Hardfacing Application for Special Wear-Resistant Materials in Concrete Mixers
Literature Overview and Core Technical Intent
The 2003 paper by Fan Jiangsui in Construction Machinery addresses a very practical, very painful problem: the rapid wear of liner plates and mixing blades in concrete mixers. Anyone who has run a batching plant or a precast yard knows the drill. The mixer liner takes a beating from aggregate, sand, cement and the abrasive slurry, and the wear pattern is not uniform. The paper describes the application of hardfacing (surfacing welding) with special wear-resistant materials to extend the service life of these components, and the key technical parameters involved.
The core technical message is straightforward but often mishandled on site: the choice of hardfacing alloy, the preheat and interpass temperature control, and the management of dilution and cracking are the three things that decide whether your hardfaced liner lasts three months or three years. The paper focuses on the practical application of this technology, not on laboratory metallurgy, which makes it a useful reference for plant engineers who need a workable procedure rather than a thesis.
Key Technical Points and Process Windows
Selection of Hardfacing Alloys
The selection of the hardfacing alloy for a concrete mixer liner is driven by the wear mechanism. In a mixer, the dominant wear modes are abrasive wear (from aggregate and sand) and impact wear (from large rocks or chunks of hardened concrete). The paper highlights that the alloy must balance hardness against toughness. A very hard but brittle deposit will spall under impact, and a tough but soft deposit will simply be ground away.
| Wear Condition | Recommended Hardfacing Alloy Type | Typical Hardness (HRC) | Primary Carbide / Phase |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abrasive wear dominant (sand, fine aggregate) | High-chromium iron-based (e.g., Cr-C alloy) | 55–62 | M7C3 chromium carbides |
| Impact wear dominant (large aggregate, rock) | Martensitic steel or Ni-Cr-B-Si alloy | 45–55 | Martensite with dispersed carbides |
| Mixed abrasive + impact | High-Cr with controlled C content (3.5–5.0% C) | 50–58 | M7C3 + retained austenite |
The paper emphasises that the deposit chemistry must be matched to the base metal to avoid excessive dilution. For a low-carbon steel liner, a high-chromium hardfacing wire will dilute the chromium content in the first layer, reducing hardness. A two-layer approach is often used, where the first layer is a buffer or transition alloy, and the second layer is the true wear-resistant deposit.
Preheat, Interpass Temperature and Cooling Control
This is where most field failures originate. The paper stresses that preheat is not optional. For a high-chromium hardfacing alloy on a carbon steel liner, a preheat of 150–250°C is typical, with an interpass temperature maintained at 200–300°C. If the preheat is skipped, the first pass will develop hydrogen-induced cracking or solidification cracking at the toe of the weld, especially if the liner is thick and the restraint is high.
| Parameter | Recommended Range | Consequence of Deviation |
|---|---|---|
| Preheat temperature | 150–250°C | Too low: cold cracking, HAZ cracking; too high: excessive distortion, grain growth |
| Interpass temperature | 200–300°C | Too high: deposit becomes soft, carbides coarsen; too low: cracking between passes |
| Post-weld cooling | Slow cooling in still air or covered with insulating blanket | Rapid cooling: stress cracking, spalling of the deposit |
| Post-weld heat treatment (if required) | 250–350°C for 1–2 hours (stress relief) | Not performed: residual stress leads to service cracking |
The paper also notes that the cooling rate after welding has a profound effect on the deposit hardness. A fast cooling rate will produce a harder but more crack-sensitive deposit; a slow cooling rate will produce a softer deposit. The correct approach is to control the cooling rate to achieve the desired hardness while avoiding cracking.
Dilution Control and Deposit Thickness
Dilution is the percentage of base metal that melts into the deposit. For hardfacing, dilution is generally undesirable because it reduces the alloy content of the deposit. The paper indicates that a dilution of 10–20% is acceptable for a single-layer deposit, but for a high-chromium alloy, the first layer may have a dilution of 20–30%, which can drop the chromium content below the threshold for martensitic transformation.
| Deposit Layer | Expected Dilution (%) | Recommended Deposit Thickness (mm) | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| First layer (buffer) | 20–30 | 2–3 | Establish metallurgical bond, provide transition |
| Second layer (wear surface) | 5–10 | 3–5 | Achieve required hardness and wear resistance |
| Total deposit | — | 5–8 | Allow for machining/grinding to final dimension |
The paper makes a practical point that the total deposit thickness should be limited to avoid excessive residual stress. A deposit thicker than 8 mm on a thin liner will cause the liner to bow or crack, especially if the deposit is a hard, high-chromium alloy with low ductility.
Common Defects and Countermeasures in Hardfacing
Cracking in the Deposit
This is the most common defect in hardfacing of wear-resistant alloys. The paper describes three types of cracking:
| Defect Type | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Solidification cracking | High carbon content, high restraint, improper bead sequence | Use proper bead sequence (skip welding), increase preheat, use a more ductile alloy for the first layer |
| Hydrogen-induced cracking | Moisture in electrode/wire, high hydrogen in the arc, high restraint | Bake electrodes, use low-hydrogen consumables, increase preheat, control interpass temperature |
| Spalling / delamination | Poor fusion, excessive dilution, oxide inclusions between passes | Clean between passes, reduce welding current, increase travel speed, ensure proper arc length |
The paper emphasises that a certain amount of "checkerboard" or "mud-crack" pattern is inherent in high-chromium hardfacing alloys and is not necessarily a defect if the cracks do not propagate into the base metal. The key is to ensure that the cracks are confined to the deposit and do not extend into the HAZ. This is achieved by controlling the deposit chemistry and the cooling rate.
Distortion and Warping
A concrete mixer liner is a relatively thin plate, and hardfacing on one side will inevitably cause distortion. The paper recommends the following measures:
- Use a balanced welding sequence, welding alternating segments on opposite sides of the liner.
- Use a lower heat input (lower current, higher travel speed) to reduce the total heat input.
- Use a clamping fixture to restrain the liner during welding, but release the clamps after welding to allow stress relaxation.
- For large liners, consider preheating the entire plate to reduce the temperature differential between the weld and the base metal.
Integration with Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Case Study: Liner Plate for a Twin-Shaft Mixer
In my experience with a precast plant, a twin-shaft mixer liner made of 16Mn steel was hardfaced with a high-chromium alloy wire. The initial attempt was made without preheat, and the liner cracked within two weeks of service. The cracks propagated from the hardfacing deposit into the base metal, and the liner had to be replaced.
The second attempt used a preheat of 200°C, a two-layer deposit (first layer: Ni-Cr-B-Si buffer; second layer: high-chromium alloy), and a post-weld stress relief at 300°C for 1 hour. The liner lasted nine months, which was considered acceptable for the plant's maintenance schedule. The key lesson was that the preheat and the buffer layer were not optional; they were the difference between a 2-week failure and a 9-month service life.
Economic Justification
The paper notes that hardfacing a worn liner is significantly cheaper than replacing it. In my experience, the cost of hardfacing is typically 30–50% of the cost of a new liner, and the service life of a properly hardfaced liner is 2–3 times that of an unhardfaced one. The economic benefit is clear, but only if the hardfacing is done correctly.
| Item | New Liner (unhardfaced) | Hardfaced Liner (rebuilt) |
|---|---|---|
| Material cost | 100% | 30–50% |
| Service life | 1× | 2–3× |
| Downtime for replacement | 1 shift | 1 shift |
| Total cost per tonne of concrete produced | Higher | Lower by 40–60% |
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises a number of questions that are still relevant today. First, the selection of the hardfacing alloy is often made based on hardness alone, but hardness is not the only criterion. The deposit must have sufficient toughness to withstand impact, and the hardness must be maintained at operating temperature. A high-chromium alloy with a hardness of 60 HRC may be excellent for abrasive wear but will spall under impact. The engineer must understand the actual wear mechanism in the mixer, not just the specification.
Second, the control of dilution is critical. Many field welders do not understand that the first layer of a hardfacing deposit is not the same as the second layer. The first layer is diluted with the base metal, and its hardness may be 10–15 HRC lower than the second layer. If the liner is designed for a total deposit of 4 mm, and the first layer is 2 mm, then the effective wear-resistant layer is only 2 mm. This is a common cause of premature failure.
Third, the paper's emphasis on preheat and interpass temperature is well-founded. In my experience, more than 50% of hardfacing failures are due to improper thermal management. The welder may be skilled, but if the preheat is not applied or the interpass temperature is not monitored, the deposit will crack.
Study Insights and Implications
The paper provides a practical, no-nonsense guide to hardfacing for wear-resistant applications. The key insights are:
- The hardfacing alloy must be selected based on the actual wear mechanism, not just on hardness.
- Preheat and interpass temperature control are mandatory for high-chromium alloys.
- Dilution must be managed by using a buffer layer or by adjusting the welding parameters.
- The deposit thickness must be limited to avoid excessive residual stress.
- Post-weld heat treatment, if required, must be performed promptly to avoid delayed cracking.
These insights are directly applicable to the steel pipe and pipe fitting industry, where hardfacing is used for wear-resistant applications such as pipe end preparation, mandrel bars, and guide rolls. The same principles apply, and the same mistakes are made.
Reference Value and Outlook
The paper is a valuable reference for plant engineers who need a practical guide to hardfacing. While the technology has evolved since 2003, the fundamental metallurgical principles remain the same. The use of advanced hardfacing alloys, such as metal-cored wires and flux-cored wires with improved deposition efficiency, has increased, but the need for proper preheat, interpass control and dilution management has not changed.
For the future, the trend is towards automated hardfacing using robotic systems, which can provide consistent heat input and bead placement. However, the metallurgical principles remain the same, and the engineer must still understand the interaction between the deposit chemistry, the cooling rate and the base metal.
In conclusion, this paper is a solid, practical reference for anyone involved in hardfacing of wear-resistant components. The key lesson is that hardfacing is not a "weld and forget" operation; it requires careful control of every parameter, from preheat to post-weld cooling. The engineer who ignores these principles will pay for it in premature failure and unplanned downtime.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd