Hardfacing Repair of Electric Shovel Drive Wheels and Bucket Teeth
The Wear Problem in Mining Equipment
The 1992 paper by Xu Guoling and Shi Meiyu from Ningbo Port Authority and Ningbo Equipment Installation Company addresses a practical problem that is familiar to anyone who has worked in mining or earthmoving: the severe wear of electric shovel components. The paper describes the repair of WK-4 electric shovels, which have a bucket capacity of 4.6 m³. After extended service, the drive wheels, bucket teeth, bucket front wall, and support wheels were found to be severely worn, with some components reaching the point of scrap.
The paper's contribution is the development of a hardfacing repair process for these components, using manual metal arc (MMA) welding with hardfacing electrodes. The repair process allowed the components to be returned to service at a fraction of the cost of replacement.
Repair Process for Drive Wheels
The drive wheel is made of ZG35CrMo, a cast steel with a carbon equivalent that requires careful welding. The paper describes the repair process in detail:
- Surface preparation: The worn surface is ground back to sound metal, removing all cracks and fatigue damage. The surface is then cleaned with a wire brush and degreased.
- Preheat: The wheel is preheated to 200–300°C using a gas torch or an induction heater. The preheat is essential to prevent cold cracking in the HAZ.
- Hardfacing: The hardfacing material is selected based on the service conditions. For the drive wheel, which experiences high contact stress and abrasive wear, a Cr-Mo alloy with a hardness of HRC 50–55 is recommended. The welding is done with a 4 mm electrode at a current of 150–200 A, using a short arc to minimise dilution.
- Post-weld treatment: The wheel is allowed to cool slowly, and a stress-relief treatment at 400–500°C may be applied if the component is large or highly stressed.
The paper emphasises the importance of controlling the interpass temperature. If the temperature rises above 250°C, the hardfacing layer may crack due to thermal stress. The welder should allow the component to cool between passes, using a temperature-indicating crayon or an infrared thermometer to monitor the temperature.
Repair Process for Bucket Teeth
The bucket teeth are subjected to severe abrasive wear and impact. The paper describes the repair process for these components:
- Surface preparation: The worn teeth are ground back to sound metal, removing all cracks and fatigue damage.
- Hardfacing: A high-hardness hardfacing material (HRC 55–60) is recommended for the bucket teeth, as they experience severe abrasive wear. A Cr-W-V alloy is commonly used, as it provides excellent abrasive wear resistance.
- Welding parameters: The welding is done with a 4 mm electrode at a current of 150–200 A, using a short arc. The teeth are welded in a staggered sequence to minimise distortion.
- Post-weld inspection: The teeth are inspected for cracks and porosity using penetrant testing.
Quality Control and Economic Considerations
The paper discusses the economic benefits of the repair process. The cost of repairing a drive wheel is typically 20–30% of the cost of replacement, and the repaired wheel can be returned to service with a life expectancy of 70–80% of a new wheel. The bucket teeth can be repaired multiple times, further extending the economic advantage.
The paper also discusses the importance of quality control. The repaired components must be inspected for cracks, porosity, and lack of fusion. The inspection methods include:
- Visual inspection: Detects surface defects and weld discontinuities.
- Penetrant testing (PT): Detects surface cracks and porosity.
- Hardness testing: Verifies that the hardfacing layer has the expected hardness.
Lessons from the Field
The paper provides a practical guide to the repair of mining equipment components. The most valuable lesson is the importance of surface preparation. In my experience, the most common cause of repair failure is inadequate surface preparation. If the worn surface is not ground back to sound metal, the hardfacing layer will crack and spall in service.
The paper also highlights the importance of selecting the correct hardfacing material. The drive wheel and the bucket teeth have different wear mechanisms, and they require different hardfacing materials. The drive wheel experiences contact fatigue and abrasive wear, while the bucket teeth experience severe abrasive wear and impact. A hardfacing material that is suitable for one application may not be suitable for the other.
For the young engineers reading this note, I would emphasise the importance of understanding the wear mechanism before selecting the hardfacing material. This is a lesson that I have seen applied in many other contexts, from rolling mill rolls to crusher hammers. The repair process is only as good as the selection of the hardfacing material and the discipline of the welder.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd