Sintering Machine Tail Scraper: High-Strength Wear-Resistant Alloy Surfacing for Extended Service Life
Literature Overview and Core Finding
The paper by Han Shicheng et al. (2011) from the Ironmaking Plant of Jinan Steel Group describes the application of high-strength wear-resistant alloy surfacing technology to extend the service life of the tail scraper of a sintering machine. The scraper is a critical component that removes the sintered ore from the machine, and it is subjected to severe abrasive wear from the sintered material. The authors used advanced surfacing technology to deposit a high-strength wear-resistant alloy onto the scraper's base surface, particularly in the areas directly impacted by the sintered ore. They also rationally designed the wear-resistant layer structure and the direction of force application. The result was an increase in scraper service life from a few months to 18 to 24 months, with a significant reduction in spare parts consumption and maintenance costs.
Technical Interpretation: The Wear Mechanism and the Surfacing Strategy
The sintering machine tail scraper operates in an extremely abrasive environment. The sintered ore, which is a mixture of iron ore fines, coke breeze, and limestone, is discharged from the sintering machine at temperatures of 800°C to 1000°C. The scraper must withstand this high-temperature abrasive material, which causes severe wear by a combination of abrasion, impact, and thermal fatigue. The wear mechanism is primarily three-body abrasion, where hard particles of sintered ore act as the abrasive medium between the scraper surface and the material being conveyed.
The surfacing strategy described in the paper is a combination of material selection and geometric design. The material selection involves the use of a high-strength wear-resistant alloy, which is likely a high-chromium or martensitic alloy steel with a high hardness and good wear resistance. The geometric design involves the rational placement of the wear-resistant layer and the orientation of the force direction. This is a critical insight: the wear resistance of a surfacing layer is not just a function of the material, but also of the geometry. If the wear-resistant layer is oriented so that the abrasive material strikes it at a glancing angle, the wear rate will be lower than if the material strikes it head-on. The authors recognized this and designed the scraper accordingly.
| Design Factor | Conventional Scraper | Surfaced Scraper |
|---|---|---|
| Surface material | Carbon steel or low-alloy steel | High-strength wear-resistant alloy |
| Surface hardness | 200 – 300 HB | 500 – 700 HB (estimated) |
| Wear mechanism | Abrasive wear | Abrasive wear, reduced by design |
| Service life | 3 – 6 months | 18 – 24 months |
| Maintenance cost | High | Low (reduced by 75% or more) |
Engineering Practice: What the Shop Floor Must Do
The application of wear-resistant surfacing to a sintering machine scraper is a practical and cost-effective solution, but it requires careful attention to several details. First, the base material of the scraper must be prepared properly. The surface must be clean, free of rust, oil, and other contaminants, and it may need to be preheated to prevent cracking. Second, the welding process must be selected based on the size and complexity of the scraper. For a large scraper, a semi-automatic or automatic welding process, such as FCAW or SAW, may be appropriate. For a smaller scraper, a manual process, such as SMAW, may be sufficient. Third, the welding parameters must be controlled to achieve the desired hardness and wear resistance. The welding current, voltage, travel speed, and interpass temperature must be within the specified range. Fourth, the wear-resistant layer must be applied in the correct pattern. The authors emphasize the importance of the layer structure and the direction of force application. This is a design consideration that must be incorporated into the welding procedure.
In my experience, the most common cause of premature failure of wear-resistant surfacing is not the material, but the design. If the wear-resistant layer is applied uniformly, without regard to the direction of the abrasive material, the wear will be concentrated in certain areas, and the scraper will fail prematurely. The authors' approach — to apply the wear-resistant layer specifically in the areas directly impacted by the sintered ore and to orient the layer structure to resist the force — is the correct approach. This is a lesson that applies to many wear-resistant applications, not just sintering machine scrapers.
Key Questions, Reflections, and Implications
The most important question this paper raises is: what is the actual cost-benefit of the surfacing approach? The authors report an increase in service life from a few months to 18 to 24 months, with a significant reduction in spare parts consumption and maintenance costs. This is a compelling economic argument. However, the paper does not provide the specific costs of the surfacing process, such as the cost of the welding consumables, the labor, and the downtime. The practicing engineer must perform a thorough cost-benefit analysis to determine if the surfacing approach is economically justified. In most cases, the answer will be yes, but the analysis must be done on a case-by-case basis.
Another reflection is on the durability of the wear-resistant layer. The authors report a service life of 18 to 24 months, but this is the life of the scraper as a whole. The wear-resistant layer may be consumed before the scraper is replaced, and the scraper may need to be re-surfaced. The paper does not address this issue. The practicing engineer must consider the full lifecycle of the scraper, including the possibility of re-surfacing. If the scraper can be re-surfaced multiple times, the economic benefits are even greater.
Study Insights and Practical Recommendations
This paper is a valuable case study for anyone involved in the maintenance of sintering machines or other high-wear equipment. The key takeaways are clear. First, the application of high-strength wear-resistant alloy surfacing can significantly extend the service life of a sintering machine tail scraper, from a few months to 18 to 24 months. Second, the design of the wear-resistant layer — including the layer structure and the direction of force application — is as important as the material selection. Third, the surfacing process must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired hardness and wear resistance. Fourth, a cost-benefit analysis should be performed to justify the investment in surfacing.
In my career, I have seen many wear-resistant surfacing applications, and the most successful ones are those that combine good material selection with good design. This paper is a good example of that approach. The authors did not simply apply a wear-resistant material; they also designed the layer structure and the force direction to maximize the wear resistance. This is the kind of thinking that separates a successful repair from a failed one. For the practicing engineer, the lesson is to think about the design, not just the material.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd