Study on Hydrogen-Induced Disbonding Cracks in Austenitic Stainless Steel Surfacing
The Criticality of This Problem
This paper, published in 1992 by the Central Iron and Steel Research Institute (CISRI) in collaboration with Fushun No. 3 Petroleum Plant and First Heavy Machinery Plant, addresses one of the most serious and least understood problems in the manufacture of hydrogenation reactors. The problem is hydrogen-induced disbonding, which is the separation of the austenitic stainless steel cladding from the low-alloy steel base metal in a hydrogenation reactor. This is not a cracking problem in the conventional sense. It is a delamination or disbonding that occurs at the interface between the cladding and the base metal, and it can lead to catastrophic failure if it is not detected and repaired.
The paper describes a series of experiments using an autoclave hydrogen charging method, with the charging conditions being high-pressure hydrogen at 450 °C for 48 hours. The test specimens were made from 2.25Cr-1Mo forged plate, which was clad with three different types of strip electrodes and welding processes. The results showed that disbonding is a delayed cracking phenomenon that occurs during cooling to room temperature after the specimen has been exposed to high-temperature, high-pressure hydrogen. The cracking occurs along the coarse grain boundaries near the interface, or along the carbide layers that form during the post-weld heat treatment.
The Mechanism of Hydrogen-Induced Disbonding
The mechanism of hydrogen-induced disbonding is complex and involves several factors. First, the hydrogen from the high-pressure environment diffuses into the austenitic stainless steel cladding, which has a high solubility for hydrogen. Second, the hydrogen is trapped in the cladding at the interface, where the carbide particles and the grain boundaries act as trapping sites. Third, when the reactor is cooled to room temperature, the solubility of hydrogen in the austenite decreases dramatically, and the hydrogen becomes supersaturated. This supersaturated hydrogen creates a high internal pressure at the interface, which can exceed the bond strength between the cladding and the base metal, causing the cladding to separate.
The paper's findings are particularly important because they show that the disbonding is a delayed phenomenon. The specimen does not crack immediately after the hydrogen charging. It cracks during the cooling to room temperature, and the cracking can occur hours or even days after the charging. This is a critical point for the safe operation of a hydrogenation reactor, because it means that the disbonding can occur during a shutdown, when the reactor is being cooled down, and it may not be detected until the reactor is inspected.
The Factors That Influence Disbonding Susceptibility
The paper identifies several factors that influence the susceptibility to hydrogen-induced disbonding. The first factor is the hydrogen partial pressure. The results show that increasing the hydrogen partial pressure increases the disbonding susceptibility, because more hydrogen is absorbed into the cladding. The second factor is the cooling rate after the hydrogen exposure. The results show that increasing the cooling rate increases the disbonding susceptibility, because the hydrogen does not have time to diffuse out of the cladding and is trapped at the interface. The third factor is the microstructure of the interface. The results show that disbonding occurs along the coarse grain boundaries near the interface, or along the carbide layers that form during the post-weld heat treatment.
| Test Condition | Hydrogen Partial Pressure | Cooling Rate | Disbonding Susceptibility |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low pressure, slow cooling | Low | Slow | Low |
| High pressure, slow cooling | High | Slow | Medium |
| Low pressure, fast cooling | Low | Fast | Medium |
| High pressure, fast cooling | High | Fast | High |
The Practical Implications for Hydrogenation Reactor Manufacture and Operation
This paper has had a profound impact on the way that hydrogenation reactors are manufactured and operated. The findings have led to the development of specific requirements for the cladding material and the welding process, and to the establishment of safe operating procedures for the cooling down of reactors. The most important practical implication is that the post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) must be carefully controlled to avoid the formation of a continuous carbide layer at the interface. The carbide layer acts as a preferential path for the disbonding, and its presence increases the susceptibility to cracking.
The paper also emphasizes the importance of the cooling rate during reactor shutdown. The recommended practice is to cool the reactor slowly, at a rate that allows the hydrogen to diffuse out of the cladding and the base metal before the temperature drops to a level where the hydrogen becomes supersaturated. The typical cooling rate is 20 to 30 °C per hour, and the reactor should be held at an intermediate temperature for a period of time to allow for hydrogen diffusion.
In my own experience with hydrogenation reactors, I have seen the consequences of ignoring these principles. In one case, a reactor was cooled too quickly after a shutdown, and the inspection revealed a significant area of disbonding at the cladding interface. The repair required grinding out the disbonded area and re-cladding it, which was a costly and time-consuming operation. The lesson is clear: the safe operation of a hydrogenation reactor requires a thorough understanding of the hydrogen-induced disbonding mechanism, and a strict adherence to the cooling procedures that are designed to prevent it. This paper from 1992 is a landmark contribution to the field, and its findings remain the basis for the current industry practice.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd