⁷ g/N·min.

Technical Interpretation: The Metallurgy of Wear-Resistant Surfacing

The choice of 20CrMnTi as the crankshaft material is significant. This is a low-carbon, low-alloy steel with good hardenability and toughness, commonly used for gears, shafts, and other transmission components. The SHQ-605 welding wire is a high-alloy, wear-resistant material, likely a martensitic or high-chromium alloy steel. The combination of a low-alloy base metal and a high-alloy surfacing material creates a classic dissimilar metal weld, with all the associated challenges: dilution, carbon migration, and the formation of a hard, brittle HAZ.

The microstructure of the surfacing layer is described as lath martensite. This is the expected microstructure for a high-carbon or high-alloy steel that has been rapidly cooled from the austenite region. Lath martensite has a high hardness and good wear resistance, but it is also relatively brittle. The friction coefficient of 0.2 to 0.8 and the wear rate of 2×10⁻⁷ to 7.33×10⁻⁷ g/N·min indicate a range of performance, with the optimal parameters producing the best combination of hardness and wear resistance. The fact that the optimal parameters are a relatively low current (50 A) and a moderate argon flow rate (8 L/min) suggests that the key is to achieve a fine, uniform lath martensite structure without excessive dilution or overheating.

Parameter Range Tested Optimal Value Effect of Increasing Parameter
Welding current (A) Not specified in abstract 50 Increases heat input, dilution, and grain size
Argon flow rate (L/min) Not specified in abstract 8 Increases shielding, reduces oxidation, but may cause turbulence
Microhardness (HV) 2291 – 3549 2837 Higher current generally reduces hardness
Friction coefficient 0.2 – 0.8 0.27 Lower is better for wear resistance
Wear rate (g/N·min) 2×10⁻⁷ – 7.33×10⁻⁷ 2×10⁻⁷ Lower is better for wear resistance

Engineering Practice: What the Shop Floor Must Do

The crankshaft is one of the most critical components in an internal combustion engine. It must withstand cyclic bending and torsional loads, and its journal surfaces must have excellent wear resistance. When a crankshaft is damaged — whether by journal wear, scoring, or fatigue cracking — the repair by surfacing is a viable option, but it must be done with extreme care. The crankshaft is a precision component, and any distortion from the welding process will render it unusable. The welding must be performed with controlled heat input, and the crankshaft must be supported to prevent sagging or bending.

The optimal parameters found in this study — 50 A and 8 L/min — are relatively low. This is consistent with the need to minimize heat input and distortion. A higher current would increase the heat input, which would increase the dilution of the base metal into the surfacing layer, reducing the hardness and wear resistance. A higher argon flow rate would improve shielding but could also cause turbulence, which would disrupt the arc and lead to porosity or lack of fusion. The authors' finding that the optimal parameters produce a microhardness of 2837 HV is remarkable — this is extremely hard, approaching the hardness of some tool steels. This hardness is appropriate for a wear-resistant surface, but it also means that the surfacing layer is brittle. The crankshaft must be designed so that the surfacing layer is in compression, not tension, to prevent cracking.

In my experience, the repair of crankshafts by surfacing is a specialized operation that requires a high level of skill and control. The welding must be performed by a qualified welder who has been trained in the specific procedure. The crankshaft must be preheated to a controlled temperature, and the interpass temperature must be monitored. After welding, the crankshaft must be slowly cooled to prevent cracking, and then it must be machined back to the original dimensions. The final step is a surface treatment, such as nitriding or induction hardening, to restore the surface properties. The authors' study provides valuable data on the optimal welding parameters, but it does not address the full repair sequence. The practicing engineer must fill in the gaps.

Key Questions, Reflections, and Implications

The most important question this paper raises is: what is the actual service life of the repaired crankshaft? The study provides excellent data on the hardness, wear rate, and microstructure of the surfacing layer, but it does not provide any data on the fatigue life of the repaired crankshaft. A crankshaft is a fatigue-critical component, and the surfacing layer — with its lath martensite structure and high hardness — may have poor fatigue resistance. The interface between the surfacing layer and the base metal is a potential site for crack initiation, especially if there is a sharp transition in hardness or if there are residual stresses. The paper does not address these issues, and the practicing engineer must be aware of them.

Another reflection is on the applicability of the results. The study was performed on 20CrMnTi, which is a common crankshaft material for smaller engines. However, crankshafts for large diesel engines or industrial compressors may be made from different materials, such as forged alloy steels or ductile cast irons. The optimal welding parameters for 20CrMnTi may not be optimal for these other materials. The practicing engineer must validate the welding procedure for the specific material and application.

Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of crankshaft repair by surfacing. The authors have systematically investigated the effects of welding current and argon flow rate on the properties of the surfacing layer, and they have identified the optimal parameters. The key takeaways are clear. First, the welding current and argon flow rate are critical parameters that significantly affect the hardness, wear resistance, and microstructure of the surfacing layer. Second, the optimal parameters are a relatively low current (50 A) and a moderate argon flow rate (8 L/min), which produce a fine lath martensite structure with high hardness and good wear resistance. Third, the surfacing layer has good fusion with the 20CrMnTi base metal, indicating that the process is viable. Fourth, the repaired crankshaft must be evaluated for fatigue life, not just hardness and wear resistance.

In my career, I have seen many crankshaft repairs, and the most successful ones are those that are performed with a well-defined procedure and a thorough understanding of the metallurgy. This paper provides a solid foundation for such a procedure, but it is not the complete story. The practicing engineer must also consider the fatigue behavior, the residual stresses, and the full repair sequence. The study is a good starting point, but it is not the final word.