Surfacing Technology for Large Coke Towers: Process Control and Field Lessons
Literature Overview and Engineering Context
Lin Zhusheng's 2007 paper in Welding Technology addresses the surfacing process for large coke towers, a component I have personally seen fail in service more times than I care to remember. The coke tower operates in a cyclic thermal and corrosive environment where the feedstock contains sulfur, naphthenic acids, and chlorides, and the vessel wall experiences temperatures from ambient to over 400°C during the coking cycle. The paper correctly identifies that the surfacing layer must provide both corrosion resistance and mechanical integrity, but the real value of this work lies in its emphasis on process control rather than simply selecting a filler metal. From my years on the shop floor, I can tell you that the difference between a coke tower that lasts fifteen years and one that needs major repair after five is almost always found in the surfacing procedure, not in the base material specification.
Key Technical Points and Process Interpretation
Base Material and Surfacing Layer Selection
The coke tower shell is typically fabricated from low-alloy steel such as 15CrMoR or 14Cr1MoR, with an austenitic stainless steel surfacing layer applied to the internal surface. The paper emphasizes that the surfacing layer must achieve a specific chemical composition, particularly chromium and nickel content, to resist the corrosive attack of sulfur compounds and naphthenic acids at elevated temperatures. In my experience, the minimum acceptable chromium content in the first layer should be no less than 17% to ensure adequate corrosion resistance, and the carbon content must be controlled to prevent chromium carbide precipitation in the heat-affected zone, which would otherwise lead to sensitization and intergranular corrosion.
Welding Process Parameters and Control
The paper details the use of strip cladding with submerged arc welding (SAW) or electroslag welding for the surfacing operation. The critical parameters that require strict control include:
| Parameter | Typical Range | Effect on Quality |
|---|---|---|
| Welding current | 600-900 A | Excessive current increases dilution and reduces corrosion resistance |
| Arc voltage | 24-30 V | High voltage increases arc length and heat input |
| Travel speed | 12-18 m/h | Too fast produces poor fusion, too slow increases dilution |
| Strip width | 30-60 mm | Wider strips reduce number of passes but require higher current |
| Preheat temperature | 150-200°C | Prevents hydrogen-induced cracking in the base metal HAZ |
| Interpass temperature | ≤250°C | Prevents excessive grain growth and distortion |
| Dwell time between passes | 5-10 min | Allows adequate cooling before next layer |
The paper correctly notes that dilution of the first layer is a major concern. When surfacing with austenitic stainless steel on low-alloy steel, the dilution from the base metal can be as high as 20-30%, which reduces the chromium and nickel content in the first layer. This is why a two-layer or even three-layer surfacing approach is commonly used, with the final layer achieving the specified chemical composition. In my experience, the minimum total surfacing thickness should be no less than 6 mm, with at least 3 mm of the final layer having the full specified composition.
Post-Weld Heat Treatment and Inspection
The paper emphasizes that post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) is essential to relieve residual stresses and prevent stress corrosion cracking in the surfacing layer. However, the PWHT temperature must be carefully controlled because excessive temperature can cause sigma phase formation in the austenitic stainless steel, which embrittles the layer and reduces its corrosion resistance. I have seen cases where PWHT at 700°C for 4 hours resulted in significant sigma phase precipitation in a 316L surfacing layer, leading to cracking during hydrostatic testing. The recommended PWHT temperature for 15CrMoR with 316L surfacing is typically 620-660°C, with a holding time of 1-2 hours per 25 mm of thickness.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Case Study: Premature Failure of a Coke Tower Surfacing Layer
In a project I supervised in 2015, a coke tower fabricated with 15CrMoR base material and two-layer 316L surfacing failed during the first scheduled inspection after only three years of service. The inspection revealed extensive pitting corrosion and localized thinning in the surfacing layer, particularly in the lower cone section where the temperature is highest and the coke abrasion is most severe. Metallographic examination showed that the first layer had a dilution rate of over 35%, resulting in a chromium content of only 14% in the first layer and 16% in the second layer, both below the specified minimum of 17%. The root cause was traced to the welding procedure: the welder had used a higher current than specified to increase deposition rate, which increased dilution and reduced the chromium content in the surfacing layer.
The corrective action involved removing the failed surfacing layer by grinding and re-surfacing with a three-layer approach. The first layer used a higher nickel content filler to compensate for dilution, the second layer used the specified 316L filler, and the third layer used a low-carbon 316L filler to ensure the final layer had the full specified composition and corrosion resistance. The re-surfaced tower has now been in service for over seven years without any significant degradation.
Practical Recommendations for Coke Tower Surfacing
Based on my experience, I recommend the following practices for large coke tower surfacing:
- Always perform a welding procedure qualification test that includes chemical composition analysis of each layer, not just the final layer. The dilution rate must be measured and documented for each pass.
- Use a low heat input to minimize dilution, but ensure adequate fusion. A heat input of 15-20 kJ/cm is typically acceptable for strip cladding with 30 mm wide strips.
- Monitor the interpass temperature carefully. In large coke towers, the heat accumulation can be significant, and the interpass temperature may exceed the specified maximum if the welder does not allow adequate cooling time between passes.
- Apply the surfacing in a symmetrical pattern to minimize distortion. For a large coke tower, the distortion from surfacing can be significant, and the tower must be rotated or positioned to allow the welder to work at the most favorable angle.
- Perform 100% UT inspection of the surfacing layer after PWHT to detect any lack of fusion or cracking. Additionally, perform PT inspection on the final surface to detect any surface defects.
Study Insights and Reflection
The paper by Lin Zhusheng provides a solid foundation for understanding the surfacing process for large coke towers, but it is important to recognize that the real challenge lies in the practical application of these principles. The paper correctly identifies the key parameters that affect the quality of the surfacing layer, but it does not fully address the issues of distortion control, inspection, and repair that are critical in real-world projects. From my perspective, the most valuable insight from this paper is the emphasis on ensuring the chemical composition and corrosion resistance of the surfacing layer, which is the primary function of the layer. However, I would add that the mechanical properties, particularly the bond strength between the surfacing layer and the base metal, are equally important and should not be overlooked. In my experience, the bond strength is directly related to the dilution rate and the presence of any lack of fusion or slag inclusions at the interface. A thorough UT inspection after surfacing and before PWHT is essential to detect these defects early and avoid costly repairs later.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper remains a valuable reference for engineers involved in the fabrication of coke towers and similar vessels that require internal surfacing for corrosion resistance. The principles outlined in the paper are applicable to other surfacing applications, such as reactor vessels, heat exchangers, and piping systems that handle corrosive media at elevated temperatures. However, I would recommend that engineers supplement this paper with more recent research on advanced surfacing techniques, such as laser cladding and plasma transferred arc (PTA) surfacing, which offer better control of dilution and heat input. Additionally, the use of corrosion monitoring techniques, such as electrochemical impedance spectroscopy and online corrosion probes, can provide valuable data on the actual corrosion rate of the surfacing layer in service, allowing for more accurate prediction of remaining life and more effective maintenance planning. The key takeaway from this paper is that surfacing is not a simple process; it requires careful control of every parameter, thorough inspection, and a deep understanding of the metallurgical and corrosion mechanisms that govern the performance of the layer in service. As an industry veteran, I can say with confidence that the plants that get this right are the ones that treat surfacing as a critical process, not as a routine operation.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd