ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Application of Fe-Cr-B Wear-Resistant Hardfacing Electrodes on High-Temperature Blast Furnace Bells

Literature Overview and Core Findings

The 1999 study by Peng Weilin at Shenyang University of Technology's Electrode Factory addresses a specific and demanding application: the hardfacing of blast furnace bells and hoppers, which operate at high temperatures and see severe abrasive wear from the burden materials. The study describes the development of a special Fe-Cr-B series hardfacing electrode, and it evaluates the performance of the resulting deposit in high-temperature abrasive conditions.

The key finding is that the Fe-Cr-B alloy system, with chromium boride (CrB) as the primary hard phase, provides an excellent combination of wear resistance and high-temperature oxidation resistance. The study reports that the hardfaced components performed well in service at temperatures of 400-500°C, and it discusses the composition, microstructure, and wear mechanism of the deposit.

This study is particularly valuable because it addresses a real industrial problem with a practical solution. Blast furnace bells and hoppers are critical components in the ironmaking process, and their failure can cause significant downtime and production losses. The development of a reliable hardfacing solution is therefore of great economic importance.

Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Logic

The Fe-Cr-B alloy system is a relatively recent addition to the family of hardfacing alloys. Unlike the traditional Fe-Cr-C alloys, which use chromium carbides as the hard phase, the Fe-Cr-B alloys use chromium borides (CrB, Cr2B) as the primary hard phase. The borides have several advantages over carbides: they are harder, they have a higher melting point, and they are more stable at high temperatures.

The microstructure of the Fe-Cr-B deposit consists of primary CrB particles dispersed in a matrix of martensite or bainite, depending on the cooling rate and the alloy composition. The CrB particles provide the wear resistance, while the matrix provides the toughness and the support for the hard particles.

Alloy System Hard Phase Hardness (HV) High-Temperature Stability
Fe-Cr-C Cr7C3, Cr23C6 1200-1600 Moderate
Fe-Cr-B CrB, Cr2B 1500-2000 High
Co-Cr-W Cr7C3, WC 1300-1800 High

The study emphasizes the importance of the boron-to-carbon ratio in the alloy design. Boron is a stronger carbide former than carbon, and it preferentially combines with chromium to form borides. The carbon content should be kept low to avoid the formation of chromium carbides, which are less hard and less stable than the borides.

The wear mechanism of the Fe-Cr-B deposit is primarily micro-cutting and micro-spalling. The hard CrB particles resist the abrasive action of the burden materials, while the matrix deforms and absorbs the impact energy. The high-temperature oxidation resistance of the deposit is attributed to the formation of a protective chromium oxide layer on the surface, which prevents further oxidation and maintains the integrity of the hard phase.

Integration with Manufacturing Practice

The application of Fe-Cr-B hardfacing electrodes to blast furnace bells and hoppers requires careful consideration of the service conditions and the welding process. The components are typically made of cast steel or low-alloy steel, and they are large and heavy, which makes preheating and post-weld heat treatment challenging.

The study reports that the hardfacing was applied to the "scale rod" of the blast furnace bell, which is the vertical rod that connects the bell to the hopper. The scale rod sees both abrasive wear from the burden materials and high-temperature oxidation from the furnace gases. The hardfacing was applied using a manual metal arc welding process with the specially developed Fe-Cr-B electrode.

Application Parameter Recommended Value Rationale
Preheat temperature 200-300°C Prevents cracking in the hardfacing layer
Interpass temperature 250-350°C Maintains a uniform thermal field
Welding current 150-200 A Balances deposition rate and dilution
Electrode diameter 4-5 mm Matches the thickness of the deposit
Deposit thickness 3-5 mm Provides adequate wear allowance

The study reports that the hardfaced scale rod performed well in service at temperatures of 400-500°C, with a service life that was significantly longer than the unhardfaced component. The success of the application was attributed to the combination of high hardness, good high-temperature oxidation resistance, and adequate toughness.

Key Questions and Practical Reflections

One question that the study does not fully address is the effect of the hardfacing on the fatigue life of the component. Blast furnace bells and hoppers are subjected to cyclic loading as the bell opens and closes, and the hardfacing layer can introduce residual stresses that affect the fatigue performance. In my experience, the hardfacing should be applied with a low heat input and a controlled interpass temperature to minimize residual stress, and a post-weld heat treatment should be considered to relieve the residual stresses.

Another consideration is the repair of hardfaced blast furnace components. When the hardfacing wears out, it can be repaired by grinding out the worn area and re-hardfacing. However, the repair process must be carefully controlled to avoid damaging the base metal or the existing hardfacing layer. The study's emphasis on the composition and microstructure of the deposit is particularly relevant to repair work, where the thermal history of the component is already complex.

I recall a project where a blast furnace bell was hardfaced with a Fe-Cr-B electrode, and the hardfacing layer spalled after a few months of service. The investigation revealed that the spalling was caused by a combination of high residual stress and inadequate interpass temperature control. The solution was to increase the preheat temperature, to control the interpass temperature more carefully, and to apply a post-weld heat treatment to relieve the residual stresses. The revised process produced a hardfacing layer that lasted for several years.

Study Insights and Implications

This study provides a valuable example of how a specific hardfacing alloy can be developed and applied to solve a real industrial problem. The Fe-Cr-B alloy system offers a combination of high hardness, good high-temperature oxidation resistance, and adequate toughness that makes it well suited for high-temperature abrasive wear applications.

The key insight is that the alloy design must be matched to the service conditions. The Fe-Cr-B system is not a universal solution; it is specifically designed for applications that involve high-temperature abrasive wear. For applications that involve impact loading or corrosion, other alloy systems may be more appropriate.

The study also highlights the importance of process control in hardfacing applications. The success of the hardfacing depends not only on the alloy composition but also on the welding parameters, the preheat and interpass temperature control, and the post-weld heat treatment. A well-designed alloy can fail if the process is not properly controlled.

Reference Value and Outlook

The Fe-Cr-B alloy system has gained increasing attention in recent years, and it is now used in a wide range of applications beyond blast furnace bells and hoppers. The principles established in this study remain relevant, and they are applicable to any high-temperature abrasive wear application.

Looking ahead, I would expect to see more research on the development of Fe-Cr-B alloys with improved toughness and weldability, and on the use of advanced welding processes, such as laser cladding and plasma transferred arc welding, for the application of these alloys. The fundamental principles of alloy design and process control will remain the same.

For the production engineer, the practical takeaway is clear. When selecting a hardfacing alloy for a high-temperature abrasive wear application, consider the Fe-Cr-B system as a viable option. The alloy offers an excellent combination of hardness, high-temperature stability, and wear resistance, and it can be applied using conventional welding processes with careful process control.