Heat Treatment Effects on Corrosion Resistance of N06625 Cladding
Overview
The paper by Qi Shugai from Shanghai SenSong Pressure Vessel Co., Ltd. investigates the effect of heat treatment on the corrosion resistance of N06625 (Inconel 625) cladding deposited on SA-516 Gr70 carbon steel. This is a classic problem in the fabrication of pressure vessels for corrosive services. In my career, I have seen many cases where the cladding passes the initial corrosion test but fails after post-weld heat treatment (PWHT). The reason is often the diffusion of carbon from the base metal into the cladding, forming chromium carbides and depleting the matrix of chromium, which reduces corrosion resistance. The paper compares three welding processes: SMAW, GTAW, and ESW, and applies various heat treatment cycles, including a "maximum simulated stress relief" of three cycles. The corrosion test is per ASTM G28A, which is the boiling ferric sulfate-sulfuric acid test for detecting susceptibility to intergranular corrosion in nickel-based alloys.
Experimental Methods and Results
The author first analyzes the chemical composition of the SMAW cladding. It is found that the carbon content is higher than the GTAW wire, likely due to dilution from the carbon steel base and the use of a higher carbon electrode. The high carbon content leads to the formation of chromium-rich carbides, such as M23C6, during heat treatment, which causes sensitization. The GTAW process uses a low-carbon filler wire, which results in a lower carbon content in the cladding, even after dilution. The paper then performs three cycles of maximum simulated stress relief heat treatment, with a narrow temperature range. The results show that the GTAW cladding with low carbon content passes the G28A test, while the SMAW cladding fails. The ESW process is also mentioned, but the details are not fully given in the abstract.
Process Recommendations
Based on the findings, the author recommends using GTAW with a low-carbon filler wire for the cladding to ensure good corrosion resistance. Additionally, the PWHT temperature range should be controlled to minimize carbon diffusion. The paper suggests narrowing the stress relief temperature range, which is a practical step that many fabricators overlook. In my experience, the PWHT temperature is often set to the maximum allowed by code, but this can be detrimental to the cladding. By reducing the upper limit, the carbon diffusion is reduced, and the cladding retains its corrosion resistance. The three-cycle maximum simulated heat treatment is a stringent test that simulates the worst-case scenario of multiple PWHTs, which can occur if the vessel is repaired or if there are multiple heat treatments during fabrication.
Engineering Practice Insights
This paper highlights a critical issue: the selection of welding process and filler material must be made with the final heat treatment in mind. I have seen vessels where the cladding was specified as N06625, but the fabricator used SMAW for convenience, and then the vessel failed the corrosion test after PWHT. The cost of rework is enormous. The key is to control the carbon content of the cladding. Dilution from the base metal is a major factor, so the first layer of cladding should be deposited with a low-heat-input process to minimize dilution, or a buttering layer of nickel-based alloy should be applied first. The paper's approach of using GTAW with a low-carbon wire is a good solution, but it is more expensive and slower than SMAW. However, for critical services, the extra cost is justified.
Conclusions
The study clearly demonstrates that the carbon content of the N06625 cladding is the dominant factor affecting corrosion resistance after heat treatment. The use of low-carbon GTAW filler wire and a controlled PWHT temperature range is essential to achieve acceptable corrosion performance. This is a valuable lesson for fabricators and inspectors. I would add that the ASTM G28A test is a severe test, and passing it gives high confidence in the cladding's ability to resist intergranular corrosion in service. The paper's emphasis on the "maximum simulated heat treatment" is particularly important, as it ensures that the cladding can withstand multiple thermal cycles without degradation. In my opinion, this should be a standard requirement for all corrosion-resistant cladding applications.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd