ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Experimental Study on Magnetic Control Technology of Strip Cladding Current

Literature Overview and Core Findings

The paper by Gao Zebin and Li Chunlan, published in Welding in 2005, presents an experimental study on the magnetic control of strip cladding current. Using a simulated strip cladding setup, the authors investigated how the presence, strength, and position of a control magnetic field affect the distribution of current across the width of the strip electrode. Applying principles from electrical engineering, they analyzed the mechanism of magnetic control in strip cladding. The results show that under the same current and voltage parameters, the position of the magnetic poles and the magnetic field strength directly influence the current distribution, causing changes in the current across the strip width. The authors conclude that electromagnetic control in strip cladding is essentially a control of the current distribution state by the magnetic field, which in turn controls the uniformity and stability of the arc across the strip width, ensuring stable cladding with a wide strip electrode.

Technical Points and Process Analysis

Fundamentals of Strip Cladding

Strip cladding is a variant of submerged arc welding where a wide, thin strip electrode is used instead of a round wire. The strip is typically 30-100 mm wide and 0.4-0.5 mm thick. The advantages of strip cladding over wire cladding are:

Parameter Wire Cladding Strip Cladding
Deposition rate 5-10 kg/h 15-30 kg/h
Dilution 15-25% 10-15%
Deposit smoothness Moderate Excellent
Number of passes for large area Many Few
Heat input per unit area Higher Lower

The lower dilution of strip cladding is particularly important for corrosion-resistant cladding, as it minimizes the pickup of base metal elements that can degrade the corrosion resistance of the deposit.

The Problem of Arc Stability in Strip Cladding

One of the key challenges in strip cladding is maintaining arc stability across the entire width of the strip. The arc in strip cladding is not a single arc but a series of micro-arcs distributed across the strip width. If the current distribution is non-uniform, the arc will be concentrated in certain areas, leading to:

The magnetic control technology described in the paper addresses this problem by applying an external magnetic field to control the current distribution.

Mechanism of Magnetic Control

The authors apply electrical engineering principles to explain the mechanism. When a current-carrying conductor (the strip electrode) is placed in a magnetic field, the interaction between the current and the magnetic field produces a force (Lorentz force) on the charge carriers. This force causes the current to redistribute across the strip width.

The key parameters are:

  1. Magnetic field strength (B)
  2. Magnetic field direction (perpendicular or parallel to the strip)
  3. Position of the magnetic poles relative to the strip

The authors found that the position of the magnetic poles directly affects the current distribution. If the magnetic field is applied in a direction that causes the current to concentrate at the center of the strip, the arc will be more stable and uniform. Conversely, if the field causes current concentration at the edges, the arc will be unstable.

Experimental Results and Practical Implications

The experimental results show that:

The practical implications for strip cladding are significant:

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

Application to Cladding of Pipe and Fittings

In our industry, strip cladding is used for:

The magnetic control technology is particularly useful for wide strip cladding (60 mm and above). Without magnetic control, wide strips tend to have unstable arcs at the edges, leading to undercut and non-uniform deposit. With magnetic control, the arc is stabilized, and the deposit is uniform.

Practical Case Study

I recall a project where we used 60 mm wide strip cladding with 309L and 347L electrodes to clad the internal surface of a large diameter pipe fitting for a refinery service. The base material was a low-alloy high-strength steel. Without magnetic control, we experienced significant undercut at the strip edges and non-uniform deposit thickness. The deposit thickness varied from 3 mm at the center to 2 mm at the edges, which was unacceptable.

After implementing a magnetic control device, the deposit thickness became uniform at 3.0 ± 0.2 mm across the entire width. The arc was stable, and the surface quality was excellent. The NDT results (UT and PT) showed no defects.

Key Parameters for Magnetic Control

Parameter Typical Range Effect
Magnetic field strength 50-200 mT Higher strength increases the control effect but may cause arc blow
Pole position 10-20 mm from strip edge Position affects the current distribution profile
Pole orientation Perpendicular to strip Most effective for current redistribution
Welding current 700-900 A (for 60 mm strip) Higher current requires stronger magnetic field

Common Problems and Countermeasures

Problem Root Cause Countermeasure
Arc blow Excessive magnetic field Reduce magnetic field strength, adjust pole position
Non-uniform deposit Incorrect pole position Optimize pole position, use feedback control
Undercut at edges Current concentration at edges Adjust magnetic field to concentrate current at center
Porosity Moisture in flux Dry flux, maintain proper flux layer thickness

Study Insights and Reflections

This paper provides a valuable theoretical foundation for understanding and optimizing magnetic control in strip cladding. The authors' application of electrical engineering principles to explain the current redistribution mechanism is elegant and practical. The key insight is that the magnetic field controls the current distribution, which in turn controls the arc behavior.

From my experience, the practical implementation of magnetic control requires careful tuning. The magnetic field strength and pole position must be optimized for each specific combination of strip width, welding current, and welding speed. A one-size-fits-all approach will not work. The best approach is to use a feedback control system that monitors the arc voltage and current across the strip width and adjusts the magnetic field accordingly.

I would also note that the magnetic control technology is particularly valuable for wide strip cladding (60 mm and above). For narrow strips (30-50 mm), the arc is naturally more stable, and magnetic control may not be necessary. However, for wide strips, magnetic control is almost essential for achieving consistent quality.

Conclusion

The experimental study by Gao Zebin and Li Chunlan provides a solid theoretical and practical foundation for the application of magnetic control in strip cladding. The key finding is that the magnetic field controls the current distribution across the strip width, which in turn controls the arc stability and uniformity. This technology is particularly valuable for wide strip cladding applications in the steel pipe and fitting industry, where uniform deposit thickness and good surface quality are essential. The practical implementation requires careful tuning of the magnetic field strength and pole position, and ideally, a feedback control system. For engineers involved in strip cladding, this paper is a valuable reference for understanding and optimizing the process.