ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hardfaced Hot Shear Blades for Continuous Casting: A Technical Study

The Problem with Solid High-Alloy Blades

The 1997 paper by Xu Hengjun and colleagues from Beijing University of Technology addresses a specific but important problem: the manufacture of hot shear blades for continuous casting of steel billets. These blades operate at temperatures of 800–1000°C and must withstand severe thermal shock, abrasive wear, and mechanical impact. The conventional approach was to manufacture the blades from solid 3Cr2W8 high-alloy steel, which is expensive and difficult to machine. The paper's contribution is the development of a composite blade: a low-cost quenched and tempered medium carbon low alloy steel base, with a hardfaced cutting edge.

The paper reports that the hardfaced blades achieved a service life 2–3 times longer than solid 3Cr2W8 blades, with a significant reduction in production cost. The paper also reports successful repair of worn blades, which further extends the economic advantage.

Design of Hardfaced Blades

The composite blade design is based on a simple principle: the base material provides toughness and structural integrity, while the hardfaced edge provides wear resistance. The key is to select a hardfacing material that can withstand the thermal cycling of the shear operation without cracking or spalling.

The paper's experimental work identified an optimal hardfacing composition based on a Cr-Mo-V alloy system. The key parameters are summarised below:

Parameter Optimal Value Practical Significance
Base material Quenched and tempered medium carbon low alloy steel (e.g., 35CrMo) Provides toughness and low cost
Hardfacing material Cr-Mo-V alloy, HRC 50–55 Balances wear resistance and thermal fatigue resistance
Hardfacing thickness 5–8 mm Provides sufficient wear allowance
Preheat temperature 200–300°C Prevents cold cracking in the HAZ
Interpass temperature 150–250°C Prevents overheating and distortion
Post-weld heat treatment Stress relief at 400–500°C Reduces residual stress

The paper's choice of a quenched and tempered base material is significant. 3Cr2W8 is a high-alloy steel that is difficult to weld and expensive to produce. By using a lower-cost base material, the authors reduced the material cost significantly while improving the blade's toughness. The hardfaced edge provides the wear resistance that the base material lacks.

Welding Process and Material Selection

The paper discusses the welding process in detail, focusing on the selection of the hardfacing electrode and the welding parameters. The authors used a manual metal arc (MMA) process with a specially developed electrode, which is appropriate for the relatively small size of the blades.

The key welding parameters are:

  1. Welding current: 150–200 A for a 4 mm electrode, with a short arc to minimise dilution.
  2. Voltage: 22–26 V, with a straight polarity (DCEN) to maximise deposition rate.
  3. Travel speed: 150–250 mm/min, with a weave pattern to ensure uniform coverage.
  4. Bead sequence: Multiple passes, with each pass overlapping the previous by 30–50%.

The paper emphasises the importance of controlling dilution. If the welding current is too high, the base material melts excessively, and the hardfacing layer becomes diluted with the base material, reducing its hardness and wear resistance. The authors recommend a dilution rate of less than 20%, which is achieved by using a low current and a short arc.

Field Performance and Economic Analysis

The paper reports that the hardfaced blades achieved a service life 2–3 times longer than solid 3Cr2W8 blades. This is a significant improvement, but the paper does not provide detailed field data. In my experience, the actual improvement depends on the service conditions: the billet temperature, the shear frequency, and the presence of scale or other contaminants.

The economic analysis is straightforward. The hardfaced blade costs less to manufacture because the base material is cheaper and easier to machine. The longer service life further reduces the cost per tonne of steel sheared. The ability to repair worn blades by re-hardfacing is an additional benefit, as it avoids the cost of manufacturing a new blade.

Lessons and Outlook

The paper's most valuable contribution is the demonstration that composite blades can outperform solid high-alloy blades in hot shear service. This is a lesson that applies beyond shear blades: in many applications, a tough base material with a hardfaced surface is superior to a solid high-alloy material, both in performance and cost.

For the young engineers reading this note, I would emphasise the importance of matching the hardfacing material to the service conditions. The Cr-Mo-V alloy used in this paper is optimised for thermal fatigue resistance, which is the dominant failure mode in hot shearing. A different application, such as a cold shear, would require a different hardfacing material with higher hardness and better abrasive wear resistance.

The paper also highlights the importance of repair and re-hardfacing. In many steel plants, the cost of replacement blades is a significant operating expense. By developing a repair procedure, the authors extended the life of the blades and reduced the plant's operating costs. This is a lesson that I have seen applied in many other contexts, from rolling mill rolls to crusher hammers.