ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Application of Pre-Deformation Method in Tube Sheet Surfacing

1. The Challenge: Controlling Distortion in Tube Sheet Surfacing

A tube sheet is a thick, circular plate that is used in a shell-and-tube heat exchanger. The tube sheet has a large number of holes drilled in it, and the tubes are expanded or welded into these holes. The tube sheet is often made of a low-alloy steel, such as 2.25Cr-1Mo or a carbon steel, and the process side of the tube sheet is surfaced with a corrosion-resistant alloy, such as austenitic stainless steel or a nickel-based alloy. The surfacing is done to protect the tube sheet from the corrosive process stream.

The surfacing of a tube sheet is a challenging job, because the tube sheet is a large, thin plate, and the welding process introduces a significant amount of heat. The heat causes the tube sheet to expand, and when the tube sheet cools, it contracts. The contraction is not uniform, because the surfacing layer is on one side of the plate, and the base metal is on the other side. The result is a "dish" or "bowl" shape, where the center of the tube sheet is lower than the edges. This is called "pot-bottom" deformation.

The paper by Xu Zailin and Sheng Likuan, published in Welding Technology in 1996, describes the application of a pre-deformation method to control the distortion in tube sheet surfacing. The authors are from the Changzhou Chemical Machinery Factory, which is a manufacturer of pressure vessels and heat exchangers. Their experience is directly relevant to anyone who is involved in the fabrication of tube sheets.

The pre-deformation method is a simple but effective technique. Before the surfacing is started, the tube sheet is bent in the opposite direction to the expected distortion. The pre-bending is done by placing the tube sheet on a support and applying a force to the center. The pre-bending is calculated to be equal to the expected distortion, so that when the surfacing is complete and the tube sheet has cooled, it will be flat.

2. Analysis of the Distortion Mechanism

The paper provides a qualitative analysis of the distortion mechanism. The authors explain that the distortion is caused by the difference in the coefficient of thermal expansion between the surfacing layer and the base metal. The surfacing layer, which is typically austenitic stainless steel, has a higher coefficient of thermal expansion than the base metal, which is typically carbon steel or low-alloy steel. When the surfacing layer cools, it contracts more than the base metal, and this causes the tube sheet to bend.

The magnitude of the distortion depends on several factors:

  1. The thickness of the surfacing layer. A thicker surfacing layer causes more distortion.
  2. The thickness of the tube sheet. A thinner tube sheet is more susceptible to distortion.
  3. The diameter of the tube sheet. A larger diameter tube sheet has a larger moment arm, and therefore more distortion.
  4. The welding process. A higher heat input causes more distortion.
  5. The welding sequence. The distortion can be controlled by the sequence of the welding passes.

The authors also note that the distortion is not uniform. The center of the tube sheet is the most affected, because the center is the farthest from the edges. The distortion is a "pot-bottom" shape, where the center is lower than the edges. The amount of distortion can be measured by placing a straight edge across the tube sheet and measuring the gap at the center.

3. The Pre-Deformation Method: Procedure and Parameters

The pre-deformation method is a two-step process. The first step is to determine the amount of pre-deformation. The second step is to apply the pre-deformation and then perform the surfacing.

3.1 Determining the Pre-Deformation Amount

The pre-deformation amount must be determined by calculation or by trial and error. The authors recommend a trial and error approach, where a test piece is made, and the distortion is measured. The pre-deformation amount is then adjusted until the final distortion is within the acceptable tolerance.

The pre-deformation amount depends on the diameter of the tube sheet, the thickness of the tube sheet, and the thickness of the surfacing layer. As a general rule, the pre-deformation amount is equal to the expected distortion. The expected distortion can be estimated using the following formula:

δ = (αs - αb) × ΔT × t / (2 × D)

Where:

This formula is an approximation, and it does not account for the stiffness of the tube sheet. In practice, the pre-deformation amount is determined by trial and error.