ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Roll Hardfacing Process: Technical Study Note

The Role of Hardfacing in Roll Service

The 2005 paper by Ding Jie and Shen Qianhui from Tianjin Sino-German Vocational Technical College and Tianjin Pipe Company addresses a subject that is close to my heart: the hardfacing of rolls for steel pipe and steel rolling mills. Rolls are among the most expensive consumables in a steel plant. A single large roll for a seamless pipe mill can cost over a million dollars, and its service life is often measured in weeks, not years. The paper focuses on the process parameters for roll hardfacing, particularly the use of flux-cored wire with submerged arc welding (SAW).

The key insight of the paper is that roll hardfacing is not a simple "weld metal onto the surface" operation. It is a metallurgical process that must be controlled at every step: the choice of filler material, the welding parameters, the preheat and interpass temperature, and the post-weld heat treatment. The paper's emphasis on carbon equivalent (CE) is particularly valuable, as it provides a practical way to assess the weldability of the roll material.

Process Parameters and Material Selection

The paper discusses the selection of hardfacing materials based on the roll's service conditions. For hot rolls, the dominant wear mechanisms are thermal fatigue and abrasive wear. For cold rolls, the dominant mechanisms are abrasive wear and contact fatigue. The paper recommends the following approach:

Roll Type Base Material Hardfacing Material Process Typical Hardness
Hot strip mill work roll High Cr cast iron Flux-cored wire, Cr-W-V alloy SAW HRC 55–60
Seamless pipe mill roll Forged steel, Cr-Mo Flux-cored wire, Cr-Mo-V alloy SAW HRC 45–55
Cold rolling work roll Forged steel, Cr-Mo-V Flux-cored wire, Cr-W-Mo alloy SAW HRC 58–62
Guide roll for pipe mill Cast steel Flux-cored wire, Ni-Cr alloy SAW HRC 40–50

The carbon equivalent of the base material is the critical parameter. The paper correctly notes that as CE increases, the preheat temperature must increase to prevent cold cracking. For rolls with CE above 0.45%, a preheat of 200–350°C is typically required, with the interpass temperature maintained at 150–250°C.

The paper also discusses the selection of welding flux. For SAW hardfacing, the flux must be compatible with the filler wire and must produce a slag that is easy to remove. Agglomerated fluxes with a basicity of 1.0–1.5 are commonly used, as they provide good weld metal toughness and acceptable slag removal.

Common Defects and Countermeasures

In my experience, the most common defects in roll hardfacing are:

  1. Cracking in the hardfacing layer. This is usually caused by insufficient preheat, high interpass temperature, or a filler material with too high a carbon equivalent. The countermeasure is to increase preheat, reduce the interpass temperature, and select a filler material with better toughness.
  2. Spalling of the hardfacing layer. This occurs when the hardfacing layer has poor bond strength to the base metal, often due to insufficient penetration or the presence of slag inclusions at the interface. The countermeasure is to increase the welding current, reduce the travel speed, and ensure thorough cleaning between passes.
  3. Porosity. This is typically caused by moisture in the flux or wire, or by contamination of the roll surface. The countermeasure is to dry the flux and wire properly, and to grind the roll surface clean before welding.
  4. Distortion of the roll. This is a serious problem for long rolls, where the heat input causes bending. The countermeasure is to use a low heat input, a staggered welding sequence, and a roll rotation speed that ensures uniform heat distribution.

Engineering Practice Insights

The paper's practical value lies in its emphasis on the process window. In my experience, the most common mistake in roll hardfacing is trying to achieve maximum hardness at the expense of toughness. A hardfacing layer with HRC 60 may look impressive on paper, but it will spall and crack in service if the base material cannot support it. The key is to match the hardfacing hardness to the roll's service conditions and to the base material's properties.

Another critical point is the post-weld heat treatment (PWHT). For large rolls, a stress-relief treatment at 500–600°C is often required to reduce residual stress. However, this treatment can reduce the hardness of the hardfacing layer if the temperature is too high or the time is too long. The paper does not discuss this in detail, but it is a critical practical consideration.

I would also add that roll hardfacing is not just about the welding process. The roll must be balanced after hardfacing, and the surface must be machined to the required tolerance. A roll that is out of balance by even a few kilograms will cause vibration in the mill, which can damage the roll and the mill itself.

Lessons and Outlook

The paper provides a good overview of roll hardfacing, but it is a brief communication (two pages) and lacks depth in several areas. The most valuable lesson is the emphasis on carbon equivalent as a practical tool for assessing weldability. This is a concept that every welding engineer should understand, and it is often the difference between a successful hardfacing job and a cracked roll.

For the future, I see roll hardfacing moving towards laser cladding and plasma transferred arc (PTA) welding, which offer better control of dilution and heat input. However, SAW with flux-cored wire remains the workhorse for large rolls, and the process parameters discussed in this paper will remain relevant for many years.