ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Repair Welding of Hard Alloy Surfacing Layer on Mixing Chamber

Literature Overview and Core Findings

Li Xuean from Yiyang Rubber Machinery Factory addresses a challenging repair problem: the repair welding of a cracked hard alloy surfacing layer on the mixing chamber of an internal mixer used in rubber processing. The component is a complex assembly made of 20Mn steel with an internal surface that has been surfaced with a 5mm-thick wear-resistant and corrosion-resistant hard alloy layer with a hardness of HRC 56-60. The high hardness, low ductility, and high brittleness of the surfacing layer make repair welding extremely difficult.

The paper presents a practical approach to this repair problem, drawing on the author's experience in the rubber machinery industry. The key insight is that the repair must be planned carefully, with attention to the specific characteristics of the hard alloy material and the constraints imposed by the component geometry.

Component and Defect Analysis

Component Description

The mixing chamber is a complex welded assembly consisting of an inner sleeve, a wear-resistant liner plate, several rib plates, and three wall plates. The overall dimensions are 889mm × 590mm × 1000mm. The material is 20Mn, which is a low-alloy steel with good weldability and moderate strength. The internal surface of the inner sleeve is surfaced with a 5mm-thick hard alloy layer to provide wear and corrosion resistance.

Defect Characteristics

The defect that requires repair is a crack in the hard alloy surfacing layer. The crack may have been caused by thermal fatigue, mechanical stress, or a combination of both. The high hardness and low ductility of the hard alloy make it susceptible to cracking, particularly when subjected to thermal cycling or mechanical impact. The crack may propagate through the surfacing layer and into the base metal, which complicates the repair.

Defect Type Location Severity Repair Difficulty
Surface crack Surfacing layer Low Moderate
Through-thickness crack Surfacing layer + base metal High High
Delamination Interface High Very high

Repair Welding Challenges

Material Compatibility

The hard alloy surfacing material is a nickel-based or cobalt-based alloy with high hardness and low ductility. The repair welding material must be compatible with both the hard alloy and the 20Mn base metal. The selection of the repair material is critical — if the material is too hard, it may crack during cooling; if it is too soft, it may not provide adequate wear resistance.

Preheat and Interpass Temperature

The high hardness and low ductility of the hard alloy make it susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking. Preheating is required to reduce the cooling rate and minimize the risk of cracking. The preheat temperature must be high enough to ensure that the repair weld cools slowly, but not so high that it causes distortion or metallurgical damage to the base metal.

Welding Process Selection

The repair welding process must be selected based on the accessibility of the defect and the required deposit properties. Gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW) provides good control and low heat input, which is beneficial for minimizing distortion. Shielded metal arc welding (SMAW) is more practical for larger repairs and provides higher deposition rates. The choice depends on the specific repair situation.

Pre-weld Preparation

Defect Removal

The crack must be completely removed before repair welding. This is typically done by grinding or machining, with the extent of the removal verified by dye penetrant testing or magnetic particle inspection. The removal must be complete to prevent the crack from propagating during or after the repair.

Surface Preparation

The surfaces to be welded must be clean and free of contaminants. The hard alloy surface may have a hardened layer that must be removed by grinding or machining. The base metal surface must be prepared to a clean, bright condition to ensure good fusion.

Bevel Design

The bevel design must provide good access for the welding torch and ensure complete fusion. For a repair weld, a U or J bevel is often preferred to minimize the weld volume and reduce distortion. The bevel angle should be sufficient to allow the welding torch to reach the root of the bevel.

Welding Process Development

Filler Material Selection

The filler material for the repair must be compatible with both the hard alloy and the base metal. A nickel-based filler is often used for repairing hard alloy surfacing layers, because nickel provides good compatibility with both materials. The filler should have a hardness that is between the hardness of the hard alloy and the base metal, to provide a gradual transition in properties.

Welding Parameters

The welding parameters must be optimized to achieve good fusion and minimize the risk of cracking. The heat input should be controlled to ensure that the cooling rate is slow enough to prevent hydrogen-induced cracking, but not so slow that it causes excessive distortion. The interpass temperature must be maintained within a specified range to ensure consistent deposit properties.

Post-weld Heat Treatment

A post-weld heat treatment may be required to relieve residual stresses and reduce the risk of cracking. The heat treatment temperature and time must be selected based on the material properties and the component geometry. For the hard alloy surfacing layer, the heat treatment temperature should be below the temperature at which the hard alloy properties begin to degrade.

Post-weld Inspection and Validation

Non-destructive Testing

The repaired area must be inspected to verify that the crack has been completely removed and that the repair weld is sound. Dye penetrant testing or magnetic particle inspection is used to detect surface defects. Radiographic testing or ultrasonic testing may be used to detect internal defects.

Hardness Testing

The hardness of the repair weld must be checked to ensure that it meets the required specification. The hardness should be measured at several locations across the repair to verify consistency. If the hardness is too high, the repair may be susceptible to cracking; if it is too low, the repair may not provide adequate wear resistance.

Dimensional Verification

The dimensions of the repaired area must be verified to ensure that the component meets the required tolerances. The repair may require machining to restore the original dimensions and surface finish.

Study Insights and Reflections

The repair welding of hard alloy surfacing layers is one of the most challenging tasks in the welding industry. The high hardness, low ductility, and high brittleness of the material make it extremely susceptible to cracking, and the repair must be planned and executed with great care. The paper provides a practical approach that is based on the author's extensive experience in the rubber machinery industry, and the lessons learned are applicable to many other industries.

The key insight is that the repair must be approached systematically, with attention to every detail of the process. The defect must be completely removed, the surfaces must be properly prepared, the welding parameters must be optimized, and the repair must be thoroughly inspected. Any shortcut in the process is likely to result in a premature failure of the repair.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable reference for welding engineers and maintenance personnel who are responsible for the repair of hard alloy surfacing layers. The practical guidance on material selection, welding parameters, and inspection is directly applicable to many repair situations. Future work should include experimental data on the repair welding of different hard alloy materials and the development of more robust repair procedures.