Tube Sheet Distortion After Cladding: Analysis and Control Measures
Overview of the Problem
The cladding of tube sheets with austenitic stainless steel is a common practice in the chemical and petroleum industries. The tube sheet is made of a ferritic steel, typically carbon steel or low-alloy steel, and the cladding provides corrosion resistance on the process side. The cladding is applied by welding, and the welding process introduces a significant amount of heat into the tube sheet. This heat causes the tube sheet to distort, and the distortion can be severe enough to make the tube sheet unusable.
The paper by Zhou Dapeng and Xu Hui from Nanjing Second Chemical Machinery Works addresses this problem in detail. The paper analyzes the causes of the distortion, the residual stress distribution, and the methods for controlling the distortion.
Analysis of Distortion and Residual Stress
The distortion of the tube sheet is caused by the residual stresses that are introduced by the welding process. The welding heat creates a localized temperature gradient, and the thermal expansion and contraction of the material create stresses. When the weld cools, the cladding layer contracts more than the base material, creating a tensile stress in the cladding and a compressive stress in the base material. This stress distribution causes the tube sheet to warp.
The paper identifies several factors that contribute to the distortion:
- Heat input: The higher the heat input, the greater the distortion. The paper recommends using a low heat input welding process, such as pulsed MIG welding, to minimize the distortion.
- Welding sequence: The welding sequence has a significant effect on the distortion. The paper recommends a symmetrical welding sequence, where the welding is done in a pattern that balances the heat input. The "checkerboard" or "brick" pattern is recommended for large tube sheets.
- Cladding thickness: The thicker the cladding, the greater the distortion. The paper recommends keeping the cladding thickness to the minimum required by the design.
- Base material thickness: The thicker the base material, the less the distortion. However, the base material thickness is determined by the design pressure, and it cannot be changed.
Control Measures
The paper proposes several control measures to minimize the distortion:
| Control Measure | Description | Effectiveness |
|---|---|---|
| Preheat | Preheating the tube sheet to 150–200°C reduces the temperature gradient | Moderate |
| Low heat input | Using a low heat input welding process reduces the total heat input | High |
| Symmetrical welding sequence | Welding in a symmetrical pattern balances the heat input | High |
| Peening | Peening the weld bead reduces the tensile stress in the cladding | Moderate |
| Post-weld heat treatment | Stress relief heat treatment reduces the residual stress | High |
| Mechanical straightening | Straightening the tube sheet after welding | Low |
The paper emphasizes the importance of the welding sequence. The welding should be done in a pattern that distributes the heat evenly. The paper recommends starting from the center of the tube sheet and working outward in a spiral pattern. The welding should be done in a "checkerboard" pattern, where the beads are laid in a sequence that alternates between different areas of the tube sheet.
Practical Case Study
The paper describes a case where a tube sheet for a heat exchanger was clad with austenitic stainless steel. The tube sheet was 2 meters in diameter and 50 mm thick. The cladding was 6 mm thick. The initial welding sequence caused a distortion of 8 mm, which was unacceptable. The welding sequence was changed to a symmetrical pattern, and the distortion was reduced to 2 mm, which was within the acceptable range.
The paper also discusses the use of peening to reduce the distortion. Peening is a process where the weld bead is hammered with a pneumatic tool. The peening introduces a compressive stress in the cladding layer, which counteracts the tensile stress. The paper recommends peening the weld bead after each pass.
Summary and Practical Implications
The distortion of tube sheets after cladding is a serious problem that can lead to the rejection of the component. The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the causes and the control measures. The key to success is the careful control of the welding sequence, the heat input, and the use of peening. For engineers working on tube sheets or other large components that require cladding, this paper is a valuable reference. The practical lessons are clear: plan the welding sequence carefully, use a low heat input, and consider peening to reduce the residual stress. Do not underestimate the importance of these measures—they are the difference between a usable tube sheet and a rejected component.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd