SMAW Surfacing with Self-Fluxing Alloy Composite Powders on Q235 Steel
Literature Overview and Core Findings
Zhang Yong and Qi Xiuling from Liaoning Technical University investigated the effect of adding self-fluxing alloy powders to the coating of shielded metal arc welding electrodes for hardfacing on Q235 steel. The work compares three powder systems — iron-based, iron-nickel mixed, and nickel-based self-fluxing alloys — and evaluates their influence on hardness and wear resistance of the resulting surfacing layer. This is a practical approach to improving hardfacing performance without changing the welding process, which makes it directly applicable to shop floor operations where process changes are costly and time-consuming.
The key findings are straightforward but significant: adding iron-based or iron-nickel mixed self-fluxing powders increases the hardness of the surfacing layer, and the hardness and wear resistance improve with increasing powder addition. The iron-nickel and nickel-based composite powders provide better strengthening than iron-based powders alone. This suggests that the nickel content in the powder plays a critical role in the hardening mechanism.
Powder System Analysis
Composition and Function
Self-fluxing alloys are characterized by their ability to form a protective oxide layer during deposition, which prevents oxidation of the molten pool and promotes good wetting and bonding with the substrate. The typical composition includes silicon and boron as fluxing elements, along with nickel, chromium, and iron as the primary alloying elements. When these powders are added to the electrode coating, they are transferred to the weld pool during the arc welding process and become part of the deposited metal.
| Powder System | Primary Composition | Hardening Mechanism |
|---|---|---|
| Iron-based | Fe-Cr-Si-B | Boride and carbide precipitation |
| Iron-nickel mixed | Fe-Ni-Cr-Si-B | Combined boride and intermetallic strengthening |
| Nickel-based | Ni-Cr-Si-B | Ni3B, Ni3Si, and chromium boride precipitation |
Transfer Efficiency
The transfer efficiency of powders from the electrode coating to the weld pool is a critical factor that is not always appreciated. In SMAW, the coating melts and transfers to the pool along with the core wire, but the powder particles may not fully dissolve or may be lost as spatter. The authors' results indicate that the powders are effectively transferred and incorporated into the deposit, since the hardness increases are consistent and reproducible. However, the exact transfer efficiency is not quantified in the paper, which leaves some uncertainty about the actual composition of the deposited layer.
Hardness and Wear Behavior
Hardness Improvement
The hardness measurements show a clear trend of increasing hardness with powder addition. The base Q235 steel has a hardness of approximately 120-140 HV, while the hardfacing layer without powder addition achieves around 200-250 HV. With the addition of self-fluxing powders, hardness values increase to 300-400 HV depending on the powder type and quantity. The nickel-based powder provides the highest hardness, followed by the iron-nickel mixed powder, with the iron-based powder being the least effective.
Wear Resistance Correlation
The wear test results correlate well with the hardness data. Higher hardness corresponds to lower weight loss in the wear test, confirming that the hardening mechanism is effective in improving wear resistance. The nickel-based composite powder provides the best wear resistance, which is consistent with its highest hardness. The improvement in wear resistance is not linear with hardness, however — the nickel-based powder shows a disproportionately large improvement, suggesting that the microstructure plays a role beyond simple hardness.
Microstructural Observations
Matrix Structure
The metallographic examination reveals that the surfacing layer consists of a matrix with dispersed hard phases. The iron-based powder produces a structure with chromium borides and carbides distributed in a ferritic or martensitic matrix. The iron-nickel mixed powder produces a more complex structure with both borides and intermetallic compounds. The nickel-based powder produces a structure with fine, uniformly distributed hard phases in a nickel-rich matrix, which provides both hardness and toughness.
Dilution Effects
Dilution from the Q235 substrate is a significant factor in SMAW hardfacing. The first layer typically has 20-30% dilution, which reduces the alloy content and hardness of the deposit. The authors' results suggest that the powder addition compensates for this dilution by increasing the alloy content of the deposit. This is an important practical consideration — if multiple layers are deposited, the dilution decreases with each subsequent layer, and the hardness of the final layer will be higher than the first layer.
Practical Application Considerations
Process Parameter Optimization
The addition of powders to the electrode coating affects the arc characteristics and deposition rate. The powders may increase the viscosity of the molten pool, which can affect bead shape and penetration. The welding parameters must be adjusted to maintain good bead appearance and fusion. In practice, this means that the welding current and voltage may need to be increased slightly to compensate for the higher melting point of the alloy powders.
Cost and Availability
The cost of self-fluxing alloy powders is significantly higher than conventional electrode coatings. The economic justification depends on the application — if the hardfacing layer is expected to provide a substantial increase in service life, the additional cost is easily recovered. However, for applications where the wear rate is not the limiting factor, the additional cost may not be justified.
Quality Control Considerations
The consistency of powder addition is critical for maintaining uniform hardness and wear resistance across the surfacing layer. Variations in powder content from one electrode to another can produce inconsistent results. This is a particular concern in manual welding operations where electrodes are produced in batches and the powder content may vary between batches. The fabricator must have a robust quality control system to ensure that the powder addition is consistent.
Study Insights and Reflections
The approach described in this paper is a practical solution to a common problem — how to improve the wear resistance of a hardfacing layer without changing the welding process. The use of self-fluxing alloy powders in the electrode coating is a clever way to introduce alloying elements into the deposit without the need for special welding wires or processes. This is particularly valuable for field welding applications where the use of specialized equipment is not practical.
The finding that nickel-based powders provide better strengthening than iron-based powders is consistent with the metallurgy of these systems. Nickel provides solid solution strengthening and promotes the formation of intermetallic compounds that are harder and more stable than iron-based borides. However, the cost of nickel-based powders is higher, so the selection must be based on the specific application requirements.
Reference Value and Outlook
This work provides a useful reference for hardfacing applications where SMAW is the preferred process. The data on hardness and wear resistance for different powder systems is directly applicable to process selection. Future work should investigate the effect of powder addition on other properties such as impact toughness and corrosion resistance, which are important for many applications. The approach could also be extended to other welding processes such as gas metal arc welding and flux-cored arc welding, where the powders could be added to the flux core.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd