ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

HTHA Susceptibility Evaluation for Hydrogen Service Equipment with Cladding: A Practical Review

Overview

The paper by Li Pengfei and Zhao Jianping addresses a gap in RBI (Risk-Based Inspection) methodology for hydrogen service equipment that has been internally clad with austenitic stainless steel. In my years on the shop floor, I have seen many hydrogen reactors and vessels that rely on a cladding layer to protect the base metal from hydrogen attack. The standard HTHA assessment in API 581 and similar codes assumes the hydrogen partial pressure at the base metal surface is the same as the process gas, which is conservative for unclad vessels but overly pessimistic for clad ones. The cladding acts as a barrier to hydrogen diffusion, reducing the effective hydrogen concentration at the base metal interface. This paper proposes a method to calculate an effective hydrogen partial pressure that accounts for the cladding, and then uses that to compute the Pv factor for HTHA susceptibility.

Key Technical Points

The authors start from hydrogen diffusion theory. The hydrogen flux through the cladding is governed by Fick's law, and the steady-state concentration at the cladding/base metal interface depends on the diffusivity and solubility of hydrogen in the cladding material versus the base metal. For austenitic stainless steel, the solubility of hydrogen is higher but the diffusivity is much lower than for ferritic steel. This means the cladding acts as a diffusion barrier, and the hydrogen partial pressure at the interface is lower than the process gas pressure. The effective hydrogen partial pressure, \(P_{H2,eff}\), is derived from the ratio of the hydrogen permeation rates. The paper then applies this to calculate the Pv factor, which is the product of the hydrogen partial pressure and the operating temperature (in Rankine or Kelvin, depending on the Nelson curve). The Nelson curves used in API 581 are based on the hydrogen partial pressure in the process gas. By using the effective pressure, the calculated Pv factor is lower, thus reducing the predicted HTHA susceptibility.

Modification of Critical Pv Factor for E347+E309L Cladding

The paper specifically addresses a double-layer cladding of E347 (first layer) and E309L (second layer) on a Cr-Mo steel base. They propose a modified critical Pv factor for this configuration. The critical Pv factor is the threshold above which HTHA is considered possible. The modification factor accounts for the reduced hydrogen ingress. I recall that for many years, the industry has used a "cladding factor" in some proprietary assessments, but this paper provides a more rigorous theoretical basis. The modified critical Pv factor is higher than the unclad value, meaning the equipment can tolerate a higher hydrogen partial pressure before HTHA becomes a concern.

Engineering Practice Insights

In practice, this has significant implications for inspection intervals and fitness-for-service assessments. For example, a hydroprocessing reactor with a design life of 20 years might be assessed as having a higher risk of HTHA if the cladding is ignored. By incorporating the cladding effect, the risk is reduced, and the inspection interval can be extended. However, I would caution that the cladding must be sound and continuous. Any defects, such as disbonding, cracks, or porosity, will compromise the barrier effect. In my experience, cladding disbonding is a real concern in service, especially in cyclic operation. The effective hydrogen partial pressure calculation assumes a perfect cladding, so if there are any through-thickness defects, the model is invalid. Therefore, this method should be used in conjunction with a thorough NDT program to verify the integrity of the cladding. Also, the method is for steady-state diffusion; in transient conditions, such as during startup and shutdown, the hydrogen concentration may be different. But for long-term HTHA, steady-state is a reasonable assumption.

Conclusions

This paper is a valuable contribution to the RBI methodology for clad hydrogen service equipment. It provides a theoretical basis for considering the cladding's beneficial effect, which is often ignored in standard assessments. The proposed effective hydrogen partial pressure method is practical and can be easily implemented in existing RBI software. However, the reliability of the method depends on the integrity of the cladding, and it should not be used to justify ignoring known cladding defects. As a veteran, I would recommend that this method be adopted with caution, and that the inspection plan still includes a robust cladding examination. The paper's focus on E347+E309L is particularly relevant for many hydroprocessing reactors, and the modified critical Pv factor provides a useful reference for engineers performing fitness-for-service evaluations.